What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Recent content by 30 Rock

  1. 3

    Hines Ward Blasts NFL Hypocrisy

    The NFL always does what it thinks will bring in the most revenue. It doesn't necessarily care so much about player injuries unless it affects the quality of the game or draws too much criticism (because that could have a negative effect on revenues). The players always do what they think will...
  2. 3

    are the dynasty rankings ever going to get updated?

    Besides SSOG and Go Deep dynasty rankings, are there any up-to-date rankings anywhere (FBG or beyond)?
  3. 3

    Vick the Best Player in the NFL?

    My job is not to make accurate statements, but rather make controversial statements to put my name in the headlines and generate traffic for my employer's various media outlets. Thanks for playing.Sincerely,Wilbon
  4. 3

    The Weight Gain or Weight Loss Thread For Players

    What does that mean? Did he gain a lot of weight in the offseason because he has poor work ethic?
  5. 3

    Sam Bradford Pro Day

    Aikman only had one season where he threw for more than 20 touchdowns. Would you be excited if I said Ryan Matthews had the best workout since Rudi Johnson?
  6. 3

    Javon Walker

    That's not really fair to JaMarcus Russell.
  7. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    Consistency based on flawed logic is not good enough when there are other consistent solutions that make more sense.
  8. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    The scenario you describe is a major flaw in fantasy football scoring as far as I'm concerned. It does not justify acceptance of other flawed scoring.
  9. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    Why is that any more true than the following statement?If, at any point during the play, you are attacking your opponents end zone, you are the offense. If at some point during the play, you are attacking your opponents end zone, and you end up scoring, it should be an offensive touchdown.
  10. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    The explanation from Fantasy Commissioner makes the most sense to me. It explains why they don't award the Saints D with a score and it explains why the Saints do get credit for a fumble recovery. link: http://www.webleaguemanager.com/faq-stats.html#s16 A player on Team B intercepted a pass...
  11. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    Also add Fantasy Commissioner to the first category (offensive fumble recovery TD for the player, not the Saints D).http://www.webleaguemanager.com/faq-stats.html#s16
  12. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    Does anyone have a summary of how various sites like Yahoo, ESPN, MFL, etc., are scoring this play? I have been searching and can't find anything.
  13. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    1. Seems consistent to me.2. If your league allows defensive touchdowns, as does mine, then this is inconsistent.3. You explanation makes no sense. Immediately after the second turnover the Saints gained possession of the ball and were therefore on offense, meaning Meachem scored an offensive...
  14. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    Maybe I wasn't clear. The only consistent way to look at this is to say the offense is always the offense and the defense is always the defense. Meacham was on the field as an offensive player and therefore gets credit for an offensive touchdown. When you start trying to say that the offense...
  15. 3

    A Ruling On The Robert Meachem Play

    If you're going to awards points for the Saints D then your logic would have to be that once the Redskins obtained possession of the ball the Redskins became the offense and the Saints became the defense. However, carrying that logic through, wouldn't you then have to say that once Meacham got...
Back
Top