Recent content by Dungeon Master

Yes

Jordan Lyles

Did Buxton get hurt?

Without looking too deeply, Carew probably would have been ahead of Chipper and behind Brett. 

Used to buy on every few years. Then I got the Bill James Baseball extract and when I needed a nerd fix I just re-read that, but the encyclopedia was always close at hand. 

BEST INFIELDER: I looked at MVPs, WAR, Gold Gloves, Career OPS+, Peak performance, and four stats from baseball-reference: Black Ink (how many times led the league in something), Grey Ink (how many times in the top 10 in something), HOF Standards (an all encompassing look at stats and assessing...

pass

I'm about 2/3 of the way through best infielder.  Do we need any judges to step in for baseball or basketball? I can take 'em. 

Robin Yount should be ashamed of himself. .236/.311/.348.  This why everyone hates Wisconsin. 

This should be unanimous. 

It's more like paying in for a random portion of a box, either by team or by last name, for a shot at big money cards without paying for the entire box. What you're describing happens too, but its' dumb. 

Both Lucas and Hayes would have ranked above Rodman. Not sure exactly where they'd land, but I don't have to rank them since I'm done.

I agree, Honus and Lajoie are just too old to rank well. 

I love the guy and was a big fan, and he was no doubt a wizard with the glove, but he shouldn't have been drafted.  I'm not so sure on Brooks either, although he is an all time fave of mine. 

What was the reasoning behind splitting up greatest baseball player, greatest outfielder, and greatest infielder? Am I supposed to judge infielder by their fielding ability, or is Ozzie Smith a terrible pick?