What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

2024-2025 NBA Who’d He Play For Draft/Auction - Sign Up Now! (1 Viewer)

Yo Mama

Footballguy
Trying something new this year since I don’t feel like sorting through salaries and constantly making updates as NBA teams make changes.

This year, we’ll draft based on where the players played before entering the NBA. But wait, there’s more - to make things more confusing, we’ll also be auctioning for draft order each round*. We’re not done - to make things even more unpredictable, I’ll be rolling dice before each round* to determine which player bucket we will be drafting from. * = pending a vote on format in the second post.

Team Setup
- 12 rounds of drafting
- You need to have at least one player from each of our eight buckets (see below)
- You can not have more than two players from any bucket

Player Buckets
- ACC
- Big-10
- Big-12
- PAC-12
- SEC
- Big East + WCC
- Other US college + HS + G League
- Foreign

Bucket Eligibility
- There are 8 player buckets based on where they played prior to the NBA (per NBA dot com)
- I looked at a few different sets of rankings to get the buckets as balanced as possible
- Conferences are based on last year’s conferences so UCLA is in PAC-12 and Oklahoma is in Big-12
- If a player transferred colleges, he is only eligible for the last school he attended
- If a foreign born player went to a US college, they get bucketed with the college and are not considered foreign
- If a US born player played overseas rather than go to a US college, he is considered in the foreign bucket
- I believe the G League designation is for players who went directly to the G League instead of college. This includes a few foreign born players. It does not include players who were drafted out of college and were later sent down to the G League.
- On the draft workbook, I will have a tab with all the player buckets so there is less confusion (LOL I almost said no confusion)
- I made the player bucket list last week based on official rosters as of that time. Any players not on this list can be added, but must use the NBA dot com designation for Who’d He Play For.

Pre-Draft Random Dice Roll
- Before each round*, I will roll the dice to determine which bucket we will be drafting from
- Once we draft from a bucket twice, that bucket will be closed

Draft Order Auction
- Everyone gets $1000 to bid on draft order
- After the bucket for each round* is set, we will do a blind auction for draft order
- Everyone will PM me their bids and I will PM one lucky volunteer to send my bid to
- Highest bidder drafts first that round, lowest bidder goes last
- Bids need to leave enough $ remaining for at least $1 for all remaining rounds (no bidding in cents or fractions)
- Ties go to the person with the most remaining funds, then a dice roll if that is tied

Other
- As usual, I’m hoping we won’t need to set a timer on drafting. We’ve been pretty good in the past with this. I retain the right to change my mind if this whole mess takes months to complete.
- I’ll set up a workbook for the draft once we figure everything out and know how many participants we have. I might need someone to help automate some things.
- If we have lots of drafters, I may consolidate a couple of the buckets that are less deep.

I may have been slightly under the influence when thinking this ludicrous process up, so I am willing to make any tweaks as needed for things that are too crazy.

Join now!!!
 
Ok, here are the options for the draft process. Thanks for the suggestion @Gally but I think that’s way too complicated.

Option 1 - Original Draft/Auction Format
- Roll dice for bucket we are drafting from
- Auction off draft spots (highest bidder goes first, lowest goes last)

Option 2 - Straight Draft with Dice
- Roll dice two times before each odd-numbered round to determine the player buckets for the next two rounds
- Set draft order for for the next two rounds randomly (serpentine). This can also be done via auction for an Option 1.5.
- Drafters need to pick one player from each bucket in the next two rounds, in whatever order they want.
- EXAMPLE - Before the 1st round, we roll the dice and land on the ACC and SEC buckets. We then randomly determine the draft order for the first two rounds (serpentine). In the first and second rounds you have to pick one player from each bucket.

Option 3 - Straight Draft, No Dice
- Determine draft order for whole draft (serpentine, third round reversal)
- Everyone drafts whoever they want, but need to fill all the roster/bucket requirements by the end of the draft.

Let me know what you think.
 
