2019 rookie rankings Post NFL draft pick 2.06 (1 Viewer)

[Biabreakable]

The purpose of these polls is to get an idea of who the majority of voters prefer at a specific pick in a rookie draft. These drafts assume that all 2019 rookie players are available. For the 2QB poll there may be some variance in scoring. Some may be standard, others PPR. I think a lot of 2QB leagues may involve IDP as well so these differences are not accounted for here. Only looking at the offensive skill players in the two most common formats and also 2QB leagues, to get a sense of where the QB are valued relative to other positions, when there is actually scarcity at the QB position. For the TE premium poll this assumes the scoring format is PPR because that is what these leagues almost always are. The polls assume 12 teams and likely 24-26 roster spots as the most common format for dynasty. Short bench dynasty leagues should only care about the top 6-12 rookie players.

 If a player isn't listed that you would vote for please vote other and then post the name of the player that you voted for so that player can be added to the next poll. Also please suggest players not listed that you would vote for soon, even if not on the particular poll that is active.

I don't have any lists to follow for populating the poll, so I will just add players based off their draft position for now. As always I appreciate suggestions of players you think should be listed in a poll.

Thanks everyone for voting. Discussion welcome.

Results so far

Standard

1.01 Josh Jacobs RB Raiders 72% of the vote

1.02 NKeal Harry Patriots 32% of the vote

1.03 David Montgomery RB Bears 26% of the vote

1.04 Miles Sanders RB Eagles 50% of the vote

1.05 DK Metcalf WR Seahawks 25% of the vote

1.06 AJ Brown WR Titans 16% of the vote

1.07 Deebo Samuel WR 49ers 21% of the vote

1.08 TJ Hockenson TE Lions 26% of the vote

1.09 1 Kyler Murray QB Cardinals 21% of the vote

1.10 Noah Fant TE Broncos 23% of the vote

1.11 Darrell Henderson RB Rams 31% of the vote

1.12 Paris Campbell WR Colts 22% of the vote

2.01 Marquise Brown WR Ravens 47% of the vote

2.02 Mecole Hardman WR Chiefs 28% of the vote

2.03 Damien Harris RB Patriots 16% of the vote

2.04 JJ Acrega Whiteside WR Eagles 27% of the vote

2.05 Hakeem Butler WR Cardinals 27% of the vote

PPR

1.01 Josh Jacobs RB Raiders 68% of the vote

1.02 NKeal Harry WR Patriots 71% of the vote

1.03 Miles Sanders RB Eagles 29% of the vote

1.04 David Montgomery RB Bears 44% of the vote

1.05 DK Metcalf WR Seahawks 31% of the vote

1.06 AJ Brown WR Titans 30% of the vote

1.07 Deebo Samuel WR 49ers 32% of the vote

1.08 TJ Hockenson TE Lions 26% of the vote

1.09 59 Paris Campbell WR Colts 25% of the vote

1.10 Marquise Brown WR Ravens 33% of the vote

1.11 Darrell Henderson RB Rams 27% of the vote

1.12 Kyler Murray QB Cardinals 29% of the vote

2.01 Noah Fant TE Broncos 45% of the vote

2.02 Mecole Hardman WR Chiefs 25% of the vote

2.03 JJ Acrega Whiteside WR Eagles 38% of the vote

2.04 Andy Isabella WR Cardinals 33% of the vote

2.05 Hakeem Butler WR Cardinals 35% of the vote

2QB

1.01 Kyler Murray QB Cardinals 57% of the vote

1.02 Josh Jacobs RB Raiders 35% of the vote

1.03 NKeal Harry WR Patriots 21% of the vote

1.04  Dwayne Haskins QB Redskins 23% of the vote

1.05 David Montgomery RB Bears 20% of the vote

1.06 Miles Sanders RB Eagles 29% of the vote

1.07  DK Metcalf WR Seahawks 13% of the vote

1.08 AJ Brown WR Titans 16% of the vote (tie with TJ Hockenson broken based on the standard and PPR polls)

1.09 8 TJ Hockenson TE Lions 15% of the vote (confirms tie with AJ Brown)

