Recent content by mgillig5

The first offer was better. Rashad Jennings is horribly inefficient, to the point that they tried giving the job (unsuccessfully) to Paul Perkins last week. It's really tough, because Roethlisberger has a bad weather matchup with very strong winds this week. Odds are, he won't play well...

I don't want to take credit for somebody else's answer, but I honestly think this is right on the nose. He's 100% right. To add to it, Maclin is out this week. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

I agree. A sure number 1 receiver in Steve Smith has a safer weekly floor than Percy Harvin. They pulled him out of retirement because they needed depth. I'd rather start Woods tbh. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

Jordan Matthews is the play, Seattle has been getting burnt with slot receivers all season and he's gonna get at least 9 targets. The other two have shaky floors imo. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

I go Prosise and Gio for the best floors. Hurns has great upside with Slay on A Rob though. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

I'd go Hyde. Both have poor matchups, but with Cam Chancellor back, I wouldn't play any Philly RBs. Hyde will at least get open in some space against NE. Answer mine? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

I think Rodulph will have lots of targets with Diggs up against Pat Pete. If he catches half, he's good. That's my pick. Help me? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

Idts to either. Next year's draft is full of RB talent. You can't know the future of either backfield yet https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

You have the RB1. Unless you get an offer that's such a no brainer you instant accept, don't do it. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

No way. Starks will probably split carried and even then isn't very good. With no Alshon, Meredith should get at least 8 targets. I like his floor better. Help me? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

Alshon's suspension hurt me too. I think that having AB and Julio is something you can't turn down. You have decent RBs behind McCoy, and J Stew's playoff schedule is great. I say do it. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

I like Bennett, but there's a solid chance that the Pats run the ball a lot. Eiffert has touchdown upside. It's a coin flip with no wrong answer. Bennett has the better floor. Help me? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

Which one doesn't face Patrick Peterson? Larry Fitz all day. https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/

Kenneth Dixon only received 10 fewer snaps than Terrence West last week (who was awful), and caught a pass on 47.1% of his routes. I see him taking over in the next two weeks, which makes him an asset. Coleman is the next best option. Do NOT drop Lewis or White yet. There's no way to know...

I think Thomas is the right choice, but keep in mind that with Pat Pete covering Diggs, Rudolph may have a high volume of targets. Answer mine? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751495-trade-edelman-and-giodixon-for-brate-and-ingram/