Last edited:
Do we need to build a table of players and which bucket they fall into in advance? I'll be glad to help if we're talking about pulilng down some data and formatting a couple of columns. I'm pretty good at that.
 
Do we need to build a table of players and which bucket they fall into in advance? I'll be glad to help if we're talking about pulilng down some data and formatting a couple of columns. I'm pretty good at that.
I’ve got one built out that we can all use based on the rosters as of last week. I’ll put it in the shared draft file.
 
I still don't understand what we are doing here but it involves hoops so of course I'm going to think I'm 100% right on everything.
 
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 33 33 33 33 3 3 3 3 33 33 3 3 33 3 3 33 33 33 3 3 3 3 37

5

2

4 13

37

3

3 3 3 1

36

10 11 19

17 32 18 14 13 16 12 11 10 10 9 9 9 15 35 34

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 11 11 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 33 33 3 3 3 3 3 33

22

21 19 20 21 21

31

3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 3 3 33 33 33 33

29 27 28 25

26

23 23 24

22 30
 
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 33 33 33 33 3 3 3 3 33 33 3 3 33 3 3 33 33 33 3 3 3 3 37

5

2

4 13

37

3

3 3 3 1

36

10 11 19

17 32 18 14 13 16 12 11 10 10 9 9 9 15 35 34

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 11 11 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 33 33 3 3 3 3 3 33

22

21 19 20 21 21

31

3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 33 3 3 3 3 33 33 33 33

29 27 28 25

26

23 23 24

22 30
Awesome! Draft order is set, everyone.
 
you know what f it im in i will not understand 95 percent of this but hell if i wont give it a run the only caveat is that i am only here in spurts like one or two times a day so i might slow it all down take that to the bank bromigos
 
you know what f it im in i will not understand 95 percent of this but hell if i wont give it a run the only caveat is that i am only here in spurts like one or two times a day so i might slow it all down take that to the bank bromigos
I usually put my phone number in the draft spreadsheet and people will text me when I'm up. You could try that as well. Plus now I get a nice random richard pic from time to time - not going to say who from. Bonus!
 
you know what f it im in i will not understand 95 percent of this but hell if i wont give it a run the only caveat is that i am only here in spurts like one or two times a day so i might slow it all down take that to the bank bromigos
Awesome! If you’re not around we can always pick someone for you like Bronny or kobme’s buff kin, broseph.
 
Draft Order Auction
- Everyone gets $1000 to bid on draft order
- After the bucket for each round* is set, we will do a blind auction for draft order
- Everyone will PM me their bids and I will PM one lucky volunteer to send my bid to
- Highest bidder drafts first that round, lowest bidder goes last
- Bids need to leave enough $ remaining for at least $1 for all remaining rounds (no bidding in cents or fractions)
- Ties go to the person with the most remaining funds, then a dice roll if that is tied
make it more complicated (and interesting) and instead of just placing a bid you are bidding on a particular draft slot. If nobody else bids on that slot you get it. If 5 people draft on the same slot then the top bid gets the slot and the 2nd highest gets the next highest slot available and so on and so forth.

So if you don't want to be in a bidding war then you put $1 on slot 7. It might increase the strategery as you can potentially save money in places to use elsewhere.


ETA: If you want I can be the draft order commish and have everyone send me their bids and I can organize it. Since I am not drafting I don't have to bid on anything.
 
Draft Order Auction
- Everyone gets $1000 to bid on draft order
- After the bucket for each round* is set, we will do a blind auction for draft order
- Everyone will PM me their bids and I will PM one lucky volunteer to send my bid to
- Highest bidder drafts first that round, lowest bidder goes last
- Bids need to leave enough $ remaining for at least $1 for all remaining rounds (no bidding in cents or fractions)
- Ties go to the person with the most remaining funds, then a dice roll if that is tied
make it more complicated (and interesting) and instead of just placing a bid you are bidding on a particular draft slot. If nobody else bids on that slot you get it. If 5 people draft on the same slot then the top bid gets the slot and the 2nd highest gets the next highest slot available and so on and so forth.

