I think my problem is that for the most part this is my reaction every year.I'm fairly eh about the pick. Not excited, not disappointed. I think that would have been the case for anything other than a huge reach or a great steal though. At this point, just need to wait and see how he turns out.
Same here. It's a very "Texans" pick. A safe, solid contributor. I think it also says a lot to what I've been worried about since we hired Wade... they really don't know how these guys are gonna transition or take to their new roles in the 3-4. So they are drafting insurance and depth in case guys struggle or we end up having to cut or trade guys like Okoye/Smith, etc.My guess for our 2nd pick is an OLB pass rusher to add more depth to the front 7. I'm hoping Akeem Ayers is still on the board. DB's will be addressed with some later picks and some mid-level free agent's.I normally don't like spending big in FA, but I would gladly welcome money-whipping Aso to come join us.I think my problem is that for the most part this is my reaction every year.I'm fairly eh about the pick. Not excited, not disappointed. I think that would have been the case for anything other than a huge reach or a great steal though. At this point, just need to wait and see how he turns out.
1 Ras-I Dowling DB Patriots 86
2 Aaron Williams DB Bills 88
3 Andy Dalton QB Bengals 86
4 Colin Kaepernick QB 49ers 81
5 Jabaal Sheard DE Browns 87
6 Ryan Williams RB Cardinals 88
7 Akeem Ayers OLB Titans 88
8 Bruce Carter OLB Cowboys 84
9 Jarvis Jenkins DT Redskins 78
10 Da'Quan Bowers DE Texans 91
11 Kyle Rudolph TE Vikings 89
12 Titus Young WR Lions 83

[Houston Texans]J.J. WattDefensive End93SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 90-100 Grade * 1st Round Round EquivalentA premier college player with all the physical tools to take over a game and play at a championship level. He demonstrates elite-to-rare NFL potential and rates in the top 5 players nationally at his position. A prospect with a grade of 99 or 100 is rare. Prospects carrying grades between 92-98 are considered mid-to-high first rounders, while prospects grading out between 90-91 are fringe first rounders.View All Grades »Close * WisconsinSchool * Big TenConference * 6'5⅜"Height * 290 lbsWeight * 34.0"Arm Length * 11.1"Hand Size * 16Overall Rank * 4Positional RankCAREER NCAA FOOTBALL STATSStats are not available.2011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICKHOU 1 11(11)Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 2 2007 (Central Michigan): Played in 14 games at tight end; 8 catches, 77 yards. 2008: Transferred to Wisconsin, moved to defensive end, sat out the season under NCAA transfer rules. 2009: (13/13) 44 total tackles, 15.5 TFL, 4.5 sacks, 2 FR, 5 PBU, 1 BLK FG. 2010: (13/13) 62 total tackles, 21 TFL, 7 sacks, 3 FF, 2 FR; 1 INT, 9 PBU; 1 BLK FG, 2 BLK PATs.Height-Weight-Speed 2 Exceptional combination of height, weight and straight-line speed.Durability 2 Appeared in every game of three-year collegiate career. Left 2010 Arizona State game twice with leg injuries but returned to the game both times.Intangibles 1 Named Wisconsin's defensive scout team player of the year in 2008. Named team MVP in 2010. Named Academic All-Big 10 in 2009 and 2010.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalDefensive End Specific TraitsPass Rush Skills 2 Lacks elite first-step quickness. Carries his weight well but is not an elite pass rusher. Lacks lateral agility on double moves but still is a three-down defensive end. Power-to-speed rusher. Shows savvy setting up offensive linemen. Has quick, violent hands. Can get off of blocks quickly, finds the quarterback quickly and shows very good closing burst for his size. Much faster finishing than he is starting. Has rare instincts when it comes to getting hands up and either batting down passes or affecting QBs passing lane. Always active and never stops hustling. Absolutely relentless.Versus the run 1 Stronger upper body than lower body. Could play with better pad level at times but is powerful. Can anchor versus the run but also does an excellent job of finding the ball, disengaging and pursuing. He shows exceptional hand usage. Shows violent, quick hands and knows how to use them. Takes good angles in pursuit and shows better straight-line speed than anticipated once he has momentum. He's a finisher.Versatility 2 Can slide inside and rush the passer on occasion. Has the frame and upper-body strength to develop into an effective 5-technique but needs to get stronger in the lower body.Instincts/Motor 1 Snap awareness is generally very good. Will take the bait versus the option on occasion and leaves his scheme vulnerable. But his overall awareness is exceptional. Finds the ball and keeps his head on a swivel. Shows outstanding anticipation. No defensive lineman in this class does a better job of getting his hands up and affecting the quarterback's throwing lane. Is absolutely relentless. Tremendous motor.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
