SleeperPix
Footballguy
Who would you rate as the best "1B" RB?
Some to look at:
Bradshaw
J.Stewart
L.Washington
F.Jones
Caddy ( - 1A?)
Some to look at:
Bradshaw
J.Stewart
L.Washington
F.Jones
Caddy ( - 1A?)
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Best of the "1B" RBs? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter SleeperPix
- Start date
theplayer11
Footballguy
I like Leon in PPR..then Bradshaw
SleeperPix
Footballguy
What about non-ppr?I was assuming non-ppr and thought Bradshaw would be #1.
Jason Wood
Zoo York
Well Caddy is the 1A (IMHO), to Ward's 1B. But either way, I like them both over the others you have listed. I would put Leon Washington 2nd, and then probably Michael Bush 3rd.
Jason Wood
Zoo York
And let's not forget Donald Brown (13 touches in his first game) or Mike Bell.
SleeperPix
Footballguy
Even with Thomas coming back?
Jason Wood
Zoo York
Sure, who's to say Bell isn't going to get most of the carries? And who's to say Thomas is coming back healthy anytime soon?
Jewell
Footballguy
Took the words right out of my mouth. Plus, I'd toss in that Bradshaw is running behind the best offensive line of any of those backs. Although, the other New York offensive line looks real impressive too.Addai's Adidas
Footballguy
You're kidding yourself if you think Jstew is a 1B. He's more like 2A.
BobbyLayne
Footballguy
Caddy is the outlier, doesn't belong with this group IMO.
Stew will score more TDs than the rest combined, so I like him in standard scoring.
Felix has the most talent and the most upside, but whether he gets enough touches is debateable.
Leon in a PPR (though I expect Ahmad to catch a lot more balls this year, as he basically inherited Ware's role).
Bell will be irrelevent by Columbus Day.
Brown is intriguing but I see less potential there than I did with Addai back when he was sharing with Dom Rhodes. The role reversal is ironic, but I just don't see the Indy RBBC being the force it once was.
Stew will score more TDs than the rest combined, so I like him in standard scoring.
Felix has the most talent and the most upside, but whether he gets enough touches is debateable.
Leon in a PPR (though I expect Ahmad to catch a lot more balls this year, as he basically inherited Ware's role).
Bell will be irrelevent by Columbus Day.
Brown is intriguing but I see less potential there than I did with Addai back when he was sharing with Dom Rhodes. The role reversal is ironic, but I just don't see the Indy RBBC being the force it once was.
timschochet
Footballguy
Fred Jackson
sho nuff
Footballguy
"inside the 10" very cleverly worded...since Dwil scored from the 11...and got this one in the 2nd quarter.1st-10, PHI10 2:00 D. Williams rushed up the middle for 2 yard gain
but he also got these...at the end...and did not score...
2nd-3, PHI3 1:01 D. Williams rushed up the middle for no gain
3rd-3, PHI3 0:51 D. Williams rushed up the middle for 2 yard gain
4th-1, PHI1 0:34 D. Williams rushed to the right for 1 yard loss
Stewart got the few before the penalty and Dwill took it in from the 11.
That was pretty much it for Stewart inside the 10.
circelli17
Footballguy
I'm a big fan of Jackson and also Jerious Norwoodtimschochet said:
dmac37
Footballguy
Thanks, I missed the end of the game and didn't know about those last carries for Williams.
thekidd2009
Footballguy
He didn't have every carry inside the 10. Dwill carried the ball the entire first drive and scored. If i remember the panthers were inside the ten and there was a penalty which pushed them back a bit.
UnknownCoach
Footballguy
This could have been a good topic, but it just looks like someone asking who he should pick up off the wire.
1-10-CAR30 (14:54) J.Delhomme pass short right to S.Smith to CAR 38 for 8 yards (A.Samuel).2-2-CAR38 (14:31) D.Williams right tackle to CAR 47 for 9 yards (S.Brown).
1-10-CAR47 (13:54) D.Williams up the middle to CAR 48 for 1 yard (O.Gaither).
2-9-CAR48 (13:13) J.Delhomme pass incomplete short right to M.Muhammad.
3-9-CAR48 (13:06) J.Delhomme pass incomplete short left to S.Smith.
PENALTY on PHI-J.Parker, Face Mask (15 Yards), 15 yards, enforced at CAR 48 - No Play.
1-10-PHI37 (13:00) D.Williams left tackle to PHI 27 for 10 yards (V.Abiamiri).
1-10-PHI27 (12:13) PENALTY on CAR-J.King, False Start, 5 yards, enforced at PHI 27 - No Play.
1-15-PHI32 (12:13) (Shotgun) S.Smith left end to PHI 28 for 4 yards (T.Cole).
2-11-PHI28 (11:11) J.Delhomme scrambles up the middle to PHI 18 for 10 yards (B.Bunkley).
3-1-PHI18 (10:30) J.Delhomme pass short right to D.Williams to PHI 11 for 7 yards (O.Gaither).
1-10-PHI11 (10:01) J.Stewart right end to PHI 3 for 8 yards (Q.Mikell).
2-2-PHI3 (10:01) J.Stewart up the middle to PHI 2 for 1 yard (A.Jordan).
3-1-PHI2 (8:29) J.Stewart right tackle to PHI 2 for no gain (O.Gaither, M.Patterson).
4-1-PHI2 (8:15) J.Stewart right tackle to PHI 1 for 1 yard (V.Abiamiri).
1-1-PHI1 (8:15) PENALTY on CAR-R.Kalil, False Start, 5 yards, enforced at PHI 1 - No Play.
1-6-PHI6 (7:02) PENALTY on CAR-J.Otah, False Start, 5 yards, enforced at PHI 6 - No Play.
1-11-PHI11 (7:02) D.Williams left end for 11 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
J.Kasay extra point is GOOD, Center-J.Jansen, Holder-J.Baker.
PHI 0 CAR 7, Plays: 13 Yards: 70 Possession: 8:06.
RamMan
Footballguy
So, adding Bush to the discussion (and dropping Caddy since I agree he's a 1A), in non-ppr redraft I'd rank them: StewartBradshawLeonBush BrownFelixIf the 1A were to get injured, I'd rank them:Stewart (would be a stud)Bradshaw (would also be a stud)Bush (would be very good)Brown (would be very good)Leon (would probably get a few more touches than now but I think Shonn Green would take T. Jones' place)Felix (same as Leon but with Choice taking Barber's touches).
fozzy fosbourne
Footballguy
Seems like there's more 1b's out there. McGahee looks ownable for sure
Similar threads