1.10 Daniel Jones QB Giants 16% of the vote

1.11 Drew Lock QB Broncos 18% of the vote

1.12 Deebo Samuel WR 49ers 24% of the vote

2.01 Darrell Henderson RB Rams 22% of the vote

2.02 Paris Campbell WR Colts 22% of the vote

2.03 Marquise Brown WR Ravens 24% of the vote

2.04 Noah Fant TE Broncos 27% of the vote

2.05 JJ Acrega Whiteside WR Eagles 11% of the vote (tie with Hakeem Butler and Damien Harris broken based on PPR poll)

TE premium

1.01 Josh Jacobs RB Raiders 52% of the vote

1.02 NKeal Harry Patriots 31% of the vote

1.03 TJ Hockenson TE Lions 27% of the vote

1.04 Noah Fant TE Broncos 23% of the vote

1.05 Miles Sanders RB Eagles 27% of the vote

1.06 David Montgomery RB Bears 33% of the vote

1.07  DK Metcalf WR Seahawks 15% of the vote

1.08 Irv SMith TE Vikings 16% of the vote

1.09 AJ Brown WR Titans with 13% of the vote (tie with Kyler Murray broken based on PPR poll)

1.10 Kyler Murray QB Cardinals 21% of the vote (confirms tie with AJ Brown)

1.11 Deebo Samuel WR 49ers 20% of the vote

1.12 Paris Campbell WR Colts 22% of the vote

2.01 Marquise Brown WR Ravens 22% of the vote

2.02 Jace Sternberger TE Packers 25% of the vote

2.03 Darrell Henderson RB Rams 30% of the vote

2.04 Mecole Hardman WR Chiefs 15% of the vote

2.05 Damien Harris RB Patriots 13% of the vote (tie with Hakeem Burler broken based on standard poll)

Links to previous polls

1.01

1.02

1.03

1.04

1.05

1.06

1.07

1.08

1.09

1.10

1.11

1.12

2.01

2.02

2.03

2.04

2.05

 

[Biabreakable]

Some interesting action occurring in the standard poll where with 14 votes in Andy Isabella has 50% of them.

Hakeem Butler Isabellas team mate won the previous poll with 27% of the vote. Isabella had 13% of the vote when I closed the poll.

Isabella was drafted before Hakeem Butler in the NFL and some such as Pff think very highly of Isabella.

I am one of the folks who voted for Butler over Isabella although to be honest I could see going either way here. I choose Butler mostly because of what I have seen of him in cut ups. I love how he can just Moss people and his run after the catch ability is outstanding for a player his size. I don't like the drops but I have seen most of them and analyzed what happened on each of these drops I came across. I don't think his hands are bad like Sammie Coates. I think he doesn't use good hands technique on some of them and that defenders are able to disrupt him on others. Butler can track the ball and catch over his shoulder though. He can make some outstanding catches as well.

Isabella has small hands and struggles to high point the ball,

They are really different players and I think both of them could be starting for the Cardinals soon. They are so different from each other I don't really see them as in direct competition for opportunities. I think Isabella has to compete with Christan Kirk for opportunities more so than Butler does.

Just curious to hear others thoughts on this including why I am crazy for thinking Butler is a better WR than Isabella for FF.

 

[Miro Z]

Some interesting action occurring in the standard poll where with 14 votes in Andy Isabella has 50% of them.

Hakeem Butler Isabellas team mate won the previous poll with 27% of the vote. Isabella had 13% of the vote when I closed the poll.

Isabella was drafted before Hakeem Butler in the NFL and some such as Pff think very highly of Isabella.

I am one of the folks who voted for Butler over Isabella although to be honest I could see going either way here. I choose Butler mostly because of what I have seen of him in cut ups. I love how he can just Moss people and his run after the catch ability is outstanding for a player his size. I don't like the drops but I have seen most of them and analyzed what happened on each of these drops I came across. I don't think his hands are bad like Sammie Coates. I think he doesn't use good hands technique on some of them and that defenders are able to disrupt him on others. Butler can track the ball and catch over his shoulder though. He can make some outstanding catches as well.

Isabella has small hands and struggles to high point the ball,

They are really different players and I think both of them could be starting for the Cardinals soon. They are so different from each other I don't really see them as in direct competition for opportunities. I think Isabella has to compete with Christan Kirk for opportunities more so than Butler does.

Just curious to hear others thoughts on this including why I am crazy for thinking Butler is a better WR than Isabella for FF.

