14/15 Inter-Class Rookie Rankings (1 Viewer)

[Concept Coop]

Another conversation sparked this exercise--thought it would be interesting to see how others would break it down. 2015 prospects are valued as of today. 2014 prospects are valued as of their draft.

Based on this, I think 2015 is a big step above the 2014 class, around this time last year.

1. Gurley

2. Gordon

Gurley/Gordon are the clear top 2. They are in top 5 dynasty RB conversation--a lot more value than Sammy/Evans looked to offer.

3. Sammy Watkins

4. Mike Evans

High level WR prospects worthy of top 3-4 picks most years.

5. Amari Cooper

Step below Watkins/Evans; step above White/Parker/Cooks Could slip to below tier; unlikely to join above.

6. Kevin White

7. DeVante Parker

8. Brandin Cooks

White/Parker's prototypical size just beat out Cook's plus situation.

9. Eric Ebron

Ebron was a special prospect at TE and was drafted accordingly (NFL and FF).

10. Jay Ajayi

11. Tevin Coleman

12. Jeremy Hill

Very hard for me to break these 3 up. Ajayi/Coleman could both jump Hill by a tier depending on situation; Hill's was a negative at the time.

13. Odell Bekcham Jr.

The NFL liked him more than we did. Seemed to provide a high floor/only solid ceiling at the time.

14. Bishop Sankey

15. Duke Johnson

16. Carlos Hyde

Next tier of RBs. Was worried about Hyde's age following a likely (fantasy) redshirt. Wasn't high on Sankey, but his draft slot/situation was appealing.

17. Dorial Green-Beckham

18. Jaelen Strong

19. Marqise Lee

Was higher than most on Lee at the time, as I am with Strong now. DGB has too much upside to keep slipping.

20. Ameer Abdullah

Likely would have gone Abdullah over the huge WR tier below.

21-25

Benjamin/Funchess/Adams/Matthews/Coates

No point in breaking these up--all right there. I'm assuming Coates goes late 1st after a stupid combine. Otherwise, he'll drop. Liked Matthews/Adams' situations.

26. Austin Stud-Jenkins

27. Tre Mason

Big ASJ fan but he's a TE. Mason looked like a solid back. Liked him enough; situation was a question mark.

28-31

Robinson/Latimer/Smith/Perriman

Another jumble of WRs I don't want to break up. Not especially high on Smith, but there is a lot of 1st round buzz. Hard to drop him lower than this if it proves accurate.

32. Maxx Williams

33. Clive Walford

Like these two more than Amaro.

34. T.J. Yeldon

35. Mike Davis

I think both back have upside, though they didn't live up to past expectations.

Yours?

Edit: Swapped Mariota/Amaro for Yeldon/Davis.

 

[ChuckLiddell]

Did I miss Devonte Freeman, or is he 35+? I think he was valued around or above Jeremy Hill last year, no?

 

[Concept Coop]

Did I miss Devonte Freeman, or is he 35+? I think he was valued around or above Jeremy Hill last year, no?

He didn't make the cut for me. I personally never liked him near Hill.

He would likely go above some of the non-RBs listed within his own class. But the 2015 backs push him way down. There are a few more RBs that would make the cut before him, depending on where they get drafted--Buck, CA-P, Yeldon, Davis, etc.

 

[jtd13]

Didn't like Moncrief much last year?

 

[Concept Coop]

Didn't like Moncrief much last year?

Not enough to crack the list, though I didn't dislike him. He'd certainly be up there now, however, as would M.Bryant.

 

[JohnnyU]

Parker > White

 

[Concept Coop]

Parker > White

I like both guys just about equally and have gone back and forth. Combine/draft spot/team will sort it out soon enough.

 

[Borden]

I can't see Watkins not being in that first tier. He was pretty heavily hyped last year.

 

[Concept Coop]

I can't see Watkins not being in that first tier. He was pretty heavily hyped last year.

I think Sammy could be on a tier of his own at 1.03--and perhaps he should be--but he's closer to Evans than Gordon/Gurley, IMO. In a vacuum, I think you have a very strong argument. But considering positional value--I think the RBs are the obvious choices.

 

[Biabreakable]

This is my 2014 list from last February.

Tier 1 - 1st round rookie pick value

WR Sammy Watkins
WR Mike Evans
RB Bishop Sankey
WR Marqise Lee
RB Carlos Hyde
WR Odell Beckham Jr.
WR Brandin Cooks
TE Eric Ebron
WR Jordan Matthews
WR Davonte Adams


Tier 2 - Potential 1st round rookie pick value in a good situation. 2nd-3rd round value if not.

