2012 In Season Dynasty Trade Thread (2 Viewers)

[cstu]

Well Tannehill is younger than Cutler and maybe has more upside (though it's probably unlikely that he'll end up being any better).I'm not sure why a rebuilding team would give up Luck. Seems like a big mistake to me. Good for you though.

Because he also had RG3.No reason to carry them both on a rebuild if there's needs elsewhere. I like the Luck side of this one too, but sometimes a seemingly uneven trade can still be a win-win.

He could have got much more than that out of Luck - that's why it's a bad trade.

In some leagues probably so. IN a lot of my leagues though...QB's are hard to trade. Not always easy to get "value" out of them. I like this thread and talks about player values in trades, but QBs are generally the hardest to translate league to league.IN one of my leagues where QB's are tough to move, I recently traded RG3 and a throwaway WR for Matt Schaub and Crabtree. ON paper, I know I lost the trade, but QBs don't move in that league and I had another legit QB1 in Eli Manning. I like Crabtree as a long term high end WR2, so the deal made sense for me.Perhaps he should have shopped Luck looking for more, but it's wrong to assume he could have gotten more, and it's still a waste to hold both him and RG3 on the same roster if there's a need elsewhere.

I agree with you on QB's being hard to trade but Luck is considered by most to be a top 5 QB talent and should go for more than your usual QB1. I guess most of the problem I have is that I don't think Morris is a good fit for a rebuilding team - especially in PPR. Also, even if the guy holds onto to Luck this year it's not as if Luck will lose any value.

 

[resko99]

Traded away DeMarco Murray + 2014 2nd round pick

for Mike Wallace + 2014 1st.

Hope I didn't sell too low on Murray.

 

[Warhogs]

Traded away Peyton Manning for a 2013 1st round pick. Manning was a luxury since I had RGIII, Eli & Flacco. Other team has some decent talent but has started 1-4 so I am thinking the pick will be in the 1.03 - 1.06 range.

 

[HAM]

12 team PPR 1-2-3-1 2Flex

I sent Mendy & 2013 4th for Ingram & 2013 2nd

Achilles flair up worried me and I do not mind sitting on Ingram till he gets out of NO and gets full time job

 

[flc735]

12 ppr full dynoi gave alf, royster, tannehilli got luck, crinerhe also has rg3. both of us are rebuilding

Good deal. I like the Luck side by far.

my first offer was alf and cutler, he countered with tannehill

that same owner just traded mccoy to get martin, late 1st and gordon

Nothin wrong with that trade. I'd move McCoy for that

really? i wouldn't have done that even before the season, when i though martin would be a top 10 rb and gordon would be the best rookie wr after blackmon

 

[FallenHero32]

Traded away Peyton Manning for a 2013 1st round pick. Manning was a luxury since I had RGIII, Eli & Flacco. Other team has some decent talent but has started 1-4 so I am thinking the pick will be in the 1.03 - 1.06 range.

Pretty solid trade. I think you made out easily, especially with your current QB situation.

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team PPR dynasty (4pts passing TDs, 6 pts rushing)

Peyton, Cobb, Ballard, and Wilson

for

RG3, Garcon, Santana Moss

 

[Fly]

12 team non-PPR

Team A gave:

Jason Witten

2013 1st rounder (likely 9-12)

Team B gave:

Vernon Davis

 

[doowain]

I'd need a hell of a lot more than Jennings/Stewart to deal Spiller.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

This went down today in a 12 team PPR. Start 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, and 3 FLEX.Team A gave: Michael Floyd, Titus YoungTeam B gave: Larry FitzgeraldI had offered Jon Baldwin and a 2013 1st for Fitz just a couple days earlier. A little surprised that Team B rejected that package, but accepted this.

Either would have been a terrible deal for Fitzgerald.

 

[Concept Coop]

12 ppr full dynoi gave alf, royster, tannehilli got luck, crinerhe also has rg3. both of us are rebuilding

Good deal. I like the Luck side by far.

my first offer was alf and cutler, he countered with tannehill

that same owner just traded mccoy to get martin, late 1st and gordon

Nothin wrong with that trade. I'd move McCoy for that

really? i wouldn't have done that even before the season, when i though martin would be a top 10 rb and gordon would be the best rookie wr after blackmon

McCoy should demand a lot more than that, still. Brown is a concern, as he is getting tough yardage looks, and the offensive line is struggling a bit - but Shady is an elite talent, still the age of some rookies.

