Best QB's in their first 9 years? (1 Viewer)

[mtffl2]

does anyone know of a website that list the all time records for a certain period of a players career?

my boss is saying that Peyton has the best first 9 years of any QB of all time... i find that hard to believe. he's good, but the best of all time... i doubt it.

does anyone know of some names that i can throw out to contradict what he is saying?

 

[Reservoir Dog]

does anyone know of a website that list the all time records for a certain period of a players career? my boss is saying that Peyton has the best first 9 years of any QB of all time... i find that hard to believe. he's good, but the best of all time... i doubt it.does anyone know of some names that i can throw out to contradict what he is saying?

You might be in trouble, guy.

 

[DoubleG]

Did Jesus play QB after coming out of Jerusalem U.?

If not, you may be in trouble. How much you owe your boss?

 

[Burning Sensation]

does anyone know of a website that list the all time records for a certain period of a players career? my boss is saying that Peyton has the best first 9 years of any QB of all time... i find that hard to believe. he's good, but the best of all time... i doubt it.does anyone know of some names that i can throw out to contradict what he is saying?

You might be in trouble, guy.

Assuming you are talking about TD's and yardage. The only guy who might have a shot is Marino, but if not, your boss just you.

 

[JoeSteeler]

Marino 84-92: 37,292yds 270 Td

Manning 98-06: 37,586 275

Does Favre have a chance?

 

[JoeSteeler]

Wait. It has to be their FIRST 9 years or ANY 9 years? If it's first 9 years you can subtract 1900 and 4 tds from Marino.

 

[mtffl2]

no money, just pride on the line... he's got a man crush on anyone from the university of tennessee and i like to prove him wrong, but i can't deny how good peyton is....

was tarkenton any good in the beginning? what about george blanda? i've never seen peyton kick a football... so george has a leg up on him (pun intended)

 

[mtffl2]

Wait. It has to be their FIRST 9 years or ANY 9 years?

he's gonna say first 9 years, but any 9 years should be enough to crush his man love for peyton...

 

[Bri]

guess-Moon might since he came to the NFL as a veteran of the CFL ready to play

 

[mtffl2]

what about Don Hutson... was he any good?

 

[Ed4252]

Tarkenton was good but he never got more than 3000 yds passing in season except in 1967 and 1978.

Others that had good seasons in the first 9 years were Montana/Unitas but not as good as Manning.

 

[JoeSteeler]

no money, just pride on the line... he's got a man crush on anyone from the university of tennessee and i like to prove him wrong, but i can't deny how good peyton is....

was tarkenton any good in the beginning? what about george blanda? i've never seen peyton kick a football... so george has a leg up on him (pun intended)

I don't think either of these guys come close. Blanda didn't throw 20+ TD until 12 years into his career.Here is a good site for stats.

 

[Reservoir Dog]

what about Don Hutson... was he any good?

Great....but he was a WR.

 

[Ed4252]

what about Don Hutson... was he any good?

Don Hutson was a WR.

 

[mtffl2]

or what about Len Dawson, Steve Young, or Johnny Unitas?

 

[Bri]

If Trent Green throws for 10k this year he's got a shot

 

[Reservoir Dog]

The only one close is Marino.

 

[Bri]

guess-Moon might since he came to the NFL as a veteran of the CFL ready to play

quick glance it's close(well..) at leasthttp://www.profootballreference.com/players/MoonWa00.htm

Esp if you keep in mind two strike shortenned seasons

 

[Ed4252]

or what about Len Dawson, Steve Young, or Johnny Unitas?

Steve Young is a definite No. He didn't have good stats in his first two years with TAM. He didn't really emerge until 1991-his 7th year.

 

[mtffl2]

thanks everyone... i'll e-mail him some of these guys. it should keep him busy for a little while looking up everyones stats!!!!

 

[JoeSteeler]

Favre 94-02: 35,755 yds 277 TD

Close

 

[Bri]

Favre 94-02: 35,755 yds 277 TDClose

backup to start though

 

[adog99]

Tom Brady 3 Super Bowl rings in 7 years !!

 

[JoeSteeler]

Favre 94-02: 35,755 yds 277 TDClose

backup to start though

He was backup for only 1 year. Thats why I asked if it had to be first 9 years or any 9 years.

 

[mtffl2]

steelers, you are an evil genius! i appreciate the number you are throwing out...

 

[mtffl2]

[

Here is a good site for stats.

guess-Moon might since he came to the NFL as a veteran of the CFL ready to play

quick glance it's close(well..) at leasthttp://www.profootballreference.com/players/MoonWa00.htm

Esp if you keep in mind two strike shortenned seasons

i didn't realize that moon was such a bad ### in his day...

 

[DawnBTVS]

Jim Kelly? low totals though but 4 SB appearances isn't anything to scoff at...

