What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Baby Back vs Spare Ribs (1 Viewer)

MikeIke

Footballguy
Can anyone fill me in as to what the difference is between baby back ribs and spare ribs? I'm doing dinner on Father's Day and cooking ribs. I've always done baby back in the past, but today at the store I noticed that spare ribs were cheaper and they seemed to have more meat on them.

So, what's the difference between baby back ribs and spare ribs? What is your preference?

 
they all come different parts of the rack...the baby backs are right along the loin and have a piece of that meat attached to the rib ....smaller bones but plenty meaty. Spare ribs are from further down the rack and generally have a bunch of garbage attached (country ribs) or trimmed off (st louis cut)

I prefer st louis cut. they take longer to smoke which means they get more smoke with my methodology. ...but baby back meat is a little more tender.

 
Baby backs are better, but if I am making them at home I'll get spare ribs when theya re on sale for $1.99 per pound. Gotta eat like a barbarian, but if I am home I don't really care. I give the wife a cleaner piece and I am the only one that eats the leftovers. As long as you cook them right they are almost as good.

If we are having people over gotta go baby back though. A little better and a lot easier to eat.

 
they all come different parts of the rack...the baby backs are right along the loin and have a piece of that meat attached to the rib ....smaller bones but plenty meaty. Spare ribs are from further down the rack and generally have a bunch of garbage attached (country ribs) or trimmed off (st louis cut)

I prefer st louis cut. they take longer to smoke which means they get more smoke with my methodology. ...but baby back meat is a little more tender.
Tipsy - I just did some country ribs using the oven method (no smoker anymore ...) and I have always loved them. Very meaty but still with the bone in. Do you really think that they are a part of the "garbage"?

 
Beef ribs. Not even in the same supercluster.

See what I did there... Took two things that are relatively similar and hyperbole'd them up your ###hole. Did you enjoy that? I didn't think so! Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

 
Beef ribs. Not even in the same supercluster.

See what I did there... Took two things that are relatively similar and hyperbole'd them up your ###hole. Did you enjoy that? I didn't think so! Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
:lmao:

 
not necessarily garbage...but the lesser of the 3 levels of meat coming off the ribs. I use it for my rib meat sammich
Tks! Those things are cheap and meaty - we have grabbing them on sale for less than $2/lb. Very little bone (relatively) - and really tender. Crazy - almost half as much as ground meat.

We are hooked, just gotta get a smoker.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
What do you mean when you say 'they just didn't come out right'?

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.
If you are cooking BBs for 5 to 5.5 hours I hope your temps are 200 or lower, especially if you are foiling for an hour

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
I did them one time. I made pouches of chips. My grill had four burners, so I turned them all on to get to temp, then the middle two off. I took the grates off the outside burners and that's where I'd put my chip pouches. When one was done, I'd throw another on. I did that for about an hour and a half...then wrapped them in foil and cooked them the rest of the way in foil. Didn't do 3-2-1. Found that I didn't gain much from that last hour being out of the foil.

What was wrong with yours that they weren't right IYO? I find that 6 hours on the smoker for baby backs is too long for my tastes.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
What do you mean when you say 'they just didn't come out right'?
My friend asked the same question...hard to pin point it, but here's what I told him:

If I had to score them, I would give it a 5/10. The rub didn't "char" and create the bark like I wanted...I wouldn't say they were tough, but they weren't as moist as I wanted. I followed the instructions to a T, so :shrug:

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
I did them one time. I made pouches of chips. My grill had four burners, so I turned them all on to get to temp, then the middle two off. I took the grates off the outside burners and that's where I'd put my chip pouches. When one was done, I'd throw another on. I did that for about an hour and a half...then wrapped them in foil and cooked them the rest of the way in foil. Didn't do 3-2-1. Found that I didn't gain much from that last hour being out of the foil.

What was wrong with yours that they weren't right IYO? I find that 6 hours on the smoker for baby backs is too long for my tastes.
thx.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
What do you mean when you say 'they just didn't come out right'?
My friend asked the same question...hard to pin point it, but here's what I told him:

If I had to score them, I would give it a 5/10. The rub didn't "char" and create the bark like I wanted...I wouldn't say they were tough, but they weren't as moist as I wanted. I followed the instructions to a T, so :shrug:
Keep them out of foil if you want more char. If they aren't moist enough, you cooked them too long. As I said before, I find it hard to do 6 hours of cooking for baby backs. Have you ever tried no foil at all?