 

[Spin]

Gave: Michael Vick, 2012 4th

Got: 2012 2nd, 2012 3rd, Jared Allen

Start 1qb,2rb,3wr,1te,1flex(any),2-3de,2-3lb,2-3db (start 8 idp)

I usually start Rodgers and Flex RG3, so Vick was rotting on my bench, plus he's a free agent at the end of the year, so I only had him for 10 more games anyhow.

My weakest point in my roster atm is my DEs mainly because Trent Cole has done a disappearing act, and I'm in championship mode, and Allen is no slouch. I'll lose Allen at the end of the year, so pretty much he's a rent a DE but getting a young DE is incredibly hard, as owners just do not part with their DEs. For example, Sheard went for a future first at the beginning of the year.

 

[belljr]

I have a trade offer on the table that I really can't figure out. I don't want to post it since it more of a AC question and leaguemates read here also. If I pull the trigger I'll post it but I may send out a couple pm's to people

 

[Concept Coop]

I have a trade offer on the table that I really can't figure out. I don't want to post it since it more of a AC question and leaguemates read here also. If I pull the trigger I'll post it but I may send out a couple pm's to people

I'd be happy to share my opinion, if you want to shoot me a pm.

 

[Donsmith753]

I have a trade offer on the table that I really can't figure out. I don't want to post it since it more of a AC question and leaguemates read here also. If I pull the trigger I'll post it but I may send out a couple pm's to people

Me too

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Big move for me just now. It was tough to do since I'm in win-now mode, but I like it.

Gave:

Hakeem Nicks

Steven Jackson/Daryl Richardson/Isaiah Pead

Got:

Eric Decker

Jonathon Stewart

Jon Baldwin

Pierre Thomas

2013 2nd

2013 3rd

 

[EBF]

14 team .5/1/1.5 ppr. Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR/TE, 2 FLEX.

Team A gives: RB DeAngelo Williams

Team B gives: WR Chris Givens

 

[HAM]

12 TM PPR 1/2/3/1 2Flex

Not involved. Team A total rebuild. Team B win now

Team A gave up:

Manning, Peyton DEN QB

Armstrong, Anthony MIA WR

Year 2013 Round 5 Draft Pick from Team A

Team B gave up:

Richardson, Daryl STL RB

Randle, Rueben NYG WR

Year 2013 Round 2 Draft Pick from Team B

 

[Dawg Pound 69]

Two trades in 12-team PPR :

Team A gets Josh Gordon

Team B gets Frank Gore

Team B is contender, Team A is not.

Team C gets CJ Spiller

Team D gets Mike Wallace

Both teams are contenders, and traded from strength to upgrade weakness in starting lineup.

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team PPR

Team A gives:

Stafford & Marshall

Team B gives:

RG3 & Wallace

Thoughts?

 

[Tanner9919]

10-team non-PPR league (non-PPR for Rb's, that is, only pts per rush,rec yards and TDs)

traded Flacco and T. Richardson

for

Ray Rice and C. Ponder.

by the looks of it, I made out , big time...Ponder is 12th best QB in our league, ahead of Flacco.

Rice is #3 RB , Richardson is a distant 11th..and now hurt.

 

[Concept Coop]

12 team PPR Team A gives:Stafford & MarshallTeam B gives:RG3 & WallaceThoughts?

Give me the RG3 side. Only one of these guys is a startup first round pick. The difference bewteen Marshall and Wallace is much smaller than that of RG3/Stafford.

 

[I was in the pool]

Gave (PPR), 12 teams

CJ2k

little

1st (6-12)

2nd early

2nd early

Received

Shady

Snelling

I am pretty stacked and needed RB to pair with TRich, other team was rebuilding and now has 5 picks on the first 18 or so this coming draft. Course a 24YO top RB can definitely be a cornerstone piece to rebuilding....

 

[Nacca]

Charles and a 3rd

For

Martin and a 1st

Which side wins?

 

[renesauz]

Charles and a 3rd

For

Martin and a 1st

Which side wins?

Sometimes, neither or both. I disagree with the idea that most trades should have a "winner" and a "loser". Good trades are win-win.In this case, I like Charles and a 3rd for a win now team but like Martin and the 1st for a rebuild.

 

[The Captain]

12 team PPR

Team A gave Kenny Britt

Team B gave Torrey Smith

 

[Nacca]

Charles and a 3rd

For

Martin and a 1st

Which side wins?

Sometimes, neither or both. I disagree with the idea that most trades should have a "winner" and a "loser". Good trades are win-win.In this case, I like Charles and a 3rd for a win now team but like Martin and the 1st for a rebuild.