[Arizona]Brooks ReedDefensive End90SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 90-100 Grade * 1st Round Round EquivalentA premier college player with all the physical tools to take over a game and play at a championship level. He demonstrates elite-to-rare NFL potential and rates in the top 5 players nationally at his position. A prospect with a grade of 99 or 100 is rare. Prospects carrying grades between 92-98 are considered mid-to-high first rounders, while prospects grading out between 90-91 are fringe first rounders.View All Grades »Close * ArizonaSchool * PAC-10Conference * 6'2½"Height * 263 lbsWeight * 32.2"Arm Length * 10.0"Hand Size * 27Overall Rank * 8Positional RankCAREER NCAA FOOTBALL STATSTACKLES FUMBLES FORCED INT44 — —2011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICK— — —Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 3 2006: Redshirted. 2007: (7/0) 7 tackles, 0.5 TFL, 0.5 sacks. 2008: (13/13) 37 tackles, 9.5 TFL, 8 sacks. 2009: (10/8) 23 tackles, 5 TFL, 2 sacks. 2010: (13/13) 47 tackles, 10 TFL, 6.5 sacks.Height-Weight-Speed 2 Slightly below-average in terms of height but possesses adequate bulk and very good top-end speed.Durability 4 Suffered a high-ankle sprain at Iowa in 2009 and missed three games (two starts) as a result.Intangibles 2 Hard worker and takes a passionate approach to game. Developed into the leader of the defense and voted a team captain as senior. No off-field issues to our knowledge. Made transition from H-back to DE in 2007.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalDefensive End Specific TraitsPass Rush Skills 1 A quick-twitch athlete that shows an explosive first step off of the edge. Had the fastest 10-yard split time (1.54) of any defensive lineman at the 2011 combine. Shows quality rip and swim moves. Technically-sound and relentless. Uses hands extremely well to keep blocker off of frame. Very effective with speed-to-power moves. Can bend the edge tightly and shows outstanding leverage/flexibility. Will fight to get through the double team and works hard through the whistle. Closing burst is good but not elite category.Versus the run 3 Is undersized and occasionally can get overwhelmed at the point of attack when blockers lock on. Is not an elite athlete and shows some stiffness in space when forced to quickly change directions. But he maximizes his physical tools versus the run thanks to excellent effort and technique. Does a very good job with his first step. Is quick off the ball, uses outstanding leverage and hand technique to take on and disengage from typically bigger blockers. Also takes on blockers with the proper shoulder (typically left shoulder at RDE) to ensure gap discipline. Strong tackler for the position. Rarely fails to wrap up when he's in position.Versatility 2 Flashes potential to develop into a rush linebacker in the NFL. Not a great athlete but shows good quickness and adequate hip flexibility on tape when he occasionally drops into underneath zone. Displays awareness and discipline in coverage.Instincts/Motor 1 Is disciplined and executes his assignments. Shows good awareness in all phases of the game. Is tough and aggressive. Flies around the field and is clearly passionate about his craft. Will chip the TE when necessary. Does a nice job of keeping outside leverage versus the run.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
I'm guessing you mean they gave their 3rd and 5th for the 2nd? I love the pick, day two has been a A+ in my book.Texans trade 2nd and 5th for NE 3rd60th pick Brandon Harris CB Miami
[Miami (FL)]Brandon HarrisCornerback85SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 80-89 Grade * 1st Round 2nd Round EquivalentA feature player at the collegiate level that has an impact on the outcome of the game. He generally cannot be shut down by a single player and plays on a consistent level week in and week out. Most importantly, he shows the potential to create mismatches versus many opponents in the NFL. He rates in the top 5-to-10 at his position and is considered a second round draft prospect.View All Grades »Close * Miami (FL)School * ACC - CoastalConference * 5'9½"Height * 191 lbsWeight * 30.5"Arm Length * 8.399"Hand Size * 42Overall Rank * 6Positional Rank2010 NCAA FOOTBALL STATSTACKLES