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
What do you mean when you say 'they just didn't come out right'?
My friend asked the same question...hard to pin point it, but here's what I told him:

If I had to score them, I would give it a 5/10. The rub didn't "char" and create the bark like I wanted...I wouldn't say they were tough, but they weren't as moist as I wanted. I followed the instructions to a T, so :shrug:
Keep them out of foil if you want more char. If they aren't moist enough, you cooked them too long. As I said before, I find it hard to do 6 hours of cooking for baby backs. Have you ever tried no foil at all?
No, I haven't. Will take a shot this weekend :thumbup:

 
When using a gas grill I found it hard to keep the ribs moist. I resorted to using an oven / grill combo method that has turned out awesome ribs every time. I rub the ribs. Wrap them tight in parchment paper first. Then wrap in aluminum foil. Place on baking sheet. Bake for 2 hours at 325. Pull out and let sit still wrapped for 30 minutes. Then grill with/without sauce for 15 minutes.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
What do you mean when you say 'they just didn't come out right'?
My friend asked the same question...hard to pin point it, but here's what I told him:

If I had to score them, I would give it a 5/10. The rub didn't "char" and create the bark like I wanted...I wouldn't say they were tough, but they weren't as moist as I wanted. I followed the instructions to a T, so :shrug:
Keep them out of foil if you want more char. If they aren't moist enough, you cooked them too long. As I said before, I find it hard to do 6 hours of cooking for baby backs. Have you ever tried no foil at all?
No, I haven't. Will take a shot this weekend :thumbup:
The other option is to cook them low and slow, then throw them on the grill to "firm" them up. I've done that before and had success.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
What do you mean when you say 'they just didn't come out right'?
My friend asked the same question...hard to pin point it, but here's what I told him:

If I had to score them, I would give it a 5/10. The rub didn't "char" and create the bark like I wanted...I wouldn't say they were tough, but they weren't as moist as I wanted. I followed the instructions to a T, so :shrug:
Are you looking for a thick bark or are you looking for carmelization/char (searing on a steak)? Also if you are cooking BBs then 3-2-1 is way too long, that method is for spares and full spares at that.

For a thicker bark, try doing a mustard slather first, then add your rub, once you put the ribs on the grill/smoker/cooker let them be for at least 2 hours os the bark can set, if you decide to foil then use more solids instead of liquids (butter, brown sugar, more rub) and then lightly spray the ribs with apple juice before sealing the foil. Dont foil for more than an hour

If you are looking for char then you can

use more sugar in your rub

cook at a higher temp (300)

or finish the ribs over direct heat.

HTH

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.
If you are cooking BBs for 5 to 5.5 hours I hope your temps are 200 or lower, especially if you are foiling for an hour
Nope. Usually 225-250. Come out perfect every time. But I'm using a traditional smoker, not a gas grill.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.
If you are cooking BBs for 5 to 5.5 hours I hope your temps are 200 or lower, especially if you are foiling for an hour
Nope. Usually 225-250. Come out perfect every time. But I'm using a traditional smoker, not a gas grill.
if by perfect you mean pulled pork, I can't even imagine being able to get the ribs off the smoker after 5 hours, they are simple mush and fall apart at the first contact.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.
If you are cooking BBs for 5 to 5.5 hours I hope your temps are 200 or lower, especially if you are foiling for an hour
Nope. Usually 225-250. Come out perfect every time. But I'm using a traditional smoker, not a gas grill.
if by perfect you mean pulled pork, I can't even imagine being able to get the ribs off the smoker after 5 hours, they are simple mush and fall apart at the first contact.
Then you're doing it wrong. Been smoking them this way forever, and the meat is tender yet stays on the bone. Perfection.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.
If you are cooking BBs for 5 to 5.5 hours I hope your temps are 200 or lower, especially if you are foiling for an hour
Nope. Usually 225-250. Come out perfect every time. But I'm using a traditional smoker, not a gas grill.
if by perfect you mean pulled pork, I can't even imagine being able to get the ribs off the smoker after 5 hours, they are simple mush and fall apart at the first contact.
Then you're doing it wrong. Been smoking them this way forever, and the meat is tender yet stays on the bone. Perfection.
OK, I and the rest of the world are doing them wrong, gotcha, let me know when you find one atricle, one publication or any other resource that says to cook BBs at 225-250 for 5 hours.

