Auction Keeper - Tough Decision (Tyreek, Kelce, or Chubb) (1 Viewer)

[PPRGuy]

I play in a 10-team ppr auction keeper where we are allowed to keep 3 players a year and a single player for a maximum of 3 years.

With a $200 budget, I am faced with keeping three of the following four:

Alvin Kamara $10
Nick Chubb $5
Travis Kelce $27
Tyreek Hill $19

I have locked in Kamara but am dead even on the value of the last 3. I can keep each player for an additional 2 years after this season by adding $5 a season. (Chubb $5 then $10 then $15). 

2 RB, 2 WR, 1 Flex, 1 TE 

 

[Gally]

I think it is an easy choice to keep Chubb at that price.  It's a no brainer.  Kelce vs Hill is a toss up.  My choice would probably hinge on typical elite TE and WR auction values.  Who is the better value based on what they would go for if left to go in the auction.  The better deal is probably the guy I keep.   Without that info I probably keep Hill for the lower price tag and then have that $27 available to get Kelce back in the auction if I have the budget for it.