FUMBLES FORCED INT41 — 12011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICK— — —Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 2 2008: (13/6) 30 total tackles, 2 TFL, 1 sack, 3 PBU, 1 INT. 2009: (13/13) 52 total tackles, 6 TFL, 1 sack, 15 PBU, 2 INT.2010: (13/13) 44 total tackles, 1 TFL, 10 PBU, INT.Height-Weight-Speed 3 A bit on the short side but has prototypical bulk and possesses excellent top-end speed.Durability 1 Played in all 39 games during his three seasons at Miami.Intangibles 1 All-ACC Academic Team in 2008. Hard worker. Passionate about the game. Coaches' son (father, Tim Harris, was named USA Today National High School Coach of the Year in 2007).1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalCornerback Specific TraitsInstincts/Recognition 3 Does not get caught peeking in the backfield. Shows good natural instincts in man-to-man coverage. Showed improvement during junior season with recognition/reaction in zone coverage. Is confident in his ability, will not back down versus top competition and has proven capable of immediately bouncing back from mistakes. Also not afraid to mix it up.Cover Skills 2 A very good natural athlete with quick feet, great balance and fluid hips. Could be more compact in his pedal but shows good burst out of it and excellent closing speed when the ball is in the air. Does a nice job of wrapping up and limiting yards after catch. Is physical enough to hold up in bump-and-run coverage in the NFL, but needs work on technique and get more game reps.Ball Skills 3 Knows when to attack the ball and when to attack the body. Does not have great INT production and lacks elite playmaking ability. Can have trouble turning and locating the ball in a timely manner on occasion. However, he flashes solid hands. Can pluck away from his frame and over his head.Run Support 2 Has adequate size, strength and enough willingness to become an effective run support cornerback in the NFL. Takes solid angles when pursuing from the backside. Can do a better job of finishing in space. Shows adequate power for the position but leads with his shoulder too frequently and needs to learn when to break down and wrap up.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
oops yesI'm guessing you mean they gave their 3rd and 5th for the 2nd? I love the pick, day two has been a A+ in my book.Texans trade 2nd and 5th for NE 3rd60th pick Brandon Harris CB Miami
Yeah, They are attempting to fill need with big school dudes who have a record of production.rapidly changing my mind about this draft
[Houston Texans]Rashad CarmichaelCornerback61SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 60-69 Grade * 4th Round Round EquivalentThis player is a good starter at the collegiate level but he is overmatched versus the better players in the nation. He is usually a prospect that is missing something from his game. For example, he has the size and skills to be an outstanding prospect, but lacks the speed. He will usually rate in the top half of the players at his position and is considered an early-Day 2 prospect.View All Grades »Close * Virginia TechSchool * ACC - CoastalConference * 5'10"Height * 192 lbsWeight * 31.6"Arm Length * 9.0"Hand Size * 149Overall Rank * 22Positional Rank2010 NCAA FOOTBALL STATSTACKLES FUMBLES FORCED INT35 — 42011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICKHOU 4 30(127)Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 2 2006: Redshirted. 2007: (14/0) 8 tackles, 1 TFL, 1 PBU. 2008: (14/1) 12 tackles, 4 TFL, 1 sack, 2 PBU, 1 INT. 2009: (13/13) 55 tackles, 5 TFL, 1 sack, 6 INT, 6 PBU. 2010: (13/12) 40 total tackles, 1.5 TFL, 7 PBU, 4 INT (1 returned for TD).Height-Weight-Speed 3 Slightly undersized and top-end speed is average.Durability 1 A durable, flexible athlete that missed just one game in 2010 (twisted ankle).Intangibles 1 Has fought through adversity and shown great integrity. His father, Bernard Carmichael, died of a heart attack in July 2008 at age 40. Rashad is the oldest child and has taken on a great deal of responsibility at home. Nickname is Rock, given to him by his father.