My guess would be that one of two things is going on if your getting 5 to 5.5 hour cooks on BBs

1. Your thermostat is off on the low side

2. Your thermostat is not close to where you are cooking and the area you are cooking in is cooler than the area where the thermostat is located.

 
When using a gas grill I found it hard to keep the ribs moist. I resorted to using an oven / grill combo method that has turned out awesome ribs every time. I rub the ribs. Wrap them tight in parchment paper first. Then wrap in aluminum foil. Place on baking sheet. Bake for 2 hours at 325. Pull out and let sit still wrapped for 30 minutes. Then grill with/without sauce for 15 minutes.
I do it this way also. I peel the skin off the back side first. Perfect ribs every time and it doesn't take all day. You can rub them and wrap them a day ahead and let them sit in the fridge.

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
Get some heavy duty aluminum foil. Soak some wood chips in water for a few hours, then put them in the foil and wrap the foil up in a long cylindrical fashion.

Poke a few holes in the foil. Lay the foil right next to the heat source under the rack. Keep your heat down as far as you can. Sounds like you already doing that.

If your gas grill has a main rack and then an upper rack, put the ribs on the upper rack and put a water pan on the main rack. Don't use a ton of water - a cookie sheet with water will be fine.

You'll get some good smoke coming from the wood. I did this years ago on my brothers gas grill, and they turned out great.
Thx. do you keep all 4 burners lit? I do have a top rack. Did you use 3-2-1 method, flip every 30 minutes, something new and cool I don't even know about, etc?
I only did this once, and it's been years ago. I normally use my smoker, so this was at my brothers house before I shamed him into buying a real smoker.

Anyway, if I remember correctly, I think we only lit one side. Whatever will keep the temp in the 225-250 range. With babybacks, I usually do 3 hours on the smoker, then put them in foil, meat side down for an hour, and finish them for about an hour or an hour and a half without the foil. I also start saucing at this point as well.
If you are cooking BBs for 5 to 5.5 hours I hope your temps are 200 or lower, especially if you are foiling for an hour
Nope. Usually 225-250. Come out perfect every time. But I'm using a traditional smoker, not a gas grill.
if by perfect you mean pulled pork, I can't even imagine being able to get the ribs off the smoker after 5 hours, they are simple mush and fall apart at the first contact.
Then you're doing it wrong. Been smoking them this way forever, and the meat is tender yet stays on the bone. Perfection.
OK, I and the rest of the world are doing them wrong, gotcha, let me know when you find one atricle, one publication or any other resource that says to cook BBs at 225-250 for 5 hours.

My guess would be that one of two things is going on if your getting 5 to 5.5 hour cooks on BBs

1. Your thermostat is off on the low side

2. Your thermostat is not close to where you are cooking and the area you are cooking in is cooler than the area where the thermostat is located.
Well, I use 2 stats. The one that's on the smoker, and a digital one I place on the rack next to the ribs as my back-up. For the most part, they tend to stay within the same temperature parameters, so I know my temp is correct.

Look, I know everyone does ribs differently and there is really no "wrong" way. I probably used the wrong terminology there, and I apologize for that. All I'm saying is I've done ribs exactly this way for as long as I can remember and they come out perfectly.

I would rather sit here and argue about BBQ all day than talk to my customers or my wife, so it's all good. :lol:

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
If you did 3-2-1 on a gas I'm guessing you need to do indirect, with some of the burners off. Did you?

 
This may or not me the right thread for this, if not, just let me know....but can anyone give me some pointers for doing ribs on a gas grill (yeah I know...but I don't have a charcoal). I did some last week using 3-2-1 and keeping the temp b/w 200-250 the entire time, but they just didn't come out right. Will take all advice!

My buddy suggested a water pan?
If you did 3-2-1 on a gas I'm guessing you need to do indirect, with some of the burners off. Did you?
i did, just didn't turn out like i wanted. Tried again yesterday using Alton Brown's oven recipe and then finished them on the grill on high heat for 2 minutes each side and came out great

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top