QB Johnny Manziel
RB Charles Sims
RB Tre Mason
TE Jace Amaro
WR Cody Latimer
WR Kelvin Benjamin
WR Donte Moncrief
RB Lache Seastrunk
QB Teddy Bridgewater
WR Allen Robinson
WR Jarvis Landry
RB Devonta Freeman
QB Blake Bortles
RB Jeremy Hill
QB Jimmy Garoppolo
TE Austin Seferian-Jenkins
QB Derek Carr

Tier 3 - Situation could push these players into the above tier. Otherwise watch list.

RB Isaiah Crowell
RB Terrance West
WR Martavis Bryant
QB Brett Smith
WR Robert Herron
WR Jeff Janis
RB Andre Williams
WR Kevin Norwood
WR Bruce Ellington
WR Dri Archer
RB Jerick McKinnon
RB Damien Williams
WR Shaquelle Evans
RB KaDeem Carey
WR Josh Huff
QB Tajh Boyd
WR Paul Richardson
QB David Fales
WR Jared Abbrederis
RB Storm Johnson
TE A.C Leonard
QB Logan Thomas
WR Brandon Coleman
QB Aaron Murray
WR Matt Hazel
TE Crockett Gillmore
QB Garrett Gilbert
RB Stephen Houston
WR Cody Hoffman
QB Bryn Renner
WR Mike Davis
TE Crockett Gillmore
RB Marion Grice
WR Matt Hazel
TE Colt Lyerla
RB DeAnthony Thomas
TE C.J. Fiedorowicz
WR Michael Campanaro


I do not feel nearly as far along on my research for 2015 as I was at this time last year. There are still I lot of players I need to watch. Most of the players from 2015 I do have ranked are players I have been keeping tabs on for over a year now.

But here is my attempt to match what I know about the 2015 draft class with my 2014 list at around this time of year. I bolded the 2015 players. I consider all players in a tier to be pretty close in value as prospects.


Tier 1 - 1st round rookie pick value

WR Sammy Watkins
WR Mike Evans
RB Melvin Gordon
WR Amari Cooper
WR DeVante Parker
WR Sammie Coates
WR Kevin White
RB Todd Gurley
RB Jay Ajayi
RB Tevin Coleman
RB Bishop Sankey
WR Marqise Lee
RB Carlos Hyde
WR Odell Beckham Jr.
WR Brandin Cooks
TE Eric Ebron
WR Jordan Matthews
WR Davonte Adams


Tier 2 - Potential 1st round rookie pick value in a good situation. 2nd-3rd round value if not.

QB Johnny Manziel
RB Charles Sims
RB Tre Mason
WR Jalen Strong
RB Duke Johnson
WR Dorial Green-Beckham
RB TJ Yeldon
WR/TE Devin Funchess
TE Jace Amaro
WR Cody Latimer
WR Kelvin Benjamin
WR Donte Moncrief
RB Ameer Abdullah
WR Devin Smith
RB Lache Seastrunk
QB Teddy Bridgewater
WR Allen Robinson
WR Jarvis Landry
QB Marcus Mariota
RB Devonta Freeman
QB Blake Bortles
RB Jeremy Hill
QB Jimmy Garoppolo
TE Austin Seferian-Jenkins
QB Derek Carr
TE Maxx Williams
TE Clive Warford
QB Jameis Winston

Tier 3 - Situation could push these players into the above tier. Otherwise watch list.

RB Isaiah Crowell
RB Terrance West
WR Martavis Bryant
RB David Cobb
QB Brett Smith
WR Robert Herron
WR Jeff Janis
RB Andre Williams
WR Kevin Norwood
QB Brett Hundley
WR Bruce Ellington
RB Mike Davis
WR Dri Archer
RB Jerick McKinnon
RB Damien Williams
WR Shaquelle Evans
RB KaDeem Carey
QB Bryce Petty
WR Josh Huff
QB Tajh Boyd
WR Paul Richardson
QB David Fales
WR Jared Abbrederis
RB Storm Johnson
TE A.C Leonard
QB Logan Thomas
WR Brandon Coleman
QB Aaron Murray
WR Matt Hazel
TE Crockett Gillmore
QB Garrett Gilbert
RB Stephen Houston
WR Cody Hoffman
QB Bryn Renner
WR Mike Davis
TE Crockett Gillmore
RB Marion Grice
WR Matt Hazel
TE Colt Lyerla
RB DeAnthony Thomas
TE C.J. Fiedorowicz
WR Michael Campanaro

Overall I consider the 2014 class to be better than 2015 but it is close. The RB prospects are much better than 2014 and the WR at the top I think are comparable prospects, there just are not as many of them.

