I agree that Ridley and Julio are kind of a wash. I’m sure I could get Ridley for JuJu, but do I really want both ATL receivers?
Conners for Mahomes makes me puke in my mouth a little, but it is what it is
it’s very difficult to get true value for a top tier QB
I'm not completely a believer that Ridley has surpassed Julio as THE WR1 in Atlanta, but it's very close. Julio is no slouch and he's not washed up all of a sudden. He dropped an EZ TD already and if any of those Ridley TDs could have gone to Julio then they're much more even.
Ridley > Julio slightly, so you get an edge there.
Gore is a throw in, completely useless in this trade but wouldn't bat an eye at losing him if the other owner wants him.
Burrow is fairly useless to you since you'd have Wilson. Helps to cover his bye but that's about it.
Conner is fragile and by himself shouldn't be enough to get Mahomes. Any chance he also has Snell to give you with Conner?
This just feels like one of those trades that's made unnecessarily large in order to obscure the other guy's true intentions. He's hoping you're enamored with Ridley's last 2 games, and desperate at RB enough that Conner feels like a big upgrade".
NOW, I say all that to say, it's hard trading a top tier QB and getting good value because it's very rare that other owners have extra RB1's that they can afford to part with. There's a guy in one of my leagues who always always takes two top QBs and holds them as trade bait, and demands high prices, and nobody will trade with him, we just make him eat them both. It's very possible that Conner is as good an offer as you're going to get. I'd shop around before rejecting or pissing this guy off, but in the end I think if no better offers come then I'd probably do this deal now that I think about it more, provided that you get Ridley and only give up some lesser WR than Julio.