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalCornerback Specific TraitsInstincts/Recognition 2 Reads routes well and knows tendencies. Generally plays under control. However, can get caught flat footed on occasion. Uses the boundary as his friend and flashes some savvy as a man-to-man corner. Biggest issue here is with his ball awareness. He will be late to recognize and find the ball in the air and he's already at a size disadvantage on fade routes, etc. Also can be overaggressive jumping underneath routes and can be susceptible to effective double moves.Cover Skills 3 Has good experience in both man and zone coverage. Is solid in zone but is more effective in man. Shows good leverage in his pedal and burst out of it. He has very quick feet, he plays under control and he shows above average hip fluidity. Can lose momentum with any sudden change of direction on occasion. He has the agility and top-end speed to mirror most WRs in man-coverage. He gets into some trouble versus bigger receivers that muscle him around at times.Ball Skills 2 Will be late to react to the ball in the air (when back turned to QB) on occasion. Still, his overall ball skills are above-average. He attacks the ball in the air and will high-point it. He has strong hands. Can pluck away from his body and has the hand-eye coordination to make the acrobatic play on the ball.Run Support 4 Size and strength are less than ideal. Tackling technique and angles need work. Consistently dips his head and leads with his shoulder resulting in several missed tackles. He's by no means overly-excited to support the run but he's willing to mix it up when necessary. Has a great motor and will pursue from all angles but he's a bit of a pile inspector.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
[idaho]Shiloh KeoSafety66SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 60-69 Grade * 4th Round Round EquivalentThis player is a good starter at the collegiate level but he is overmatched versus the better players in the nation. He is usually a prospect that is missing something from his game. For example, he has the size and skills to be an outstanding prospect, but lacks the speed. He will usually rate in the top half of the players at his position and is considered an early-Day 2 prospect.View All Grades »Close * IdahoSchool * WACConference * 5'11¼"Height * 219 lbsWeight * 30.0"Arm Length * 9.5"Hand Size * 121Overall Rank * 7Positional Rank2010 NCAA FOOTBALL STATSTACKLES FUMBLES FORCED INT61 1 32011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICK— — —Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 2 2006: (12/12) 72 tackles, 6 TFL, 6 PBU, 1 INT. 2007: (12/12) 81 tackles, 5 TFL, 4 PBU, 4 INT. 2008: (4/4) 31 tackles. 2009: (13/13) 113 tackles, 4 TFL, 5 PBU, 3 INT. 2010: (13/12) 61 tackles, 6.5 TFL, 1 sack, 5 PBU, 3 INT.Height-Weight-Speed 4 Does not look the part. Heavier than most NFL Ss, especially for his somewhat shorter freame. Has marginal top-end speed.Durability 3 Injured shoulder in fourth game of the 2008 season and missed the remainder of the year.Intangibles 3 2009 and 2010 team captain. 2008 special teams' captain. 2007 team MVP. Arrested and charged with misdemeanor battery in October 2009.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalSafety Specific TraitsProduction 2 Displays above-average awareness and overall diagnostic skills. A decisive player. Flashes the ability to anticipate routes and get a quick jump on the ball. Will become overzealous on occasion, though, which can lead to some false steps. Not elite playmaker but has a knack for being at the right place at the right time.Height-Weight-Speed 3 Can open hips, get to depth and cover deep half of the field. Fluid enough to stay with most tight ends in man coverage but not a player teams should feel comfortable asking to match up with slot receivers on a consistent basis. Not explosive enough getting in and out of breaks. Closing burst is just marginal and struggles to recover once initially caught out of position.Durability 3 Does a nice job of turning, locating and playing the ball when in position. Can reach in and knock the ball down with left or right hand. Flashes the ability to extend arms and snatch the ball out of the air. However, playmaking ability s limited by lack of closing speed when the ball is in the air.Intangibles 3 Doesn't shy away from contact and can blow up running plays by submarining offensive linemen. Powerful tackler that can limit ball carriers production after contact but inconsistent in this area. Can duck head and whiff. Gets downhill when reads run but not an in-the box safety despite size. Takes too long to get off blocks. Hands are not active or violent enough. Inconsistent pursuit angles.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
ESPN:Eisen: ... including the young man out of Idaho who caught the eye of Deon Sanders and everyone else. He was a ball hawk in the onfield drill, Shiloh Keo out of Idaho...Mayock: ... 11 interceptions, he returned punts. People tell me he's slow, he runs 4.75. Watch his feet as a punt returner, they don't lie. It's a lot like Tom Zibkowski when he came out, watching his feet as a punt returner.