Both draft classes look much better than the 2013 draft class which had some RB land in good situations but didn't offer as high of quality prospects at WR as either of these draft classes.

Great topic.

 

[Biabreakable]

So do to a recent discussion about this I decided to grab Lance Zierleins draft grades from NFL.com and sort all of the rookie prospects by his draft grades.

This is what the grades mean-

9.00-10 Once-in-lifetime player

8.00-8.99 Perennial All-Pro
7.50-7.99 Future All-Pro
7.00-7.49 Pro Bowl-caliber player
6.50-6.99 Chance to become Pro Bowl-caliber player
6.00-6.49 Should become instant starter
5.50-5.99 Chance to become NFL starter
5.20-5.49 NFL backup or special teams potential
5.01-5.19 Better-than-average chance to make NFL roster
5.00 50-50 Chance to make NFL roster
4.75-4.99 Should be in an NFL training camp
4.50-4.74 Chance to be in an NFL training camp
NO GRADE Likely needs time in developmental league.

Watkins, Sammy WR 6'1" 211 Clemson Pick 4, Round 1 (4) Bills 7.3
Cooper, Amari WR 6'1" 211 Alabama 7.1
White, Kevin WR 6'3" 215 West Virginia 6.7
Winston, Jameis QB 6'4" 231 Florida St. 6.5
Evans, Mike WR 6'5" 231 Texas A&M Pick 7, Round 1 (7) Buccaneers 6.4
Parker, DeVante WR 6'3" 209 Louisville 6.3
Mariota, Marcus QB 6'4" 222 Oregon 6.2
Bortles, Blake QB 6'5" 232 Central Florida Pick 3, Round 1 (3) Jaguars 6.2
Gurley, Todd RB 6'1" 222 Georgia 6.2
Lee, Marqise WR 6'0" 192 USC Pick 7, Round 2 (39) Jaguars 6.2
Ebron, Eric TE 6'4" 250 North Carolina Pick 10, Round 1 (10) Lions 6.2
Hundley, Brett QB 6'3" 226 UCLA 6.1
Petty, Bryce QB 6'3" 230 Baylor 6.1
Grayson, Garrett QB 6'2" 213 Colorado St. 6.1
Bridgewater, Teddy QB 6'2" 214 Louisville Pick 32, Round 1 (32) Vikings 6.1
Carr, Derek QB 6'2" 214 Fresno St. Pick 4, Round 2 (36) Raiders 6.1
Manziel, Johnny QB 6'0" 207 Texas A&M Pick 22, Round 1 (22) Browns 6.1
Gordon, Melvin RB 6'1" 215 Wisconsin 6.1
Hyde, Carlos RB 6'0" 230 Ohio St. Pick 25, Round 2 (57) 49ers 6.1
Beckham, Odell WR 5'11" 198 LSU Pick 12, Round 1 (12) Giants 6.1
Benjamin, Kelvin WR 6'5" 240 Florida St. Pick 28, Round 1 (28) Panthers 6.1
Coleman, Tevin RB 5'11" 206 Indiana 6
Perriman, Breshad WR 6'2" 212 Central Florida 5.9
Strong, Jaelen WR 6'2" 217 Arizona State 5.9
Cooks, Brandin WR 5'10" 189 Oregon St. Pick 20, Round 1 (20) Saints 5.9
Moncrief, Donte WR 6'2" 221 Mississippi Pick 26, Round 3 (90) Colts 5.9
Mannion, Sean QB 6'6" 229 Oregon St. 5.8
Garoppolo, Jimmy QB 6'2" 226 Eastern Illinois Pick 30, Round 2 (62) Patriots 5.8
Ajayi, Jay RB 6'0" 221 Boise St. 5.8
Johnson, Duke RB 5'9" 207 Miami 5.8
Mason, Tre RB 5'8" 207 Auburn Pick 11, Round 3 (75) Rams 5.8
Dorsett, Phillip WR 5'10" 185 Miami 5.8
McCarron, AJ QB 6'3" 220 Alabama Pick 24, Round 5 (164) Bengals 5.7
