Bad move? Traded for C.Guillen (1 Viewer)

[Texican]

I just gave up Hafner and Lyon for C.Guillen (pending league approval). I did it really because Hafner was my Util and I figured Guillen could play Util for me and be a backup for Chipper at 3rd and Rollins at SS. What do you think? Good/Bad/Neutral?

My team:

My current roster:

C: Pierzynski

1B: D.Lee

2B: B.Roberts

3B: C.Jones

SS: Lugo

OF: N.McLouth

OF: G.Sheffield

OF: A.Rios

Util: T.Hafner

Bn: K.Griffey

Bn: B.Hawpe

Bn: D.Uggla

Bn: Rollins

 

[boom king]

id personaly have lyon and hafner

 

[Wrigley]

I just gave up Hafner and Lyon for C.Guillen (pending league approval). I did it really because Hafner was my Util and I figured Guillen could play Util for me and be a backup for Chipper at 3rd and Rollins at SS. What do you think? Good/Bad/Neutral?My team:My current roster:C: Pierzynski1B: D.Lee2B: B.Roberts3B: C.JonesSS: LugoOF: N.McLouthOF: G.SheffieldOF: A.RiosUtil: T.HafnerBn: K.GriffeyBn: B.HawpeBn: D.UgglaBn: Rollins

Hafner seems to have hit the wall over the past couple years.....and Lyon will not hold onto the Closers job all year.Not a bad trade.Guillen will also help you back up Lee.I traded D Lowe and JJ Hardy for him last week.......and I'm very happy

 

[Wrigley]

id personaly have lyon and hafner

Thats because you're a ####stick.

 

[shadyridr]

Good move cuz Guillen can replace Lugo at SS for now

 

[Clifton]

Guillen is more valuable because of his positional flexibility but I'm not a fan of anyone involved in this trade.

 

[shadyridr]

and Lyon will not hold onto the Closers job all year.

Hes pitching well now. Stranger things have happened but if hes their closer all year he'll be a top teir closer.

 

[MAC_32]

I think you're primarily gambling on Guillen's health, that's it. I have no faith in Lyon holding the closer job and Hafner looks no different now than he did for 90% of last season, time to get what you could for him and I think you made out. All depends on if Guillen's body holds up though, his medical history now has knee added to the already problematic ankle, hammy, and quads.

 

[KiddLattimer]

Guillen is very under-rated and now has multi position eligibility. Hafner is possibly the most over-rated player in fantasy baseball and Lyon is very replaceable.

 

[Balco]

If Guillen stayed at 1B, no doubt I would like Guillen, but there is no way that guy stays healthy at 3rd. No way.

 

[pollardsvision]

no worries. it was a good move.