Brandon Will
Footballguy
Who In dynasty non PPR?
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
Dk Metcalf/Miles Sanders (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Brandon Will
- Start date
all things being equal (WR/RB needs are the same, cost of keeping is the same, how long you can keep is the same, etc) I would go with DK Metcalf. I think he is a stud and will be around for longer and has a premier QB throwing to him which will only make him better.
I don't have an issue keeping Sanders but I think he has more chance for injury, competition, etc detracting from his ceiling.
I don't have an issue keeping Sanders but I think he has more chance for injury, competition, etc detracting from his ceiling.
jwsbowler
Footballguy
my question is this... is this a startup or an existing league? If a start up, I am leaning towards Sanders as I find it more of a problem in getting running backs than wide receivers. And, I have Sanders value rated higher that Metcalf. I do agree with Gally to the point that Metcalf would probably get you more years of "usage".
Don't get me wrong, I love both players. If this is an existing league, why would you have to pick between these two, I would be keeping them both. This is why my initial question. Dynasty leagues are keeping full teams, keeper leagues are you have to drop some. Is there some kind of "contract" cost in "keeping" players?.
Don't get me wrong, I love both players. If this is an existing league, why would you have to pick between these two, I would be keeping them both. This is why my initial question. Dynasty leagues are keeping full teams, keeper leagues are you have to drop some. Is there some kind of "contract" cost in "keeping" players?.
Last edited by a moderator:
Brandon Will
Footballguy
20 team dynasty. Start 2 rbs 3wrs
.25 ppr
.25 ppr
Last edited by a moderator:
jwsbowler
Footballguy
Brandon Will
Footballguy
Existing. Going on 19 yearsjwsbowler said:
Wentz
Gurley/Ingram
Hill, Metcalf, Davis, Boykin
OJ, Higbee, Hollister/Dissly
Top 12 pick and 22 overall. Thinking QB at 22.
jwsbowler
Footballguy
So, a dynasty league and you have 11 players? What is the roster size and your entire roster and if any roster limitations, starting lineup requirements? I am assuming normal non PPR scoring even though you mention .25 PPR. What top 12 pick? Drafting all free agents and rookies?Existing. Going on 19 years
Wentz
Gurley/Ingram
Hill, Metcalf, Davis, Boykin
OJ, Higbee, Hollister/Dissly
Top 12 pick and 22 overall. Thinking QB at 22.
and I have to assume you are thinking trade or someone approached you on a trade...
Last edited by a moderator:
Brandon Will
Footballguy
20 team league, 30 players a team. I also have full idp, I was just breaking down the starters in my offense.
It's a deeper league, the question was more if Sanders would outproduce Metcalf in #s, even if it isn't longevity.
fruity pebbles
Footballguy
Sanders.
fightingillini
Footballguy
Sanders over Metcalf. You have two aging RBs in Gurley and Ingram. Sanders is far more valuable to you than Metcalf.
Brandon Will
Footballguy
It's ok! We have a 5-12 lottery for rookies and I am ranked 12 (worst chance of getting 5)
.25 PPR, yes.
I need a young RB to pair with Gurley, seeing Baltimore took Dobbins.
I love what I see out of Sanders, but same with Metcalf. Deep down, for the 20 years this leagues been in, a solid recieving back like that usually leads the way over WRs.
TBBuccs6988
Footballguy
My initial reaction was Miles Sanders. That being said, I still don't understand the question. LOL
Where is Miles Sanders currently? Is this a potential trade? or are you just curious who we like better in general?
Where is Miles Sanders currently? Is this a potential trade? or are you just curious who we like better in general?
Brandon Will
Footballguy
my Uncle owns Sanders. He's rebuilding and needs WR to build around
I know I am against the consensus but I think your RB's are fine for the next 2 years. Philly hasn't proven they will utilize one RB if all are healthy. That scares me. I think Metcalf will be dominant as he grows in his 2nd year. Right now Metcalf is your #2 WR. If you move him you will be hurt more than what Sanders helps you. I also think Metcalf is a guy you can build around. Having Hill and Metcalf for the foreseeable future should give you an advantage. I stay put. I keep shopping for RB help but there are other ways to get it.