Abdullah, Ameer RB 5'9" 205 Nebraska 5.7
Green-Beckham, Dorial WR 6'5" 237 Missouri 5.7
Smith, Devin WR 6'0" 196 Ohio St. 5.7
Adams, Davante WR 6'1" 212 Fresno St. Pick 21, Round 2 (53) Packers 5.7
Matthews, Jordan WR 6'3" 212 Vanderbilt Pick 10, Round 2 (42) Eagles 5.7
Williams, Maxx TE 6'4" 249 Minnesota 5.7
Yeldon, T.J. RB 6'1" 226 Alabama 5.6
Sankey, Bishop RB 5'9" 209 Washington Pick 22, Round 2 (54) Titans 5.6
Williams, Andre RB 5'11" 230 Boston College Pick 13, Round 4 (113) Giants 5.6
Coates, Sammie WR 6'1" 212 Auburn 5.6
Robinson, Allen WR 6'2" 220 Penn St. Pick 29, Round 2 (61) Jaguars 5.6
Landry, Jarvis WR 5'11" 205 LSU Pick 31, Round 2 (63) Dolphins 5.6
Niklas, Troy TE 6'6" 270 Notre Dame Pick 20, Round 2 (52) Cardinals 5.6
Hill, Jeremy RB 6'1" 233 LSU Pick 23, Round 2 (55) Bengals 5.5
Archer, Dri RB 5'8" 173 Kent St. Pick 33, Round 3 (97) Steelers 5.5
Lockett, Tyler WR 5'10" 182 Kansas St. 5.5
Greene, Rashad WR 5'11" 182 Florida St. 5.5
Agholor, Nelson WR 6'0" 198 USC 5.5
Diggs, Stefon WR 6'0" 195 Maryland 5.5
Walford, Clive TE 6'4" 251 Miami 5.5
Funchess, Devin TE 6'4" 232 Michigan 5.5
Amaro, Jace TE 6'5" 265 Texas Tech Pick 17, Round 2 (49) Jets 5.5
Sims, Blake QB 5'11" 218 Alabama 5.4
Halliday, Connor QB 6'3" 196 Washington St. 5.4
Thomas, Logan QB 6'6" 248 Virginia Tech Pick 20, Round 4 (120) Cardinals 5.4
Johnson, David RB 6'1" 224 Northern Iowa 5.4
Davis, Mike RB 5'9" 217 South Carolina 5.4
Cobb, David RB 5'11" 229 Minnesota 5.4
Williams, Karlos RB 6'1" 230 Florida St. 5.4
Rawls, Thomas RB 5'9" 215 Central Michigan 5.4
Artis-Payne, Cameron RB 5'10" 212 Auburn 5.4
Freeman, Devonta RB 5'8" 206 Florida St. Pick 3, Round 4 (103) Falcons 5.4
Carey, Ka'Deem RB 5'9" 207 Arizona Pick 17, Round 4 (117) Bears 5.4
McKinnon, Jerick RB 5'9" 209 Georgia Southern Pick 32, Round 3 (96) Vikings 5.4
Montgomery, Ty WR 6'0" 221 Stanford 5.4
Conley, Chris WR 6'2" 213 Georgia 5.4
Mayle, Vince WR 6'2" 224 Washington St. 5.4
Waller, Darren WR 6'6" 238 Georgia Tech 5.4
Goodley, Antwan WR 5'10" 209 Baylor 5.4
McBride, Tre WR 6'0" 210 William & Mary 5.4
Evans, Shaq WR 6'1" 213 UCLA Pick 15, Round 4 (115) Jets 5.4
Anderson, Rory 'Busta' TE 6'5" 244 South Carolina 5.4
Seferian-Jenkins, Austin TE 6'5" 262 Washington Pick 6, Round 2 (38) Buccaneers 5.4
Fiedorowicz, C.J. TE 6'5" 265 Iowa Pick 1, Round 3 (65) Texans 5.4
Heinicke, Taylor QB 6'1" 213 Old Dominion 5.3
Bennett, Bryan QB 6'2" 211 Southeastern Louisiana 5.3
Carden, Shane QB 6'2" 218 East Carolina 5.3
Mettenberger, Zach QB 6'5" 224 LSU Pick 2, Round 6 (178) Titans 5.3
Allen, Javorius RB 6'0" 221 USC 5.3
Jones, Matt RB 6'2" 231 Florida 5.3
Langford, Jeremy RB 6'0" 208 Michigan St. 5.3
Zenner, Zach RB 5'11" 223 South Dakota St. 5.3