McShay: ... Back in 2009 led the team with 113 tackles. ... not going to be returning punts running 4.75. He's gonna cover and he's going to chase down the field and he's going to be a train wreck every time he gets down there and has contact. Shiloh Keo, let's just say this, he has absolutely no regard for his body. I love the fact the Houston Texans are bringing in another tough, physical player to add to that defensive side as well as upgrading the special teams.
[North Carolina]T.J. YatesQuarterback46SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 31-49 Grade * Late Rounds Round EquivalentThese are players that flash some upside but certainly do not have the full package in terms of NFL talent. Often times, these are underdeveloped prospects that need extra time and coaching in order to compete for a roster spot in the NFL. NFL teams are looking for 'diamonds in the rough' with this type of prospect. He will usually rate in the bottom third of players at his position and will be considered a late round draft choice or un-drafted free agent.View All Grades »Close * N CarolinaSchool * ACC - CoastalConference * 6'3⅝"Height * 221 lbsWeight * —Arm Length * —Hand Size * 209Overall Rank * 11Positional Rank2010 NCAA FOOTBALL STATSStats are not available.2011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICK— — —Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 3 2007: 218 of 365 (59.7 pct.), 2,655 yds., 14 TD, 18 INT. 2008: 81 of 135 (60.0 pct.), 1,168 yds., 11 TD, 4 INT. 2009: 214 of 355, 2,136 yds., 14 TD, 15 INT. 2010: 282 of 422 (66.8 pct.), 3,418 yds., 19 TD, 9 INT. Career: Finished as the school's all-time passing leader with 9,377 yards.Height-Weight-Speed 2 Has prototypical height and adequate bulk for the position. Top-end speed is right at the average of all NFL quarterbacks in 2010. Has big hand span (10 1/4').Durability 3 Fractured his left ankle vs. Virginia Tech in 2008 and missed six games that season. Started final 26 games during 2009-'10 seasons.Intangibles 2 Intelligent. Hard working. Has overcome adversity on the field and has proven to be mentally tough. Finished career with a starting record of 23-21.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalQuarterback Specific TraitsToughness/Leadership 2 Displayed very good leadership and mental toughness during a trying final two seasons at UNC. Is tough. Will hang in pocket and take a hit. A gritty competitor. Loses confidence at times and lets it affect his play.Intelligence/Decision Making 3 Has above average football intelligence. Really improved as a decision maker in 2010. Consistently looks off the safety. Goes through progressions and will take the underneath check down if nothing else is open. Needs to be more consistent in this area, though. Gets careless at times. Gets down on himself and become indecisive at other times.Accuracy 3 Shows good touch. Knows how to lead his receivers on shorter routes. Needs to become more consistent with footwork. Gets sloppy at times and does not have the arm strength to overcome. Deep ball accuracy is below average. Hangs the deep ball too frequently. Inconsistent when it comes to throwing to a spot on intermediate routes. Far more accurate when rolling right and throwing on the run than he is rolling left.Release/Arm Strength 4 Release quickness is above average. Can change release point when necessary but generally an over-the-top delivery. Arm strength is below average. Deep out will float and he struggles to drive the ball vertically.Pocket Mobility 4 Adequate quickness in his drops. Shows urgency. But really looks uncomfortable in there's even a scent of pressure. Lacks lateral agility and short-area quickness to consistently avoid the rush. Does not buy enough second chances with his feet and is not a threat to run. Has adequate straight-line speed for the position but is not elusive.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
I like that there's some actual discussion of our picks this year. Sounds like the talking heads are a lot higher on the pick than I was.Kiper: ... this year he had to battle just to keep the starting job, and he did it. He improved by leaps and bounds. Completion percentage 66%. TD-INT ratio excellent. Did a good job spreading the field, letting the receivers share the wealth in the passing game. His pocket awareness to me, 10x better than Blaine Gabbert's.McShay: Amen.Kiper: And I'll tell you what about this kid. His arm strength, average. He runs a 5.06 40, but when you watch him he looks like he runs a 4.7. For me, outside of Stanzi, he was the next guy of that next tier of QB who could maybe develop into something.Wingo: To Dilfer: You thought Gabbert wasn't comfortable in chaos. You felt the exact opposite about Yates? Dilfer: This guy is a special player. You look for things in a future starter. Unique physical traits and a tremendous will or intangible makeup. Yates has both.(video of Yates going through progression, nothing open, rusher in his face, gets ball out fast to check down).Dilfer: He can spit this ball out like Tony Romo. He will beat people with his release. He played in chaos all his career. Look at this, being off balance about to be hit in the chops, side arms flick of the wrist off balance dimes it in there, big time play. Look at this, climbs in the pocket, like Mel was saying, instincts start to work, up in the pocket, that's what it takes in the bigs, and then flicks the ball to an open receiver.There's a lot of really solid backups late in this draft. I think there's only 1 sleeper starter, TJ Yates.Wingo: You mention he has Tony Romo type qualities, some of those got Romo in trouble?Dilfer: It's both good and bad. But this kid, tough too. This is the toughest kid in the draft at QB outside of Locker. McShay: If I'm Yates sitting at home, I'm pretty pumped.Dilfer: I would take him tomorrow and try to train him, I'd love to coach TJ Yates.