1986-1994: 29,527 yards and 201 TD

 

[Bri]

Favre 94-02: 35,755 yds 277 TDClose

backup to start though

He was backup for only 1 year. Thats why I asked if it had to be first 9 years or any 9 years.

ahh good point

 

[JoeSteeler]

[

Here is a good site for stats.

guess-Moon might since he came to the NFL as a veteran of the CFL ready to play

quick glance it's close(well..) at leasthttp://www.profootballreference.com/players/MoonWa00.htm

Esp if you keep in mind two strike shortenned seasons

i didn't realize that moon was such a bad ### in his day...

One of my all time favorite QBs! The run and shoot gave him an opportunity to put up some big numbers!

 

[SSOG]

what about Don Hutson... was he any good?

Yes, I think many old-timers would argue that Don Hutson was the best player to ever play at his position. Unfortunately for you, that position was WR, not QB.

 

[David Yudkin]

Do people just not know about our Historical Data Dominator? It only goes back to 1960 . . .

Passing Yards through 9 years:

1 Peyton Manning qb 1998--2006 37586

2 Dan Marino qb 1983--1991 35386

3 Brett Favre qb 1991--1999 30894

4 Warren Moon qb 1984--1992 30200

5 Drew Bledsoe qb 1993--2001 29657

6 Jim Kelly qb 1986--1994 29527

7 John Elway qb 1983--1991 27974

8 Jim Everett qb 1986--1994 27613

9 Jake Plummer qb 1997--2005 27259

10 Kerry Collins qb 1995--2003 26381

11 Troy Aikman qb 1989--1997 26016

12 Boomer Esiason qb 1984--1992 25671

13 Trent Green qb 1997--2005 25621

14 Mark Brunell qb 1994--2002 25309

15 Joe Montana qb 1979--1987 24552

16 Ken O'Brien qb 1984--1992 24386

17 Dan Fouts qb 1973--1981 24256

18 Jeff George qb 1990--1998 23229

19 Fran Tarkenton qb 1961--1969 23140

20 Neil Lomax qb 1981--1988 22771

Passing TD through 9 years:

1 Peyton Manning qb 1998--2006 275

2 Dan Marino qb 1983--1991 266

3 Brett Favre qb 1991--1999 235

4 Jim Kelly qb 1986--1994 201

5 Fran Tarkenton qb 1961--1969 186

6 Warren Moon qb 1984--1992 175

7 Boomer Esiason qb 1984--1992 174

8 Joe Montana qb 1979--1987 172

9 Drew Bledsoe qb 1993--2001 166

10 John Hadl qb 1962--1970 165

11 Jim Everett qb 1986--1994 164

12 Donovan McNabb qb 1999--2006 152

13 Trent Green qb 1997--2005 150

13 Jake Plummer qb 1997--2005 150

15 John Elway qb 1983--1991 148

15 Dave Krieg qb 1980--1988 148

17 Tom Brady qb 2000--2006 147

18 Dan Fouts qb 1973--1981 145

19 Daryle Lamonica qb 1963--1971 143

20 Mark Brunell qb 1994--2002 142

20 Norm Snead qb 1961--1969 142

 

[David Yudkin]

does anyone know of a website that list the all time records for a certain period of a players career? my boss is saying that Peyton has the best first 9 years of any QB of all time... i find that hard to believe. he's good, but the best of all time... i doubt it.does anyone know of some names that i can throw out to contradict what he is saying?

Your boss is right.

 

[Block]

Do people just not know about our Historical Data Dominator? It only goes back to 1960 . . .

Passing Yards through 9 years:

1 Peyton Manning qb 1998--2006 37586

2 Dan Marino qb 1983--1991 35386

3 Brett Favre qb 1991--1999 30894

4 Warren Moon qb 1984--1992 30200

5 Drew Bledsoe qb 1993--2001 29657

6 Jim Kelly qb 1986--1994 29527

7 John Elway qb 1983--1991 27974

8 Jim Everett qb 1986--1994 27613

9 Jake Plummer qb 1997--2005 27259

10 Kerry Collins qb 1995--2003 26381

11 Troy Aikman qb 1989--1997 26016

12 Boomer Esiason qb 1984--1992 25671

13 Trent Green qb 1997--2005 25621

14 Mark Brunell qb 1994--2002 25309

15 Joe Montana qb 1979--1987 24552

16 Ken O'Brien qb 1984--1992 24386

17 Dan Fouts qb 1973--1981 24256

18 Jeff George qb 1990--1998 23229

19 Fran Tarkenton qb 1961--1969 23140

20 Neil Lomax qb 1981--1988 22771

Passing TD through 9 years:

1 Peyton Manning qb 1998--2006 275

2 Dan Marino qb 1983--1991 266

3 Brett Favre qb 1991--1999 235

4 Jim Kelly qb 1986--1994 201

5 Fran Tarkenton qb 1961--1969 186

6 Warren Moon qb 1984--1992 175

7 Boomer Esiason qb 1984--1992 174

8 Joe Montana qb 1979--1987 172

9 Drew Bledsoe qb 1993--2001 166

10 John Hadl qb 1962--1970 165

11 Jim Everett qb 1986--1994 164

12 Donovan McNabb qb 1999--2006 152

13 Trent Green qb 1997--2005 150

13 Jake Plummer qb 1997--2005 150

15 John Elway qb 1983--1991 148

15 Dave Krieg qb 1980--1988 148

17 Tom Brady qb 2000--2006 147

18 Dan Fouts qb 1973--1981 145

19 Daryle Lamonica qb 1963--1971 143

20 Mark Brunell qb 1994--2002 142

20 Norm Snead qb 1961--1969 142

Jake Plummer and Mark Brunell on that yardage list surprise me.

 

[mtffl2]

i've never messed with the historical data dominator, but i will....

i felt good about my argument for the other guys until you posted those lists. hopefully my boss won't find this site, i'll still try to make him think he's wrong.

 

[DoubleG]

i've never messed with the historical data dominator, but i will....i felt good about my argument for the other guys until you posted those lists. hopefully my boss won't find this site, i'll still try to make him think he's wrong.

Ummmm...why? If he's right, man up.

 

[Block]

i've never messed with the historical data dominator, but i will....i felt good about my argument for the other guys until you posted those lists. hopefully my boss won't find this site, i'll still try to make him think he's wrong.

If you count backwards yardage Andre Ware might have a shot.

 

[mtffl2]

i will tell him eventually, but it'll keep him busy for a little while...

 

[David Yudkin]

After 9 seasons, Manning already ranks 10th in completiions, 13th in passing yards, and 7th in passing TD. And he just turned 31.

 

[BassNBrew]

i've never messed with the historical data dominator, but i will....i felt good about my argument for the other guys until you posted those lists. hopefully my boss won't find this site, i'll still try to make him think he's wrong.

Explains why he's the boss and you're the peon.Try the Hutson argument on him...may impress him enough to get a promotion to the mail room.

 

[PsychoMan]

this thread is funny

 

[Kirby]

What's the definition of best? Brady already has three rings and he's been in the league 7.

 

[Banger]

What's the definition of best? Brady already has three rings and he's been in the league 7.

here we go...Brady v. Manning ... part 32

 

[Marek]

What's sad is this is how the internet enables so many people behave. They start with a conclusion (on a topic they didn't really know much on to begin with), and then work backwards. Let's run to Google to search through mountains of info to cherry pick things that will lend evidence to my conclusion!! Then I can try to regurgitate that info later as if I knew it all along!

Even worse is actually coming here and saying "lol, I really don't know anything about this and now I'm trying to save face. Someone else, please argue for me because I'm unable to." Someone should get your boss to come read this so he can laugh at how badly he sent you scrambling.

 

[Despyzer]

After 9 seasons, Manning already ranks 10th in completiions, 13th in passing yards, and 7th in passing TD. And he just turned 31.

Even better, he's got the pecs, abs, and biceps of a man nineteen years younger!

 

[PsychoMan]

What's the definition of best? Brady already has three rings and he's been in the league 7.

here we go...Brady v. Manning ... part 932

fixed

 

[corpcow]

If Trent Green throws for 10k this year he's got a shot

 

[corpcow]

What's sad is this is how the internet enables so many people behave. They start with a conclusion (on a topic they didn't really know much on to begin with), and then work backwards. Let's run to Google to search through mountains of info to cherry pick things that will lend evidence to my conclusion!! Then I can try to regurgitate that info later as if I knew it all along!Even worse is actually coming here and saying "lol, I really don't know anything about this and now I'm trying to save face. Someone else, please argue for me because I'm unable to." Someone should get your boss to come read this so he can laugh at how badly he sent you scrambling.

Haha. This is precisely what happened with all the recent accounting scandals - we want the numbers to look like this, now figure out how to make it so.

 

[Kleck.]

does anyone know of a website that list the all time records for a certain period of a players career? my boss is saying that Peyton has the best first 9 years of any QB of all time... i find that hard to believe. he's good, but the best of all time... i doubt it.does anyone know of some names that i can throw out to contradict what he is saying?

Brilliant move! Now you can search the net all day looking up football stats, that won't save you, without catching heat from your boss.

 

[PsychoMan]

 

[DoubleG]

What's the definition of best? Brady already has three rings and he's been in the league 7.

Stats, man - does Brady play defense now too?!?Oh yeah, and using that definition, Marino was gawd awful - as was Dan Fouts, Fran Tarkenton, et. al. Oh wait, but Jim McMahon was better than all of them, cuz he got a ring!! GO BEARS!! Players win games, orginizations win championships. Goober >> Brady.