I agree with you. One contributing factor is the guy with Charles rbs all has bye weeks

 

[Nucker101]

Gave (PPR), 12 teamsCJ2klittle1st (6-12)2nd early2nd earlyReceivedShadySnellingI am pretty stacked and needed RB to pair with TRich, other team was rebuilding and now has 5 picks on the first 18 or so this coming draft. Course a 24YO top RB can definitely be a cornerstone piece to rebuilding....

Well done.

 

[pacman_fl]

That time of year for some honest assessments. The following 3 were over the last week:

16 team IDP/53 man rosters/PPR/start 1 RB, 3 WR, 1 R/W

Contending team got Ray Rice

Rebuilding team got Julio and Jon Stewart

12 team .5/1/1.5 PPR 30 man rosters start 2/3, superflex

Contending team got Calvin

Rebuilding team got Doug Martin, Jordy, two 2013 2nds, 2014 1st

12 team PPR - both teams contending with different needs

Team A got Sproles

Team B got Reggie Wayne

 

[Coeur de Lion]

Jonathan Stewart and 2 2013 2nds (probably one early, one late)

for

Steve Johnson

12 team 1/2/3/1/1 flex PPR

 

[Dr. Octopus]

12 team PPR Team A gives:Stafford & MarshallTeam B gives:RG3 & WallaceThoughts?

Not sure why Team B would do that. Marshall and Wallace are a virtual wash. RGIII certainly has more trade value thatn Stafford right now - even if you think Stafford will turn things back around.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Gave:

Jon Baldwin

Jarius Wright

Got:

Andrew Hawkins

Andre Roberts

2013 2nd

 

[King of the Jungle]

Gave:Jon BaldwinJarius WrightGot:Andrew HawkinsAndre Roberts2013 2nd

I would like getting Baldwin for that personally.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Gave:Jon BaldwinJarius WrightGot:Andrew HawkinsAndre Roberts2013 2nd

I would like getting Baldwin for that personally.

I think many people will feel that way. He's certainly got all the tools. But I love Hawkins.

 

[King of the Jungle]

Gave:Jon BaldwinJarius WrightGot:Andrew HawkinsAndre Roberts2013 2nd

I would like getting Baldwin for that personally.

I think many people will feel that way. He's certainly got all the tools. But I love Hawkins.

Hawkins is dynamic with the ball in his hands, just prefer the ceiling of Baldwin.

 

[Inspiration]

Gave:

Jon Baldwin

Jarius Wright

Got:

Andrew Hawkins

Andre Roberts

2013 2nd

I would like getting Baldwin for that personally.

I think many people will feel that way. He's certainly got all the tools. But I love Hawkins.

Except any semblance of short-area explosiveness or quicks. Contrary to popular belief, good height and a decent 40 time ≠ "all the tools". Hawkins has no less ability than Baldwin, just a different skill set.

 

[Tau837]

MOX league: 14 teams, non PPR, start 1Q/2R/2WT/2F/1K/1D (WR=TE)

Gave up:

Ballard, Vick IND RB

Jackson, Vincent TBB WR

Hernandez, Aaron NEP TE

Year 2013 Round 2 Draft Pick

Got:

Nicks, Hakeem NYG WR

Currently tied for 2nd best record and 2nd in points by just a few points, so the 2nd round pick should be late. Also opened up two roster spots and added Foles in one of them.

 

[EBF]

Gave:Jon BaldwinJarius WrightGot:Andrew HawkinsAndre Roberts2013 2nd

I would like getting Baldwin for that personally.

I think many people will feel that way. He's certainly got all the tools. But I love Hawkins.

Hawkins is dynamic with the ball in his hands, just prefer the ceiling of Baldwin.

I own Baldwin in a lot of leagues, but I actually think Roberts is the best player in that trade. He has looked really good this year. Reminds me of Derrick Mason or a touch of Victor Cruz. If he played in a better offense with a better QB, he could be a really solid scorer. I am still optimistic about Baldwin, but I have cooled on him a bit since the preseason. His height, strength, leaping ability, and ball skills make him really dangerous in certain situations. However, his release off the line of scrimmage is sluggish at times and he is a bit awkward in his route running.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

I would agree about Roberts, except that eventually you'd think that Floyd would come on. And even if ARI runs a lot of 3-wide sets, getting Fitz, Floyd, and Roberts on the field (assuming that Roberts plays slot), they still need to acquire a competent QB...will he be able to make three guys fantasy relevant? These are all questions we can't even begin to answer. Mostly because we don't know what Floyd is yet or what the future holds for ARI at QB.

Then you've also got the potential of Housler waiting to emerge.

