Approve or Deny Trade Commissioner WHIR (1 Viewer)

[ddiaz386]

I am a commissioner in a ppr league and the following trade was approved Sunday night after the news of the Big Ben injury. To be specific the Brown owner approved the trade. Team A receives Cobb, Jordan Matthews and Matt Jones, Team B receives Antonio Brown. The rosters are below, would you approve this trade now that Matthews and Cobb are battling injuries and the news on Big Ben are that he might now even miss a game? The Brown owner is asking me to deny the trade.

Team B                                                                                                                                                                      


os


Player


QB


Player Note

Tom Brady NE - QB



Sun 4:25 pm @ Pit



WR


New Player Note

Jordan Matthews Phi - WR


Questionable


Sun 1:00 pm vs Min



WR


Player Note

Willie Snead NO - WR



Sun 1:00 pm @ KC



RB


Player Note

Lamar Miller Hou - RB



Mon 8:30 pm @ Den



RB


Player Note

Le'Veon Bell Pit - RB



Sun 4:25 pm vs NE



TE


New Player Note

Jordan Reed Was - TE


Out


Sun 1:00 pm @ Det



W/R/T


Player Note

Christine Michael Sea - RB



Sun 8:30 pm @ Ari



K


No new player Notes

Dustin Hopkins Was - K



Sun 1:00 pm @ Det



DEF


Player Note

Denver Den - DEF



Mon 8:30 pm vs Hou



BN


Player Note

Jacob Tamme Atl - TE



Sun 4:05 pm vs SD



BN


New Player Note

Randall Cobb GB - WR


Questionable


Thu 8:25 pm vs Chi



BN


Player Note

Jamison Crowder Was - WR



Sun 1:00 pm @ Det



BN


Player Note

Matt Jones Was - RB



Sun 1:00 pm @ Det



BN


New Player Note

Quincy Enunwa NYJ - WR



Sun 1:00 pm vs Bal



BN


No new player Notes

Philadelphia Phi - DEF



Sun 1:00 pm vs Min




Team A


QB


Player Note

Tyrod Taylor Buf - QB



Sun 1:00 pm @ Mia



WR


Player Note

Antonio Brown Pit - WR



Sun 4:25 pm vs NE



WR


Player Note

T.Y. Hilton Ind - WR



Sun 1:00 pm @ Ten



RB


Player Note

Isaiah Crowell Cle - RB



Sun 1:00 pm @ Cin



RB


Player Note

Darren Sproles Phi - RB



Sun 1:00 pm vs Min



TE


Player Note

Jason Witten Dal - TE



Bye



W/R/T


Player Note

Golden Tate Det - WR



Sun 1:00 pm vs Was



K


No new player Notes

Chandler Catanzaro Ari - K



Sun 8:30 pm vs Sea



DEF


No new player Notes

Green Bay GB - DEF



Thu 8:25 pm vs Chi



BN


Player Note

Eli Manning NYG - QB



Sun 9:30 am @ LA



BN


New Player Note

Eddie Lacy GB - RB


Questionable


Thu 8:25 pm vs Chi



BN


Player Note

Zach Ertz Phi - TE



Sun 1:00 pm vs Min



BN


Player Note

Jalen Richard Oak - RB



Sun 1:00 pm @ Jax



BN


New Player Note

Davante Adams GB - WR


Questionable


Thu 8:25 pm vs Chi



BN


Player Note

Robert Woods Buf - WR


Questionable


Sun 1:00 pm @ Mia

 

[TX Steel]

I tend to lean on the side that unless there is clear, blatant collusion, I never veto trades.  

Was this deal accepted before the injuries to Cobb & Matthews?  If so, there's absolutely no way I'd veto.  If it was accepted after the injury news, I'd check with the AB owner and see why he accepted the deal, knowing those guys got banged up.

To me, there's no justifiable reason to nix a deal unless you can find hard evidence of collusion.  The Brady owner will end up with a great squad after Big Ben returns, but that's not his fault that the Tyrod owner agreed to the trade.

Good luck, and please see mine if you have a minute:

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749837-offered-bennett-for-my-crabtree-whir/

 

[Cjw_55106]

Do not veto

 

[need2know]

Nothing wrong with that

 

[wlwiles]

Nothing wrong with the trade, and DEFINITELY no chance that an owner should be able to undo one after injury news comes out.  Thats the risk of trading.  We've all had a past trade that blew up on us because of injury.  I traded a pretty nice package of players for Aaron Rodgers a couple years ago, one week before he broke his collarbone and missed the rest of the regular season.  Tough luck, part of the game.  

 

[Gally]

No collusion then no veto.  Let owners manage their team as they see fit.   The Brown owner getting cold feet after agreeing to a trade should not be considered after he accepted. 

 

[HokieInMD]

No collusion, no veto. Too bad if the deal was accepted after or before injury news was out.