BobbyLayne
Footballguy
Edge rushers (5)
Aidan Hutchinson, Ezekiel Ansah, Robert Porcher, Cliff Avril, James HallFirst man out: Kyle Vanden Bosch
Thoughts: The Lions have had a few elite edge defenders over the past 25 years. We’ve obviously only seen the tip of the iceberg with Hutchinson. Throughout his three seasons, he’s shown steady improvement, racking up 28.5 sacks in 39 games.
Hutchinson has been the team’s best pass rusher since Ansah, the raw talent Detroit grabbed with the No. 5 pick of the 2013 draft. He dropped opposing passers behind the line 48 times in six seasons, including 14.5 in 2015, earning him second-team All-Pro honors.
Most of Porcher’s production came before 2000, but he still squeezed out a couple of solid years down the stretch, including a Pro Bowl season in 2001, when he recorded 11.0 sacks.
Avril, a third-round selection out of Purdue in 2008, started his career with a modest 10.5 sacks through two seasons before averaging nearly 10 over his final three years with the franchise.
There wasn’t a particularly strong case for a fifth. Still, we found room for Hall, an undrafted signing out of the University of Michigan who played seven seasons with the Lions. A rotational player early in his career, he ultimately started 67 games in Detroit, reaching his peak with an 11.5-sack season in 2004.
Defensive tackles (4)
Ndamukong Suh, Alim McNeill, Shaun Rogers, Luther EllissFirst man out: Corey Redding
Thoughts: Suh is a Hall of Fame-caliber talent who proved worthy of being the No. 2 pick coming out of Nebraska. He earned All-Pro honors four times in five seasons and also netted the Defensive Rookie of the Year award in 2010. His 36.0 sacks in a Lions uniform trail only Ansah and Avril this century.
Rogers isn't far behind with 29.0 sacks, second among defensive tackles. The freakishly athletic nose tackle earned Pro Bowl honors twice in seven seasons with Detroit while racking up 65 tackles for a loss.
McNeill, who had his fourth season derailed by a torn ACL, has developed into a top-10 defensive tackle. Initially a nose to begin his career, he transformed his body, shedding 30 pounds as part of a transition to 3-technique. That's opened up pass-rush opportunities, resulting in 79 pressures and 8.5 sacks across the past two seasons. He's done that while maintaining his stellar reputation as a run-stopper.
Finally, Ellis, like Porcher, had his best years before 2000. Still, there's a Pro Bowl year and 43 starts this century for the man known for getting the home crowd loud in between snaps.
We did give strong consideration to Nick Fairley. The 30-game starter was supremely talented but battled weight and motivation issues that limited his production. Redding also deserves an honorable mention, with 77 starts, 43 TFLs and 16.0 sacks for the Lions.
Linebackers (6)
Stephen Tulloch, D’Andre Levy, Alex Anzalone, Ernie Sims, Tahir Whitehead, Jalen Reeves-MaybinFirst man out: Chris Claiborne
Thoughts: The Lions have had some excellent linebackers this century.
Tulloch and Levy played key roles in the team's first playoff appearance in over a decade, back in 2011. After joining the team as a free agent, Tulloch topped 100 tackles four times during a five-season stretch.
Levy arrived two years earlier via the draft. It took him a couple of seasons to find his groove before he developed into one of the premier coverage linebackers in the league. He recorded 12 interceptions during his career, including six in 2013. He also topped 100 tackles three times, leading the league with 117 solo stops in 2014.
Anzalone, like Tulloch, played a key role in a cultural turnaround. Oft-injured early in his career, Anzalone put most of those issues behind him in Detroit, delivering back-to-back career years in 2022 and 2023, with a combined 254 tackles (14 for a loss), 12 pass breakups and 4.5 sacks.
Sims was a bright spot during a dark era of Lions football. It was always going to be difficult to deliver value as a top-10 pick. Still, he started 50 consecutive games to open his career, topping 100 tackles each of his first three seasons before a regime change facilitated his exit.
