I don't see size being a problem. He's 5'10" and 207 pounds. That puts him in the same ballpark as Tiki Barber, Clinton Portis, Reggie Bush, Maurice Drew, Priest Holmes, Curtis Martin, and Julius Jones.
Almost all of those backs looked more explosive to me coming out of college.(don't remember a lot about Priest and I wasn't very high on Julius Jones)
10 more pounds would be ideal, but 207 is plenty heavy for a featured back.
Not for a runner with Pittman's marginal skillset. See your next point.
The real issue for me is that Pittman just doesn't do anything exceptionally well. He's got a good build and he performed pretty well in all of the drills at the combine, but he just doesn't stand out on the field like you'd expect a future NFL starting RB to stand out.
This is my point, although I put relatively little stock in the combine, and much more stock into what I see on the field...thanks to excessive TV coverage for Ohio State I pretty much saw every one of their games.
He's a bit of an enigma to me. I expect him to be drafted pretty high (2nd-3rd round and probably the 3rd or 4th RB taken), but I don't know if he's more than a backup at the next level.
Exactly, I don't know why he's projected to be first day pick when he really hasn't shown IMHO that he can be more than a backup or RBBC contributor...that's where my overrated thoughts start coming into play.
He's my RB4 right now after Peterson, Lynch, and Irons. I view him as a fringe guy who isn't talented enough to excel everywhere, but is probably talented enough to be an adequate starter on certain teams. He reminds me a little bit of Chester Taylor and Frank Gore. He tested better than Gore at the combine, but he's not as bulky and strong.
Gore was a legend in college and high school and by many accounts was better than McGahee when both played together so I don't agree with your Gore statement. I can definitely see the Chester Taylor comparison. He can definitely find success in the NFL...hell, even Mike Bell(who sucked at UofA) found marginal success. I just wouldn't draft him on the first day and I wouldn't rank him at RB#4...I'd rather take a chance on a less proven back like Brandon Jackson who appears to have much more upside.