So if you don't want to be in a bidding war then you put $1 on slot 7. It might increase the strategery as you can potentially save money in places to use elsewhere.


ETA: If you want I can be the draft order commish and have everyone send me their bids and I can organize it. Since I am not drafting I don't have to bid on anything.
So if 5 people bid on the first pick, and only one person each bids on picks 2-10, the second highest bidder for pick #1 gets bumped down to pick #11?

I think I like the idea of ordering things for the whole round by bids and trying to strategically figure out how much to bid if you want a specific spot.

I’ll definitely hit you up to help with the draft order if you’re interested.
 
I’ll get my scenarios out there tonight or tomorrow so we can decide on the overall process. I’m also rethinking the buckets to make things more balanced (a couple buckets are pretty shallow for good players).
 
So if 5 people bid on the first pick, and only one person each bids on picks 2-10, the second highest bidder for pick #1 gets bumped down to pick #11?
Yes that would be correct. It makes you really decide how you want to approach bidding realizing this may happen. It adds a ton of strategy and game theory into figuring out your bids and makes it a little more exciting.

The added bonus is you can then save up on your money for a particular bucket if you think there might only be a few worthwhile players in that category so you can save for that while still maybe getting decent picks elsewhere because you bid on the 7th, 4th, and 3rd picks on other buckets.

One other stipulation would be the higher slot you bid on the higher priority you have for next highest available draft slot if you lose. By that I mean if 2 people each bid on 1st, 2nd and 3rd draft slots. The loser of the first slot bid would be slotted in the highest available, the loser of the 2nd draft slot would be slotted in the next highest and etc.

I think it would make the bidding process much more interesting......and I would be happy to help with the logistics of it.
 
Personally I think the whole auction element overcomplicates things and will slow the draft down. The randomized conference thing in combination with a rotating draft order would accomplish pretty much the same thing.

But I'm a dice guy.
 
Personally I think the whole auction element overcomplicates things and will slow the draft down. The randomized conference thing in combination with a rotating draft order would accomplish pretty much the same thing.

But I'm a dice guy.
Agree with the eephus here
 
i dont understand this thing already if we add bidding i am going to blow my entire wad in the first round and just sit back and watch the craziness and after the first round i will have nothing left to take to the bank brokehan
 
Ok, here are the options for the draft process. Thanks for the suggestion @Gally but I think that’s way too complicated.

Option 1 - Original Draft/Auction Format
- Roll dice for bucket we are drafting from
- Auction off draft spots (highest bidder goes first, lowest goes last)

Option 2 - Straight Draft with Dice
- Roll dice two times before each odd-numbered round to determine the player buckets for the next two rounds
- Set draft order for for the next two rounds randomly (serpentine). This can also be done via auction for an Option 1.5.
- Drafters need to pick one player from each bucket in the next two rounds, in whatever order they want.
- EXAMPLE - Before the 1st round, we roll the dice and land on the ACC and SEC buckets. We then randomly determine the draft order for the first two rounds (serpentine). In the first and second rounds you have to pick one player from each bucket.

Option 3 - Straight Draft, No Dice
- Determine draft order for whole draft (serpentine, third round reversal)
- Everyone drafts whoever they want, but need to fill all the roster/bucket requirements by the end of the draft.

Let me know what you think.
Updated draft format options in second post.

Vote as if our democracy depends on it!
 
i dont understand this thing already if we add bidding i am going to blow my entire wad in the first round and just sit back and watch the craziness and after the first round i will have nothing left to take to the bank brokehan
This is my plan as well.
 
Sorry everyone, I’m not sure I have the mental bandwidth to run this thing. If anyone had an idea for a different draft, I’ll probably participate, but I can’t run anything right now. Between my ongoing job search and potentially having to jump into a new internal opportunity I’m interviewing for, I just don’t have it in me to run this right now.

I’ll still do the IST contest because that is easy to set up. I’ll have that out soon.

Sorry again to bow out of this one.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: SWC

Users who are viewing this thread

Top