West, Terrance RB 5'9" 225 Towson Pick 30, Round 3 (94) Browns 5.3
Thomas, De'Anthony RB 5'9" 174 Oregon Pick 24, Round 4 (124) Chiefs 5.3
Sims, Charles RB 6'0" 214 West Virginia Pick 5, Round 3 (69) Buccaneers 5.3
Bell, Kenny WR 6'1" 197 Nebraska 5.3
Davis, Titus WR 6'1" 196 Central Michigan 5.3
Lippett, Tony WR 6'2" 192 Michigan St. 5.3
Anderson, Dres WR 6'1" 187 Utah 5.3
Crowder, Jamison WR 5'8" 185 Duke 5.3
Hardy, Justin WR 5'10" 192 East Carolina 5.3
Lewis, Dezmin WR 6'4" 214 Central Arkansas 5.3
Ellington, Bruce WR 5'9" 197 South Carolina Pick 6, Round 4 (106) 49ers 5.3
Norwood, Kevin WR 6'2" 198 Alabama Pick 23, Round 4 (123) Seahawks 5.3
Abbrederis, Jared WR 6'1" 195 Wisconsin Pick 36, Round 5 (176) Packers 5.3
Janis, Jeff WR 6'3" 219 Saginaw Valley St. Pick 21, Round 7 (236) Packers 5.3
Jones, T.J. WR 6'0" 188 Notre Dame Pick 13, Round 6 (189) Lions 5.3
Bryant, Martavis WR 6'4" 211 Clemson Pick 18, Round 4 (118) Steelers 5.3
O'Leary, Nick TE 6'3" 252 Florida St. 5.3
Heuerman, Jeff TE 6'5" 254 Ohio St. 5.3
Kroft, Tyler TE 6'5" 246 Rutgers 5.3
Koyack, Ben TE 6'5" 255 Notre Dame 5.3
Telfer, Randall TE 6'4" 250 USC 5.3
Lyerla, Colt TE 6'4" 242 Oregon 5.3
Mason, Hutson QB 6'3" 209 Georgia 5.2
Bridge, Brandon QB 6'4" 229 South Alabama 5.2
Fajardo, Cody QB 6'1" 223 Nevada 5.2
Boone, Anthony QB 6'0" 231 Duke 5.2
Lovelocke, Jerry QB 6'4" 248 Prairie View A&M 5.2
Boyd, Tajh QB 6'1" 222 Clemson Pick 37, Round 6 (213) Jets 5.2
Savage, Tom QB 6'4" 228 Pittsburgh Pick 35, Round 4 (135) Texans 5.2
Morris, Stephen QB 6'2" 213 Miami 5.2
Mathews, Jeff QB 6'4" 223 Cornell 5.2
Williams, Trey RB 5'7" 195 Texas A&M 5.2
Agnew, Malcolm RB 5'9" 207 Southern Illinois 5.2
Varga, Tyler FB 5'11" 222 Yale 5.2
Johnson, Storm RB 6'0" 209 Central Florida Pick 7, Round 7 (222) Jaguars 5.2
Seastrunk, Lache RB 5'9" 201 Baylor Pick 10, Round 6 (186) Redskins 5.2
Taliaferro, Lorenzo RB 6'0" 229 Coastal Carolina Pick 38, Round 4 (138) Ravens 5.2
Blue, Alfred RB 6'2" 223 LSU Pick 5, Round 6 (181) Texans 5.2
Gaffney, Tyler RB 5'11" 220 Stanford Pick 28, Round 6 (204) Panthers 5.2
Andrews, Antonio RB 5'10" 225 Western Kentucky 5.2
Perkins, LaDarius RB 5'7" 195 Mississippi St. 5.2
Fluellen, David RB 5'11" 224 Toledo 5.2
Baker, James RB 6'0" 237 Idaho 5.2
Harper, Josh WR 6'1" 191 Fresno St. 5.2
Alford, Mario WR 5'8" 180 West Virginia 5.2
Smelter, DeAndre WR 6'2" 226 Georgia Tech 5.2
Richardson, Paul WR 6'0" 175 Colorado Pick 13, Round 2 (45) Seahawks 5.2
Latimer, Cody WR 6'2" 215 Indiana Pick 24, Round 2 (56) Broncos 5.2
Street, Devin WR 6'3" 198 Pittsburgh Pick 6, Round 5 (146) Cowboys 5.2
Huff, Josh WR 5'11" 206 Oregon Pick 22, Round 3 (86) Eagles 5.2
Saunders, Jalen WR 5'9" 165 Oklahoma Pick 4, Round 4 (104) Jets 5.2
Gallon, Jeremy WR 5'7" 185 Michigan Pick 29, Round 7 (244) Patriots 5.2
