What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

AP: Culpepper cleared of boat scandal charges (1 Viewer)

Rig24

Footballguy
MINNEAPOLIS (AP) - Quarterback Daunte Culpepper was cleared Tuesday of misdemeanor charges stemming from a boat-party sex scandal.

A judge ruled there wasn't probable cause to determine a crime was committed by Culpepper, one of four Minnesota Vikings accused of misdemeanor lewd conduct during the cruise last fall on a suburban lake. Culpepper has since been traded to the Miami Dolphins.

Hennepin County Judge Kevin Burke denied a motion to dismiss charges against running back Moe Williams. His trial is scheduled for April 18.

The other two players charged, cornerback Fred Smoot and tackle Bryant McKinnie, weren't part of Tuesday's ruling. Their next hearings are Thursday.

Culpepper's attorney, Earl Gray, said, "I'm happy about it. I'm sure Culpepper is, and his family. It vindicates him from being involved in any sexual misconduct on the boat."

The quarterback didn't immediately respond to an e-mail.

Williams' attorney, Joe Friedberg, was disappointed with the judge's decision.

"I disagree with him, but that's what makes horse racing," Friedberg said.

Culpepper and Williams had denied any improper conduct in a hearing before Burke last month. Culpepper, who was accused of touching a dancer's buttocks, testified that he spent the cruise on Lake Minnetonka playing a dice game in the back of a boat and rejected offers from several women.

Williams, accused of touching a dancer's breast, testified that a woman danced near him but he never touched her.

In explaining his ruling, Burke wrote Culpepper's version of events would clear him if true, and since the prosecutor offered nothing to rebut it, he found no probable cause. The difference with Williams, the judge wrote, was that his story wouldn't necessarily exonerate him.

Both players also contended race played a factor in prosecutor Steve Tallen's decision to charge them. They pointed out that two white men, including the captain of one of the boats, weren't charged even though investigators found evidence the men both kissed a stripper's exposed nipple.

Burke said the claim was understandable, but the prosecutor had discretion on who was charged.

Tallen denied at last month's hearing that race was a factor, saying the case against the white men was shaky. He was in court Tuesday and didn't immediately return a phone message.

The boat-party scandal was the lowest point in a dismal season for the Vikings, who lost Culpepper to a serious knee injury soon afterward. After his relationship with the team and new head coach Brad Childress soured in the offseason, he was traded to Miami last month for a second-round pick.

All four players faced identical charges of indecent conduct, disorderly conduct and lewd or lascivious conduct. Conviction on a single misdemeanor charge is punishable by up to 90 days in jail and/or a $1,000 fine.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Since when does "A judge ruled there wasn't probable cause to determine a crime was committed by Culpepper" mean someone is "vindicates him from being involved in any sexual misconduct on the boat"???

:confused:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
MINNEAPOLIS (AP) - Quarterback Daunte Culpepper was cleared Tuesday of misdemeanor charges stemming from a boat-party sex scandal.

A judge ruled there wasn't probable cause to determine a crime was committed by Culpepper, one of four Minnesota Vikings accused of misdemeanor lewd conduct during the cruise last fall on a suburban lake. Culpepper has since been traded to the Miami Dolphins.

Hennepin County Judge Kevin Burke denied a motion to dismiss charges against running back Moe Williams. His trial is scheduled for April 18.

The other two players charged, cornerback Fred Smoot and tackle Bryant McKinnie, weren't part of Tuesday's ruling. Their next hearings are Thursday.

Culpepper's attorney, Earl Gray, said, "I'm happy about it. I'm sure Culpepper is, and his family. It vindicates him from being involved in any sexual misconduct on the boat."

The quarterback didn't immediately respond to an e-mail.

Williams' attorney, Joe Friedberg, was disappointed with the judge's decision.

"I disagree with him, but that's what makes horse racing," Friedberg said.

Culpepper and Williams had denied any improper conduct in a hearing before Burke last month. Culpepper, who was accused of touching a dancer's buttocks, testified that he spent the cruise on Lake Minnetonka playing a dice game in the back of a boat and rejected offers from several women.

Williams, accused of touching a dancer's breast, testified that a woman danced near him but he never touched her.

