Jonesin For Some Football

12 team, .5 PPR, 1 QB league. This just happened and I don't like it at all. Same person that made the Chubb trade above got Henry here: Derrick Henry and 2022 2nd (late) for Antonio Gibson and Chris Godwin Am I way undervaluing Gibson here as I think this is a horribly uneven trade?

12 team, .5 PPR, 1 QB league. Two trades I wasn't involved in: Nick Chubb, Jalen Hurts, 2022 3rd for Khalil Herbert, Damien Harris, Mike Gesicki, 22 1st (for sure top 6) and Darren Waller for Josh Jacobs, Hunter Henry, Rashad Bateman

3 1sts seems close to about right but at least one of them has to be early (preferably 2 of them). We had Cook go for 4 1sts before the season. 3 seems about right. I'd have done this if I was trying to compete.

With Dobbins injury and Philly refusing to use Sanders, I feel this was a steal.

YOu and me both. Kupp side by a mile.

Williams makes this 4 1sts and a 2nd for those Zeke, MT, and Williams. I like those players higher than most but this is a great return for a rebuilding team.

It is funny people are on the J-Will side here. If you go back just a couple of weeks before the season started, this board seemed way too high on Aiyuk. I'm a Niners fan and I didn't understand the optimism here. I'd take Williams easily and enjoy seeing people come back to Earth a bit.

I like this trade and could see both sides. I'd go King Henry and Hock personally and I like Barkley.

I would say this might be a touch light if Zeke is at the top of his game but we haven't seen that in a long time. As of right now, I think that was a good move and waiting could cause his value to sink dramatically.

I'm pretty sure I'd take CEH in the first one just on upside alone. I think Barkley bounces back but I love McLaurin and Sanders is a good throw in. I'd probably lean that side but understand taking the chance on Barkley.

I'd take a 1st and a 3rd for Winston in SF if I was ok at QB or rebuilding for sure.

I don't disagree with what you were doing at all. Just felt you could have got more but every league is different.

I don't play any TE Premium but Hill, Evans, and 2 1sts seems like a ton to pay for Brown and Kittle even though I like both of them. Think I lean that way but TE Premium definitely makes it closer even with Kittle not looking elite yet.

I totally agree that this is a lot for Barkley. However, as a Saquon owner, selling for less than this is a sell low and I'd rather wait it out to see if the dude can get right than take a small package for a possible stud. Its a gamble but I'd rather the high reward even if it comes with higher risk.

I totally get what you were trying to do there but that feels light to me when including A-Rod/Chubb. Like another 1st light. I don't give much value to Tua at all (but you needed another QB with Wentz as your other guy), Ertz has almost no value, and Reagor just above Marvin Jones due to age. CEH is the only real asset outside that 1st for me. Some of the others like the 3rd or Reagor could be decent but not with what you gave up.