Pruitt, MyCole TE 6'2" 251 Southern Illinois 5.2
James, Jesse TE 6'7" 261 Penn St. 5.2
Bell, Blake TE 6'6" 252 Oklahoma 5.2
Rodgers, Richard TE 6'4" 257 California Pick 34, Round 3 (98) Packers 5.2
Leonard, A.C. TE 6'2" 252 Tennessee St. 5.2
Denham, Anthony TE 6'4" 235 Utah 5.2
Jensen, Marcel TE 6'6" 259 Fresno St. 5.2
Burton, Trey TE 6'2" 224 Florida 5.2
Kelly, Taylor QB 6'2" 210 Arizona State 5.1
Thompson, Dylan QB 6'3" 218 South Carolina 5.1
Fales, David QB 6'2" 212 San Jose St. Pick 7, Round 6 (183) Bears 5.1
Wenning, Keith QB 6'3" 218 Ball St. Pick 18, Round 6 (194) Ravens 5.1
Shaw, Connor QB 6'0" 206 South Carolina 5.1
Renner, Bryn QB 6'3" 228 North Carolina 5.1
Smith, Brett QB 6'1" 205 Wyoming 5.1
Crockett, John RB 6'0" 217 North Dakota St. 5.1
Robinson, Josh RB 5'8" 217 Mississippi St. 5.1
Heard, Braylon RB 5'10" 198 Kentucky 5.1
Magee, Terrence RB 5'8" 213 LSU 5.1
Murphy, Marcus RB 5'8" 193 Missouri 5.1
Grant, Corey RB 5'11" 205 Auburn 5.1
Millard, Trey FB 6'2" 247 Oklahoma Pick 30, Round 7 (245) 49ers 5.1
Grice, Marion RB 6'0" 208 Arizona State Pick 25, Round 6 (201) Chargers 5.1
White, James RB 5'9" 204 Wisconsin Pick 30, Round 4 (130) Patriots 5.1
Neal, Rajion RB 5'11" 220 Tennessee 5.1
Crowell, Isaiah RB 5'11" 224 Alabama St. 5.1
Williams, Damien RB 5'11" 222 Oklahoma 5.1
Atkinson, George RB 6'1" 218 Notre Dame 5.1
Wilder, James RB 6'3" 232 Florida St. 5.1
Hall, Rannell WR 6'0" 198 Central Florida 5.1
Davis, Devante WR 6'3" 220 UNLV 5.1
White, DeAndrew WR 5'11" 193 Alabama 5.1
Daniels, DaVaris WR 6'1" 201 Notre Dame 5.1
Long, Deon WR 6'0" 192 Maryland 5.1
Brown, John WR 5'10" 179 Pittsburg St. (KS) Pick 27, Round 3 (91) Cardinals 5.1
Herron, Robert WR 5'9" 193 Wyoming Pick 9, Round 6 (185) Buccaneers 5.1
Reese, Tevin WR 5'10" 163 Baylor Pick 25, Round 7 (240) Chargers 5.1
Hazel, Matt WR 6'1" 198 Coastal Carolina Pick 14, Round 6 (190) Dolphins 5.1
Grant, Ryan WR 6'0" 199 Tulane Pick 2, Round 5 (142) Redskins 5.1
Campanaro, Mike WR 5'9" 192 Wake Forest Pick 3, Round 7 (218) Ravens 5.1
Enunwa, Quincy WR 6'2" 225 Nebraska Pick 33, Round 6 (209) Jets 5.1
Uzomah, C.J. TE 6'5" 264 Auburn 5.1
Derby, A.J. TE 6'4" 255 Arkansas 5.1
Saxton, Wes TE 6'3" 248 South Alabama 5.1
Boyle, Nick TE 6'4" 268 Delaware 5.1
Mahina, Devin TE 6'6" 251 BYU 5.1
Gillmore, Crockett TE 6'6" 260 Colorado St. Pick 35, Round 3 (99) Ravens 5.1
Jordan, Reggie TE 6'3" 240 Missouri Western 5.1
Annen, Blake TE 6'4" 247 Cincinnati 5.1
Murray, Aaron QB 6'1" 207 Georgia Pick 23, Round 5 (163) Chiefs 5
Gilbert, Garrett QB 6'4" 221 SMU Pick 38, Round 6 (214) Rams 5
Martinez, Taylor QB 6'0" 201 Nebraska 5
Lynch, Jordan QB 6'0" 217 Northern Illinois 5
Brown, Malcolm RB 5'11" 224 Texas 5
Scheuerman, Ross RB 6'0" 204 Lafayette 5