Whitehead's inclusion might feel like an upset, but it shouldn't. He started his career as a strong special-teams performer who then transitioned smoothly into the starting lineup after replacing an injured Tulloch in the early stages of the 2014 season. Whitehead would have back-to-back 100-tackle seasons before departing in free agency.
The final spot goes to an All-Pro special teamer in Reeves-Maybin over Claiborne, another top-10 pick with three 100-tackle seasons. His inability to develop into a more effective playmaker led to the Lions allowing him to walk in free agency without much of a fight.
Cornerbacks (6)
Darius Slay, Dre Bly, Chris Houston, Fernando Bryant, Rashean Mathis, Quandre DiggsFirst man out: Jerry Jacobs
Thoughts: Slay would be the No. 1 corner on this roster. The former second-round pick shook off a rocky rookie season to deliver three straight Pro Bowl campaigns, including first-team All-Pro honors in 2017 when he led the league with eight interceptions.
Bly was also a top-tier playmaker after signing with the Lions as a free agent in 2003. In four seasons with the team, he never had fewer than three picks, racking up 19 across the span.
The Lions snagged Houston in a trade from Atlanta for a Day 3 draft pick. That proved to be a steal as he provided 10 interceptions and 45 pass defenses in 54 starts across four seasons before a toe injury prematurely ended his career.
The talent pool starts to thin out from there. Bryant was solid as Bly’s running mate, although injuries limited Bryant to 38 games in four seasons. He did manage to break up 29 passes during that stretch.
Another bargain-bin find, the Lions scooped Mathis off the street during training camp in 2013. It proved fortuitous as he simultaneously replaced the struggling Slay in the starting lineup while mentoring the rookie. Even though Mathis was at the end of his solid career, he still mustered 28 PBUs in 38 games across three seasons.
Diggs is a hybrid defender, having effectively played both nickel and safety during his time with Detroit. Unfortunately, the Lions missed out on his best seasons after the Diet Patriots regime traded him away due to a personality clash.
Safeties (4)
Kerby Joseph, Brian Branch, Glover Quin, Louis DelmasFirst man out: Tracy Walker
Thoughts: Like the running backs, Detroit’s current tandem makes the cut.
Joseph is an easy case with 16 interceptions and first-team All-Pro recognition through his first three seasons. Branch, on the other hand, is extremely versatile and productive, recording 109 tackles (eight for a loss) and four interceptions in his second season.
Quin was a second-team All-Pro in 2014 when he paced the NFL with seven interceptions. One of the most cerebral defenders in Lions history, he picked off 19 passes across six seasons. He also didn’t miss a start during that stretch.
The fourth spot is debatable. Walker and Kennoy Kennedy have strong cases. In and out of the starting lineup during his six seasons with the Lions, Walker’s 398 tackles rank second among Lions safeties in the past 25 years. As for Kennedy, he racked up 253 tackles, 13 pass defenses and four forced fumbles in three seasons after coming over as a free agent from Denver. He’s certainly on the all-name team.
We have Delmas barely edging those two. A second-round pick out of Western Michigan, Delmas ranks third in tackles and second in PBUs among Lions safeties this century. A big hitter who admittedly had some missed tackle issues, he was more impactful than the others against the run, leading his position with 20 tackles for loss.
Specialists (3)
Matt Prater, Jack Fox, Don MuhlbachFirst man out: Jason Hanson
Thoughts: There's not much that can be said against the inclusion of Muhlbach and Fox. Muhlbach held the long-snapping role for much of the quarter-century, appearing in 260 games across 16 seasons.
And Fox is a record-breaking punter who just established the best single-season net average in NFL history.
Kicker is more interesting. Hanson is an undisputed franchise legend who made 83.6% of his field goals from 2000 to his retirement after the 2012 season. However, in seven years with the Lions, Prater was a bit more accurate, hitting 84.4% of his kicks. He also had a stronger leg, making a pair from 59 yards, which exceeded Hanson's career-long by 3 yards.
In terms of kicks from 50 yards and beyond, Hanson made 37 in his final 13 seasons. Prater converted 38 from that distance in a little more than half the games. He also developed a stronger reputation for clutch kicks during his time with the Lions.
