Recent content by dntpanic

Thats the feedback I was looking for thanks.  I would say the difference here was no feedback was requested by the commissioner and the idea of a vote was pushed on pretty hard until multiple people in the league complained.  I would also note this is a very high cost winner take all league...

Agree entirely, but this year with the rule change I do think having good backups becomes more critical.  You get by byes and now potential cancels.  Seems were split 50/50 in the voting which basically reflects how difficult this one is.  Thanks for the feedback.

Thanks.  Agree a vote is at least the best way of doing things.

Glad Im not in your league.  It would appear having a concern would make one a whiner.  Fun.

No I do, I just was looking for actual feedback, like your last post.

So in this instance, why would you look at this differently then a MNF game with a questionable player?  The only real difference is the number of players impacted, but if that is from your side worth the mid season rule change I get it.

Wow.  Ok man, this is a fantasy football forum, so I am looking for expertise here.  Further, to make this statement is pure ignorance.  You have no idea what the stakes are, etc.  In fact they are quite substantial (5 figures), so mid season rule changes tend to raise eyebrows.  I have for what...

I was definitely picking players who had premium position over premium ability yes (as have many)

As I said before, your position was noted.  8-4

I get it, you don't think there is an issue.  Thanks for your feedback.  Youre losing 6-4 in the vote

The point is I would have added more quality players previously.  Those players that did, now have an advantage.  

They are not available in numbers enough for everyone to roster a backup.  When not in demand this is not an issue, now it is.  Those that did roster the 2nd player have a substantial advantage.

It was the example he cited in making the rule.  I dont think he changed the rule to solely benefit himself, but I would be remiss to acknowledge the rule helps him alot this week.  

No.  Backup QBs and TEs up until this rule change are generally very available in my league as they are used only one (the bye week).   This rule change puts a premium on them.

Ours made the same rule. This placekeeper for a backup rule was not added at the time.