Catalon, B.J. RB 5'7" 186 TCU 5
Edwards, Jahwan RB 5'9" 220 Ball St. 5
Fowler, Jalston FB 5'11" 254 Alabama 5
Hunt, Akeem RB 5'10" 183 Purdue 5
Hart, Dee RB 5'7" 199 Colorado St. 5
Prosch, Jay FB 6'1" 256 Auburn Pick 35, Round 6 (211) Texans 5
Williams, Karl FB 6'0" 244 Utah 5
Malena, Ben RB 5'8" 193 Texas A&M 5
Smith, Jerome RB 5'11" 220 Syracuse 5
Copeland, J.C. FB 5'11" 271 LSU 5
Redd, Silas RB 5'10" 212 USC 5
Josey, Henry RB 5'8" 194 Missouri 5
Harris, Josh RB 5'10" 206 Wake Forest 5
Hewitt, Ryan FB 6'4" 246 Stanford 5
Bauman, Zach RB 5'7" 196 Northern Arizona 5
Houston, Stephen RB 5'11" 225 Indiana 5
Cornett, Tim RB 6'0" 209 UNLV 5
Harbridge, Kyle RB 5'10" 204 St. Francis (PA) 5
Hill, Austin WR 6'3" 212 Arizona 5
Clay, Kaelin WR 5'10" 195 Utah 5
Harper, Chris WR 5'11" 175 California 5
Taylor, Jordan WR 6'5" 210 Rice 5
Jones, Christion WR 5'10" 182 Alabama 5
Nelson, J.J. WR 5'10" 156 UAB 5
Davis, Andre WR 6'1" 205 South Florida 5
Farmer, George WR 6'1" 220 USC 5
Norwood, Levi WR 6'2" 200 Baylor 5
Wright, James WR 6'1" 201 LSU Pick 24, Round 7 (239) Bengals 5
Christian, Gerald TE 6'3" 244 Louisville 5
Pierce, Casey TE 6'4" 242 Kent St. 5
Lee, Khari TE 6'4" 235 Bowie St. 5
Bibbs, E.J. TE 6'2" 258 Iowa St. 5
Lynch, Arthur TE 6'5" 258 Georgia Pick 15, Round 5 (155) Dolphins 5
Blanchflower, Rob TE 6'4" 256 Massachusetts Pick 15, Round 7 (230) Steelers 5
Pedersen, Jacob TE 6'3" 238 Wisconsin 5
Murphy, Jake TE 6'4" 249 Utah 5
Grimble, Xavier TE 6'4" 257 USC 5
Bayer, Alex TE 6'4" 258 Bowling Green 5
Duncan, Joe Don TE 6'3" 268 Dixie St. 5
Jacobs, Nic TE 6'5" 269 McNeese St. 5
Vaughan, Dustin QB 6'5" 235 West Texas A&M 4.9
Brown, Dominique RB 6'2" 234 Louisville 4.9
Dyer, Michael RB 5'8" 218 Louisville 4.9
Ripkowski, Aaron FB 6'1" 257 Oklahoma 4.9
Neighbors, Connor FB 5'11" 229 LSU 4.9
Clay, Brennan RB 5'11" 196 Oklahoma 4.9
Tipton, Zurlon RB 6'0" 223 Central Michigan 4.9
Bibbs, Kapri RB 5'9" 212 Colorado St. 4.9
Hunt, Torrance RB 5'7" 180 Georgia Southern 4.9
Adams, D.J. RB 5'9" 213 Portland St. 4.9
Sims, James RB 5'10" 206 Kansas 4.9
Perry, Senorise RB 6'0" 206 Louisville 4.9
Luckett, Donatella WR 6'0" 211 Harding 4.9
Worthy, Cam WR 6'2" 211 East Carolina 4.9
D'Orazio, Zach WR 6'2" 217 Akron 4.9
Greenberry, Deontay WR 6'3" 200 Houston 4.9
Kumerow, Jake WR 6'5" 195 Wisconsin-Whitewater 4.9
Williams, Kasen WR 6'3" 217 Washington 4.9
Turzilli, Andrew WR 6'3" 195 Rutgers 4.9
King, Nigel WR 6'3" 210 Kansas 4.9
Brown, Da'Ron WR 6'0" 205 Northern Illinois 4.9
Richards, Addison WR 6'5" 205 Regina 4.9
Sifrin, Jean TE 6'5" 245 Massachusetts 4.9
Dixon, Larry FB 5'11" 239 Army 4.8
Smith, Dreamius RB 6'0" 217 West Virginia 4.8
Hilliard, Kenny RB 6'0" 226 LSU 4.8
Gulley, Prince-Tyson RB 5'10" 192 Syracuse 4.8
