What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

********_______ 2019 Rookie Draft Top 30 _________******** (1 Viewer)

Paulymaggs

Footballguy
Haven't done one of these in a few years. 

Here is my top 30 of 2019 draft eligible guys as of end of November 2018.

Obviously it assumes these true juniors / RS sophomores will declare.

1.  N'Keal Harry  -  ASU  -  WR

2.  AJ Brown  -  Ole Miss  -  WR

3.  Kelvin Harmon  -  NC St.  -  WR

4.  DK Metcalf  -  Ole Miss  -  WR

5.  Bryan Edwards  -  SCarolina  -  WR

6.  Hakeem Butler  -  Iowa St  -  WR

7.  Marquise Brown  -  Oklahoma  -  WR

8.  David Montgomery  -  Iowa St  -  RB

9.  Noah Fant  -  Iowa  -  TE

10.  Damarea Crockett  -  Missouri  -  RB

11.  Bryce Love  -  Stanford  -  RB

12.  Justin Herbert  -  Oregon  -  QB

13.  Kaden Smith  -  Stanford  -  TE

14. JJ Arcega-Whiteside  -  Stanford  -  WR

15.  Devin Singletary  -  FAU  -  RB

16.  Collin Johnson  -  Texas  -  WR

17.  Benny Snell  -  Kentucky  -  RB

18.  Rodney Anderson  -  Oklahoma  -  RB

19.  Lil'Jordan Humphrey  -  Texas  -  WR

20.  Deebo Samuel  -  SCarolina  -  WR

21.  Anthony Johnson  -  Buffalo  -  WR

22.  Preston Williams  -  Colorado St  -  WR

23.  Myles Gaskin  -  Washington  -  RB

24.  David Sills  -  West Virginia  -  WR

25.  Gary Jennings  -  West Virginia  -  WR

26.  Zach Moss  -  Utah  -  RB

27.  Andy Isabella  -  UMass  -  WR

28.  Mike Weber  -  Ohio St  -  RB

29.  Parris Campbell  -  Ohio St  -  WR

30.  Karan Higdon  -  Michigan  -  RB

 

Paulymaggs

Footballguy
AFTER Combine Top 30:

1. Josh Jacobs - Alabama - RB

2. AJ Brown - Ole Miss - WR

3. TJ Hockenson - Iowa - TE

4. DK Metcalf - Ole Miss - WR

5. Rodney Anderson - Oklahoma - RB

6. Hakeem Butler - Iowa St - WR

7. Marquise Brown - Oklahoma - WR

8. David Montgomery - Iowa St - RB

9. Noah Fant - Iowa - TE

10. Justice Hill - Oklahoma St. - RB

11. N'Keal Harry - ASU - WR

12. Miles Sanders - Penn St. - RB

13. Terry McLaurin - Ohio St. - WR

14. Darrell Henderson - Memphis - RB

15. Kyler Murray - Oklahoma - QB

16. Deebo Samuel - SCarolina - WR

17. Irv Smith - Alabama - TE

18. Parris Campbell - Ohio St - WR

19. JJ Arcega-Whiteside - Stanford - WR

20. Myles Boykin - Notre Dame - WR

21. Anthony Johnson - Buffalo - WR

22. Preston Williams - Colorado St - WR

23. Bryce Love - Stanford - RB

24. Emanuel Hall - Missouri - WR

25. Alex Barnes - Kansas St. - RB

26. Devin Singletary - FAU - RB

27. Andy Isabella - UMass - WR

28. Mike Weber - Ohio St - RB

29. Benny Snell - Kentucky - RB

30. Jace Sternberger - Texas A&M - TE

 

Interseptopus

Footballguy
How does Rodney Anderson go up 13 spots after doing absolutely nothing?

Harry drops after showing he is actually faster than people thought, and did really well on his pro day in the 3 cone? 

Andy Isabella 27? should be a 1st round/high 2nd rookie pick

 
Last edited by a moderator:

SayWhat?

Footballguy
2 of your top 3 weren’t even in your top 30 pre combine? 
I thought the same thing, but I suppose there’s a chance he didn’t think those two were declaring because there wasn’t talk of them declaring back when his original list was posted?  They certainly weren’t hyped back then, and probably weren’t listed in many people’s rankings at that stage.

 

Zyphros

Footballguy
The top12 guys all seem to be the top12 guys (other than Justice Hill for me, but I can see a case for him there), I just feel like you ordered them in a contrarian view on purpose rather than actually rank them.  Appreciate the list though.  

 

JohnnyU

Footballguy
I can admit I was a little abrasive in my first post, but it's interesting you say this when weve had some very knowledgeable conversations between the two of us this offseason and we agree on a lot of players and our rankings of them. I think we have nearly identical rankings actually, in spite of what you may think my rankings are (have to protect against leaguemates)

If you care to critique my analysis of the players in question feel free. 

I'd be happy to discuss reasons why he would take Rodney Anderson 1.5
I enjoy banter back and forth with you on these prospects, but you do seem to put more players in the 1st round than are physically possible over a period of time.  I guarantee you Isabella won't go in the 1st round of most dynasty drafts.  I was slammed for having him at 2.11, but I have to ask, do you honestly think he will be drafted in the early 2nd?  I just don't see him going before players like M Brown, Sanders,  Ridley, Harris, or Irv Smith.  So where would he go except mid to late 2nd round?

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top