[Houston Texans]Derek NewtonOffensive Tackle49SCOUTS GRADEGrading ScaleGrading Scale * 31-49 Grade * Late Rounds Round EquivalentThese are players that flash some upside but certainly do not have the full package in terms of NFL talent. Often times, these are underdeveloped prospects that need extra time and coaching in order to compete for a roster spot in the NFL. NFL teams are looking for 'diamonds in the rough' with this type of prospect. He will usually rate in the bottom third of players at his position and will be considered a late round draft choice or un-drafted free agent.View All Grades »Close * Arkansas StSchool * Sun BeltConference * 6'4⅞"Height * 311 lbsWeight * 31.1"Arm Length * 9.3"Hand Size * 194Overall Rank * 17Positional Rank2010 NCAA FOOTBALL STATSStats are not available.2011 Draft Pick InfoTEAM ROUND PICKHOU 7 11(214)Scouts Inc. Player Evaluations * Profile * News * Video * Scouting Combine * ConversationOverall Football TraitsProduction 4 2007: First Team All-State selection at Hinds CC. 2008: Redshirted. 2009: Started all 12 games. 2010: Started all 12 games at right tackle.Height-Weight-Speed 3 Average height and above average top-end speed but below average bulk.Durability 4 Underwent knee surgery following the 2010 season.Intangibles 3 Winner of the Gary Withrow Award given to Arkansas StaTEs best offensive lineman in 2009. Named to Sun Bowl Academic Honor Roll in 2010.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = MarginalOffensive Tackle Specific TraitsPass Protection 3 Can lock out and keep defenders off frame but hand placement needs to be more consistent. Slips off too many blocks as it is now. Adequate kick step but lacks ideal lateral quickness and going to have a tougher time beating NFL edge rushers to the corner. Struggles to plant outside foot and redirect when defensive ends shoot inside. Sets too high and can give too much ground. Ineffective cut blocker at this point. Ducks head and lunges at feet instead of attacking defender's thigh pad.Run Blocking 3 Drives legs and engulfs smaller defenders but plays high and could generate more push as a drive blocker. Doesn't take sound angles on down blocks. Footwork is inconsistent. Good range and can cover up linebackers but doesn't show great body control and can whiff in space.Awareness 3 Turned and made false calls to receivers in an effort to throw defenses off at the collegiate level. Keeps head up and can pick up linebacker when asked to combination block up to the second level. Appears to make sound pre-snap reads and can pick up blitz but inconsistent in this area. Can be late recognizing line stunts. Can be a quarter count late getting off the ball.Toughness 2 Played with a torn meniscus and bone bruise in right knee in 2010. Fights to stay in position and finishes blocks but could be more violent at the point of attack and show more of a killer instinct when defender is off balance.1 = Exceptional2 = Above average3 = Average4 = Below average5 = Marginal
Part of me would prefer this too, he'll be cheaper and younger and his play is solid. Paying Aso could be worth it like Assante Samuel, but what if he turns out like Nate Clements?I know I am in the minority, but I would prefer a run at Jonathan Joseph. Should be cheaper and is 27, not 30.
Plus he is 30. I don't want him. I know I am in the minority, but Joseph will give you more years and is still well above average.Part of me would prefer this too, he'll be cheaper and younger and his play is solid. Paying Aso could be worth it like Assante Samuel, but what if he turns out like Nate Clements?I know I am in the minority, but I would prefer a run at Jonathan Joseph. Should be cheaper and is 27, not 30.