In explaining his ruling, Burke wrote Culpepper's version of events would clear him if true, and since the prosecutor offered nothing to rebut it, he found no probable cause. The difference with Williams, the judge wrote, was that his story wouldn't necessarily exonerate him.

Both players also contended race played a factor in prosecutor Steve Tallen's decision to charge them. They pointed out that two white men, including the captain of one of the boats, weren't charged even though investigators found evidence the men both kissed a stripper's exposed nipple.

Burke said the claim was understandable, but the prosecutor had discretion on who was charged.

Tallen denied at last month's hearing that race was a factor, saying the case against the white men was shaky. He was in court Tuesday and didn't immediately return a phone message.

The boat-party scandal was the lowest point in a dismal season for the Vikings, who lost Culpepper to a serious knee injury soon afterward. After his relationship with the team and new head coach Brad Childress soured in the offseason, he was traded to Miami last month for a second-round pick.

All four players faced identical charges of indecent conduct, disorderly conduct and lewd or lascivious conduct. Conviction on a single misdemeanor charge is punishable by up to 90 days in jail and/or a $1,000 fine.
THANK GOD I don't live in a backward ### place like Minnesotta. I'd be a hard criminal. Since when is enjoying your lapdance illegal?
 
As I sit in sunny South Florida and ponder this further, I know I live in a more adventurous town but c'mon.....

If we all got arrested for grabbing a piece of ### now and then, the human race would go extinct. What goes down in Minnesota on the weekends? Do they raid every college party and nightclub to arrest everyone who is grinding on the dance floor? Take in everyone who cops a feel on the dance floor while enjoying their date?

I think it is up to the people involved to determine if the contact was inappropriate or unwarranted. DON'T GET ME WRONG. You can't just go feeling up every professional dancer in SoFla without saying hello first, but if you have half a brain..... I digress. If the stripper is cool with some touchy/feely/nibble action - then who is some lurker to say it offended them to see it.

Now I get that some of these people were boat employees who might have been obligated to be present and who may not have known what was going to happen, but they need to A) Be professional and B) Take up any beef with their employer. the freaking CUSTOMERS have nothing to do with it.

The Minnesota DA is looking like a bunch of clowns to me after this one. Excuse me, but with all the hype, I assumed there was action past 2nd base going on.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The good ol' "Race" card. Works everytime. It's painfully obvious that the charges were brought against C-Pep because he is a man of color. He wasn't even on that boat. I didn't see him. Did you?

 
As I sit in sunny South Florida and ponder this further, I know I live in a more adventurous town but c'mon.....

If we all got arrested for grabbing a piece of ### now and then, the human race would go extinct. What goes down in Minnesota on the weekends? Do they raid every college party and nightclub to arrest everyone who is grinding on the dance floor? Take in everyone who cops a feel on the dance floor while enjoying their date?

I think it is up to the people involved to determine if the contact was inappropriate or unwarranted. DON'T GET ME WRONG. You can't just go feeling up every professional dancer in SoFla without saying hello first, but if you have half a brain..... I digress. If the stripper is cool with some touchy/feely/nibble action - then who is some lurker to say it offended them to see it.

Now I get that some of these people were boat employees who might have been obligated to be present and who may not have known what was going to happen, but they need to A) Be professional and B) Take up any beef with their employer. the freaking CUSTOMERS have nothing to do with it.

The Minnesota DA is looking like a bunch of clowns to me after this one. Excuse me, but with all the hype, I assumed there was action past 2nd base going on.
:goodposting: We must be the only married guys that still get lap dances from time to time.

This whole situation was a joke and a giant waste of time.

 
Moe Williams claims Culpepper didnt leave the craps table all night. Its relevant because Moe admitted to getting a lapdance himself.

It looks like Culpepper really got slandered for no reason. He may have been cleared, but this will continue to haunt him for the remainder of his career. Fans will continue to accuse him and mock him for it - which is a shame.

 
Question is will this even get Half the coverage that it got when he was charged?

:no:

When he was first charged local media had 10 to 15 minutes in regards to it as their Top Story...

Guessing this gets buried somewhere beween..

Twins Opening night and Hamster racing.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Question is will this even get Half the coverage that it got when he was charged?

