Dynasty Rankings in The Shark Pool (NFL Talk) Posted December 9, 2012 · Edited December 9, 2012 by SSOG Just for funsies:1. Rice2. Richardson3. Peterson4. McCoy5. Martin6. Charles7. Spiller8. Foster9. Forte10. Mathews11. LynchThat's a rough first pass, and I'm not sure how I feel about it yet. Anything stand out as particularly glaring?I like Matthews' talent (and I'm an owner in several leagues), but I just can't see having him above Lynch at this point. Yes, SD is a mess in general now, but Matthews also hasn't impressed me on the field this year. And on the injury front, it's been one thing after another.Lynch is only 18 months older than Matthews (he'll be 27 next April, while Matthews will be 26 next Oct), has been extremely productive, is on a team that will ride him and looks on the upswing, and despite one of the heaviest workloads over the last two years has actually held up and looked good under the load.Lynch runs too hot and cold for me, from carry to carry, week to week, and season to season. I also don't think he's as talented as his numbers. I think he is now what he has always been his entire career- a solid if unspectacular back capable of putting up great volume stats when given a chance. I think a lot of people forgot that's what he was and had him too low earlier in his career. I think a lot of people are forgetting that's what he is and have him too high today. As for Mathews... the talent is there. The production is there. So far, the health isn't there, and the situation isn't there. I'm happy to bet on his health and situation being short term setbacks, because I think he's one of the 5 most talented backs in the league 25 and under. People are too quick to bury young backs who hit a rough patch. Ironically, your guy Lynch is the poster boy for this phenomenon. There was a reason Mathews was a consensus top5 dynasty back before the season.Edit: completely honestly, what's the difference between Lynch and Chris Ivory, other than the fact that one of them gets a workhorse workload and the other doesn't?