My understanding of the "Air Raid" offense is that it likes to use two speed guys on the inside (presumably Kirk and Isabella) and bigger guys on the outside.

When I see Isabella speeding up the middle I have visions of Tyreek Hill escaping from DBs for long TDs. That may be over-optimistic but the Cards are trying to emulate the Chiefs with a high-volume, high-octane passing attack featuring a mobile big-armed QB and lots of speed at WR.

 

[Biabreakable]

My understanding of the "Air Raid" offense is that it likes to use two speed guys on the inside (presumably Kirk and Isabella) and bigger guys on the outside.

When I see Isabella speeding up the middle I have visions of Tyreek Hill escaping from DBs for long TDs. That may be over-optimistic but the Cards are trying to emulate the Chiefs with a high-volume, high-octane passing attack featuring a mobile big-armed QB and lots of speed at WR.

Makes sense to me. That is what Isabella is good at. Very fast  I don't think he runs the drag routes and so on as well as Kirk does. So I wonder at what kind of targets and how many are going where?

Isabella won the PPR poll before Butler so I'm guessing voters think he will be more valuable in that format while Butler more valuable in standard.

That suggests people think Butler will score more TD while Isabella has more receptions and yardage, but that otherwise they are close to the same value.

I happened to be looking at a DLF poll similar to this one and their poll had these 2 WR back to back as well. 

 

[Biabreakable]

With 20 votes in it looks like Isabella could win 3 of the polls he is available. He is tied with Harris in the 2QB poll and tied with opportunity Knox in the TE premium poll. 

In the PPR poll Deontae Johnson is ahead of Harris by one vote.

 

[Hankmoody]

Some interesting action occurring in the standard poll where with 14 votes in Andy Isabella has 50% of them.

Hakeem Butler Isabellas team mate won the previous poll with 27% of the vote. Isabella had 13% of the vote when I closed the poll.

Isabella was drafted before Hakeem Butler in the NFL and some such as Pff think very highly of Isabella. 

I am one of the folks who voted for Butler over Isabella although to be honest I could see going either way here. I choose Butler mostly because of what I have seen of him in cut ups. I love how he can just Moss people and his run after the catch ability is outstanding for a player his size. I don't like the drops but I have seen most of them and analyzed what happened on each of these drops I came across. I don't think his hands are bad like Sammie Coates. I think he doesn't use good hands technique on some of them and that defenders are able to disrupt him on others. Butler can track the ball and catch over his shoulder though. He can make some outstanding catches as well.

Isabella has small hands and struggles to high point the ball,

They are really different players and I think both of them could be starting for the Cardinals soon. They are so different from each other I don't really see them as in direct competition for opportunities. I think Isabella has to compete with Christan Kirk for opportunities more so than Butler does.

Just curious to hear others thoughts on this including why I am crazy for thinking Butler is a better WR than Isabella for FF.

I prefer Butler because I think Isabella's ceiling is capped.  I think Isabella turns into a solid PPR option but another WR2-3 doesn't excite me, I'll take the shot on the guy that could be a WR1 every time.

 

[Biabreakable]

Isabella and Butler are both still available in the 2QB poll and are currently tied with Harris for winning that poll.

Isabellas lead has slipped slightly in the standard poll.

The voting on these has gotten so slow now I am not sure how much further this will go.

 

[Faust]

Isabella and Butler are both still available in the 2QB poll and are currently tied with Harris for winning that poll.

Isabellas lead has slipped slightly in the standard poll.

The voting on these has gotten so slow now I am not sure how much further this will go.

I’d welcome a 2.07 poll - training camps are opening soon, so I can’t see there being too many more polls left on our horizon. Many thanks for running these polls!

 

[Biabreakable]

I’d welcome a 2.07 poll - training camps are opening soon, so I can’t see there being too many more polls left on our horizon. Many thanks for running these polls!

Yep this kind of thing is about to get buried once there is actually news to talk about again.

I will see how it goes, would like to do 2.07 as well. This poll in particular has been very very slow though.

 

[Biabreakable]

No 2.07?

I dont believe in closing a poll that has fewer than 40 votes. It used to be 50 votes.

As you can see this poll has been open for two weeks now. 33 votes, Sick of bumping a thread where no one votes so I moved on.