:no:

When he was first charged local media had 10 to 15 minutes in regards to it as their Top Story...

Guessing this gets buried somewhere beween..

Twins Opening night and Hamster racing.
Its tough being a celebrity sometimes. Seriously.
 
All I gotta say is, what if the Oakland Raiders of the sixties and seventies were playing as the Vikings now?

:bag: The media wouldn't have a day off ever.

 
Rather extraordinary to see charges dismissed by the court at a probable cause hearing in a misdemeanor matter. Indicates an extraordinarily weak case, or a political deal. Given the attention to the matter by the press, the court would have been foolish to do so for any reason other than a legitimate ruling on the facts. It looks like Culpepper was dragged through the mud for nothing more than being associated with the wrong crowd.

Too bad as the stigma will follow him regardless.

 
The good ol' "Race" card.  Works everytime.  It's painfully obvious that the charges were brought against C-Pep because he is a man of color.  He wasn't even on that boat.  I didn't see him.  Did you?
If you're not smart enough to see how clever his defense team was, then I'm not sure we can help you.Culpepper's lawyer: "It's *race*, I tell you!"

DA: "No it's not."

Culpepper's lawyer: "Then why were all the guys charged black, and two white guys in allegedly similar circumstances were not charged?"

Now the DA is left with 2 options:

a. it really is race, or

b. it wasn't race--we charged these guys because they are rich and famous athletes, and the other guys weren't.

Neither is a very palatable option. Great lawyering on the part of the defense.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Since when does "A judge ruled there wasn't probable cause to determine a crime was committed by Culpepper" mean someone is "vindicates him from being involved in any sexual misconduct on the boat"???

:confused:
From what I understand, Culpepper had witnesses that stated he just played dice and had one drink all night.The prosecution had no witnesses.

 
Culpepper is cleared of all charges and in 2 days, there are 17 posts...there may have been 17 seperate THREADS when this all broke.

Terribily sad to see a good man have his reputation tarnished by idiots...and then the new ownership "triangle of authority" help to run him out of town.

They get a 2nd rounder for a pro-bowler, and are now seriously considering giving up a 1st for a backup.

 
Culpepper is cleared of all charges and in 2 days, there are 17 posts...there may have been 17 seperate THREADS when this all broke.

Terribily sad to see a good man have his reputation tarnished by idiots...and then the new ownership "triangle of authority" help to run him out of town.

They get a 2nd rounder for a pro-bowler, and are now seriously considering giving up a 1st for a backup.
:goodposting:
 
Culpepper is cleared of all charges and in 2 days, there are 17 posts...there may have been 17 seperate THREADS when this all broke.

Terribily sad to see a good man have his reputation tarnished by idiots...and then the new ownership "triangle of authority" help to run him out of town.

They get a 2nd rounder for a pro-bowler, and are now seriously considering giving up a 1st for a backup.
I would be interested in hearing what those individuals who ran with the story originally are saying now. I suspect they still got a good out, McKinnie and Smoot are completely different story, so the detractors will still have ammunition; and I suspect McKinnie and Smoot are somewhat guilty (based on the police report).

 
Culpepper is cleared of all charges and in 2 days, there are 17 posts...there may have been 17 seperate THREADS when this all broke.

Terribily sad to see a good man have his reputation tarnished by idiots...and then the new ownership "triangle of authority" help to run him out of town.

They get a 2nd rounder for a pro-bowler, and are now seriously considering giving up a 1st for a backup.
I would be interested in hearing what those individuals who ran with the story originally are saying now. I suspect they still got a good out, McKinnie and Smoot are completely different story, so the detractors will still have ammunition; and I suspect McKinnie and Smoot are somewhat guilty (based on the police report).
True, but Culpepper was the one who was really trashed in the media...he was villified for not talking about the case, dragged through the mud on the radio whem any fool could call in with the latest salacious rumor, and finally dumped by the team when it was clear that he was going to be a PR problem. Remember that Culpepper ASKED to have the playbook so that he could start learning the offense, Dumb-### Childress wouldn't give it to him. So it was clear to me that they always intended to dump him, they just tried to spin it to make him look like the villian.

Congrats to the Miami fans, they got a hell of a QB and a damn good guy...

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top