Any of these worth a spot on my roster? (1 Viewer)

[Galileo]

Chris Duncan

Josh Hamilton

Aaron Hill

JJ Hardy

If so, who do I drop?

12 Team, 5x5 Roto (currently in 2nd place...current weaknesses BA, SB, W)

C - Posada

1B Overbay

2B Utley

SS Hall

3B Mora

OF Sizemore

OF Wells

OF Dye

DH Thomas

Bench: Patterson, Aurilia, Estrada, Scott, Jackson

SP - Lackey, Kazmir, Cain, Hamels, Burnett, Garcia, Jennings (DL)

RP - Hoffman, Jones, Fuentes

maybe drop Jackson or Scott for Duncan??? 1B/OF eligibility would be nice. Should I drop Jennings??? He pitched well, but the hit the 15 day DL

Would I be better off with Hardy or Hill at SS and moving Hall to 3B or DH???

Any thought appreciated...thanks.

 

[my man otis]

Chris Duncan - no

Josh Hamilton - probably

Aaron Hill - no

JJ Hardy - as long as he's hitting 2nd, but you don't need him.

drop aurilia for hamiltonif the jackson you have listed is conor definitely don't drop him and most likely start him over overbay. he'll be fine.

Would I be better off with Hardy or Hill at SS and moving Hall to 3B or DH???

yes, but ride Mora for another month or two. he'll cool off and then you have to find something else, but start mora for now while he's hot.

 

[RenegadeGM]

I'd drop Scott for either Hardy, Hamilton or Duncan.

If you pick up Hardy you could use him at SS and move Hall to the OF/UTIL when guys have off days, get hurt, etc.

Hamilton could do the same. Duncan also has 1B eligibility, like you stated.

I'm not sold either Hall or Hamilton's starts are for real but with Scott struggling and not even playing everyday you have nothing to lose to find out. Duncan at least has a brief track record.

I'd even think about getting two by dropping Jennings too... unless you'd need a SP. I'd think about dropping Jennings either way though.

Good luck.

 

[Galileo]

Thanks for some feedback...

my man otis: The reason I don't like dropping Aurilia is that he is capable of filling in at so many positions. We don't have big enough rosters to back up every position, so even though he may not be a #1 guy, at any spot, his verstility has some value as a bench player. We have a limitted number of WW moves for the year, he can provide backup without wasting WW moves. As far as Mora goes, I agree. I am just waiting for the day when the bottom falls out...not "if" but "when". Which is why I think I may need a SS for when Hall needs to fill my 3B spot. I would like to figure out a deal that could land a decent 3B option...maybe trade someone like Dye. The Jackson is Conor Jackson, but right now he simply isn't producing (0.232 BA, 0 HR, 5 RBI, 0 SB) I know it is early, but last year I dug myself a BA hole early in the year and I could never climb out. So Jackson has been riding the pine.

Renegade: I can't really substitute for days off. We submit a weekly lineup. So it is difficult to justify ever pulling Sizemore, Wells or Dye out of my lineup (assuming they are healthy). Thus I don't see Hall playing much OF for me. For that matter any WW/bench guys will need to find time at 1B, SS, 3B, or DH if I am going to get any value out of them. Since my WW moves are limitted, I don't want to use them haphazardly.

 

[RenegadeGM]

Thanks for some feedback...Renegade: I can't really substitute for days off. We submit a weekly lineup. So it is difficult to justify ever pulling Sizemore, Wells or Dye out of my lineup (assuming they are healthy). Thus I don't see Hall playing much OF for me. For that matter any WW/bench guys will need to find time at 1B, SS, 3B, or DH if I am going to get any value out of them. Since my WW moves are limitted, I don't want to use them haphazardly.

Ah, the new information makes a big difference. I like to have the multi-position eligibility guys in daily transaction leagues... didn't know it was weekly lineups. Plus, I didn't know you had limited moves either. Both of those make a big difference. My bad for assuming.