ICON211
Footballguy
I think it's fair to throw out the teams that took QBs. I don't think it's fair to throw out the others because of the current performance of who they did take or the position. The way I look at it the teams that passed on him were:Most of the other teams that passed on Carter had good reason. Carolina, Houston, and Indy drafted highly rated QBs, the most important position in the NFL. Houston chose Will Anderson over Carter which wasn’t a bad choice at the time. Anderson is doing ok and was highly rated and healthy at draft day. Cards took the best OT in the draft which is another very important position. Seattle landed a great CB and Witherspoon is already having a great season. Even though he is a CB, he has more sacks, tackles, and QB pressures in 4 games than our rookie DE will likely have all season.Seven teams passed on Carter and none of them had nearly the reason to that the Raiders did.Choosing to draft an inferior player is never the correct decision. Why must it happen year after year?I wanted Carter as much as anyone, if not more, but why not take a project if you're not going to contend this season? If he's the next Greg Townsend we'll all be thrilled with that.which is why our team sucks year in and year out, you don't waste a top 10 pick on a project player that needs years to develop (injury recovery included).The more I think about it, the Tyree Wilson pick was a long view, big picture move. We may not like the pick (for the record, I don’t) but they aren’t dumb. They knew he was injured, to an extent, he was going to be a project. I don’t think they expected him to play much at all for at least the first half of the season. The Chan Jones fiasco has thrust Wilson into playing a lot sooner than McD, Graham and Ziegler all expected. Wilson is also a red flashing sign to me that this regime made that pick knowing they weren’t going anywhere for at least a couple years unless things went horribly wrong. Just my opinion and thoughts on Wilson, I hope he gets it together soon because it would be nice for Maxx to get some help.We had a chance earlier this year and wouldn’t need to be imagining right now. Great players fall into the lap of LV during the draft year after year but they pass on them for inferior players. It’s not a great model for any sports team.Guess who is the AFC Defensive Player of the Week?
Imagine if we had someone that brought half of what he does on the defense with him.![]()
I would have been thrilled if they landed Anthony Richardson and he's as big a project as they come.
If he bombs he's no worse than any other highly drafted bomb.
The bar is low in Las Vegas, I think it was a huge win just to draft a guy that everyone outside the organization didn't immediately recognize as a huge reach.
I, for one, welcome our new future Greg Townsend.
We all wanted him and we all understand why the Raiders didn't draft him. Maybe it's time to get over it.
The Raiders made the decision to build on the lines which is something that we all agree with, or at least most of us do, and they took the guy that virtually everybody agreed was the best defensive end in the draft.
And, before we start drawing conclusions after five games about who's superior and who's inferior can we please remember that Jalen Carter ended up on the team that led the league in sacks last year and Wilson ended up on the team that finished 30th. So maybe Carter has a little bit more help surrounding him to start his career.
Essentially, two teams passed on Carter and there is no excuse for either. We know the Raiders mistake and Atlanta made almost as big of a mistake in drafting Robinson. The well-run teams in the NFL don’t draft a RB in round one, no matter how highly rated. Period.
LV and Atlanta passed on Carter and should not be forgiven for their poor decisions. Maybe Atlanta is following the LV playbook and knowingly choosing inferior players because they are saving their good picks for later. I think that was the story being fed here which is quite comical.
Texans - I thought Carter and Anderson were the top two players and i can't fault them for taking Anderson
Seahawks - Could def have used a DT but went CB instead
Cards - Needed everything but passed. Johnson was some people's top tackle, but this was a down year for OT and there was no consensus top OL.
Raiders - sigh
Falcons - I thought it was madness not to take Carter. Allgeier looked really good last year.
Bears - Another poorly run, bad team making another mistake trading out of the pick and not taking Carter