 

[EBF]

I would agree about Roberts, except that eventually you'd think that Floyd would come on. And even if ARI runs a lot of 3-wide sets, getting Fitz, Floyd, and Roberts on the field (assuming that Roberts plays slot), they still need to acquire a competent QB...will he be able to make three guys fantasy relevant? These are all questions we can't even begin to answer. Mostly because we don't know what Floyd is yet or what the future holds for ARI at QB.Then you've also got the potential of Housler waiting to emerge.

I agree with all of that, but Roberts's contract only runs through 2013. You can never assume that a player is going to sign elsewhere, but I would venture to guess that Roberts will command significant attention on the free agent market, as good WRs often do. Given that Arizona has a lot of money tied up in Fitzgerald and that they just invested a first rounder in Floyd, I think there's a realistic chance that Roberts will move elsewhere after next season. Not a guarantee by any means, but something to consider.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

I wasn't aware he was home free so soon (maybe), thanks for the info! Of course, they'll probably tender him when the time comes, no?

 

[The Comedian]

12 team PPR league (.5 RB, 1 WR, 1.5 TE), deep starting lineups/flex requirements:

Team A gave:

Reggie Wayne

Anthony Fasano

Team B gave:

DeMarco Murray

Martellus Bennett

 

[moderated]

12 team PPR league (.5 RB, 1 WR, 1.5 TE), deep starting lineups/flex requirements:Team A gave:Reggie WayneAnthony FasanoTeam B gaveeMarco MurrayMartellus Bennett

Basically Wayne for Murray?I don't even like Murray that much but he's worth a lot more then Wayne.

 

[IndyHavoc]

.5 ppr wr/te dynasty. 2-4 team in 2nd year of rebuild.

Gave Welker

Got Lafell + 2013 1st (prob mid, early if I'm lucky...and he is not ).

Really wasted Welker entire year last year, and couldn't stomach watching it go

to waste again. I think it's a meh deal, but shows kinda what I thought his worth is

to a team pushing into the playoffs.

 

[Winning IS Everything]

Made both of these trades in the last two days, with value and end of season schedule in mind.....

Gave: Marshawn Lynch and San Diego Def

Got: Branden Bolden, 2013 1st Rounder (likely in the 5-8 range)and Houston D

Gave: Ahmad Bradshaw

Got: Reggie Bush

Was not sure about the Lynch trade, but that now gives me 3 first rounders next year, and I can go hard after a Top 5 RB.

The Bush deal was done solely due to Bush's cake playoff schedule and Bradshaw's foot problems.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

Made both of these trades in the last two days, with value and end of season schedule in mind.....Gave: Marshawn Lynch and San Diego DefGot: Branden Bolden, 2013 1st Rounder (likely in the 5-8 range)and Houston DGave: Ahmad BradshawGot: Reggie BushWas not sure about the Lynch trade, but that now gives me 3 first rounders next year, and I can go hard after a Top 5 RB.The Bush deal was done solely due to Bush's cake playoff schedule and Bradshaw's foot problems.

That's a pretty cheap price for lynch. I couldn't have given him up for a mid first in a bad draft class, an upgrade at defense and bolden. In fact, now that I actually wrote that out I like it even less

 

[Concept Coop]

Gave: Marshawn Lynch and San Diego DefGot: Branden Bolden, 2013 1st Rounder (likely in the 5-8 range)and Houston D

PPR?If so, still sold low. If standard, I would have turned down double that.

 

[Punch]

My fingers feel dirty typing this;

This trade just went down in a league I'm in;

RGIII

D'Quell Jackson

Kirkpatrick

for:

Bradford

Meuluga

D Landry

Late 1st

Late 2nd

Late 3rd

Don't know why a rebuild team would want to move RGIII, for a scrap heap at that.

 

[cstu]

Gave: Marshawn Lynch and San Diego DefGot: Branden Bolden, 2013 1st Rounder (likely in the 5-8 range)and Houston D

PPR?If so, still sold low. If standard, I would have turned down double that.

I'm just not a fan of Lynch and he has a very tough schedule - including the Cardinals and 49ers during the playoffs week 14 and 16 - but I think it's selling too low. Almost everyone considers him a top 15 RB so he should be worth a couple of firsts, or at least a very high one.

 

[FUBAR]

.5 ppr wr/te dynasty. 2-4 team in 2nd year of rebuild.Gave WelkerGot Lafell + 2013 1st (prob mid, early if I'm lucky...and he is not ).Really wasted Welker entire year last year, and couldn't stomach watching it goto waste again. I think it's a meh deal, but shows kinda what I thought his worth isto a team pushing into the playoffs.

Seems a horrible trade giving Welker for that. But it can be very difficult to get good value for older players.