Burton, Michael FB 5'11" 242 Rutgers 4.8
Watson, Terrell RB 6'2" 240 Azusa Pacific 4.8
Iosefa, Joey FB 6'0" 247 Hawaii 4.8
Johnson, Gus RB 5'10" 215 Stephen F. Austin 4.8
Parks, Kevin RB 5'8" 200 Virginia 4.8
Flanders, Timothy RB 5'9" 207 Sam Houston St. 4.8
Whitlock, Nikita FB 5'10" 251 Wake Forest 4.8
Muema, Adam RB 5'10" 202 San Diego St. 4.8
Shipley, Jaxon WR 6'0" 190 Texas 4.8
Miller, Matt WR 6'3" 213 Boise St. 4.8
Mumphery, Keith WR 6'0" 215 Michigan St. 4.8
Ruffin, Ezell WR 6'0" 218 San Diego St. 4.8
Davis, Geremy WR 6'2" 216 Connecticut 4.8
Powell, Walt WR 5'11" 189 Murray St. Pick 20, Round 6 (196) Cardinals 4.8
Clear, Cameron TE 6'5" 277 Texas A&M 4.8
Tomlinson, Eric TE 6'6" 263 Texas-El Paso 4.8
Vogler, Brian TE 6'7" 263 Alabama 4.8
Tonga, Westlee TE 6'4" 244 Utah 4.8
Bolser, Ted TE 6'5" 257 Indiana Pick 2, Round 7 (217) Redskins 4.8
Flacco, Michael TE 6'5" 251 New Haven 4.8
Tialavea, D.J. TE 6'3" 267 Utah St. 4.8
Najvar, Jordan TE 6'6" 256 Baylor 4.8
Pachall, Casey QB 6'4" 216 TCU 4.7
Rees , Tommy QB 6'1" 214 Notre Dame 4.7
Mendenhall, D.J. QB 6'4" 225 Urbana (OH) 4.7
Small, Kiero RB 5'8" 244 Arkansas Pick 12, Round 7 (227) Seahawks 4.7
LaCoste, Anthony RB 5'10" 203 Air Force 4.7
Spooney, John RB 5'11" 193 Brown 4.7
Lengel, Matthew TE 6'7" 270 Eastern Kentucky 4.7
Watson, Asa TE 6'3" 239 N.C. State 4.7
Price, Keith QB 6'0" 196 Washington 4.6
Sumler, Tacoi WR 5'9" 175 Appalachian St. 4.6

2015 grades
2014 grades
2013 grades

I didn't include 2013 grades because he used a differeent numerical method for those than 2014-2015 making them incomparable.

This is how he graded the 2013 prospects-

96-100 Future Hall of Famer Top Pick A once-in-a-generation type prospect who could change how his position is played

85-95 Immediate Starter 1st An impact player with the ability/intangibles to become a Pro Bowl player. Expect to start immediately except in a unique situation (i.e. behind a veteran starter).
70-84 Eventual Starter 2nd-3rd A quality player who will contribute to the team early on and is expected to develop into a starter. A reliable player who brings value to the position.
50-69 Draftable Player 4th-7th A prospect with the ability to make team as a backup/role player. Needs to be a special teams contributor at applicable positions. Players in the high range of this category might have long-term potential.
20-49 Free Agent UDFA A player with solid measurables, intangibles, college achievements, or a developing skill that warrants an opportunity in an NFL camp. In the right situation, he could earn a place on a 53-man roster, but most likely will be a practice squad player or a camp body

 

[ChuckLiddell]

Thats great stuff. Thanks for posting. Will be useful when looking at draft day wheeling and dealing.