Best WR Of This Group! (1 Viewer)

[mightyeskimo]

In my ongoing trade talks I hope to acquire one of these WR's. I'd like to hear opinion on who you think is best and why. Here's my observations:

Andre Johnson-The best pure athlete in the group. The downside to him is his situation. Will Carr get yanked if he continues to dissapoint? Will the O-line get better or worse? Will the D get better? Will the #2 WR take some heat off Johnson? I think there are too many questions on the team as a whole to choose Andre. He comes in #4. Agree or disagree?

Plaxico Burress-Great physical WR. The only knock on Plax is the consistency, which I believe will be corrected with coaching and personal development. He has a good QB who will continue to get better. A very good O-line. Good coaching. A D that continues to improve. Good talent for the #2 WR position. The only situational downside is the loss of Tiki due to retirement. If Plax had caught more targets he would have had a monster year instead of a very good year. Plax is my choice here. Agree or disagree?

Darrell Jackson-Very talented. In a good offense with a good QB. A RB with 3 more great years ahead of him. Another good D. The O-line will miss Hutch but I think they'll carry on well. Another good #2 WR. The downside here is health. Will his knee give him problems and does it increase the chance of further injury. I rate him #2 here. Agree or disagree?

Javon Walker-The only reason I claimed Andre is the top talent is due to Javon's knee injury. How bad will his knee hurt his performance. I think Jackson's injury was less severe. How long does Plummer have before Cutler takes over? The running game is always solid in Denver. The D also continues to improve. The O-line is well coached. As long as Smith stays they have another solid WR (also, many claim with good reason that Smith is the real #1 on this team). Good talent in Marshall as well. Everything hinges on the knee. He's #3 on this list for me. Agree or disagree?

League info and roster in the sig.

 

[Armando]

I'd take Jackson #1 pretty easily.

 

[mightyeskimo]

I'd take Jackson #1 pretty easily.

Why?

 

[The Mechanic]

I'd take Jackson #1 pretty easily.

Why?

Conferance, schedule, QB & Running game. Might as well through in Cheerleaders.

 

[Armando]

Because he's the best WR in the best situation.

Hasselback will be in Seattle for another 5-10 years.

Eli and Plax already hate each other and I believe Sinorice Moss was a steal in the draft. And in time, I see him putting a dent into Burress's production.

Javon Walker -- coming off torn ACL & will ultimately have to endure Cutler's growing pains (if he pans out at all); run first offense

Andre Johnson -- David Carr has not shown anything that he's a capable starting NFL QB.

 

[zamboni]

I would rank them as follows:

1) D-Jax - most consistent of the bunch; great rapport with solid QB; injury history certainly a concern, but that could happen to anyone

2) Andre Johnson: I like the addition of Kubiak to help Carr along; and if not Carr, I think Kubiak will find another solid option; whoever the QB is will likely have AJ as his top target

3) Walker: he should assume top target status probably next year; if it weren't for an unseasoned QB in Cutler assuming the reins, he might be #2 on this list

4) Plaxico: not a big drop from the other three, but his inconsistency/penchant for disappearing for long stretches concerns me; if Sinorice Moss doesn't progress, it wouldn't surprise me to see Coughlin get another top target after this year, which could cut into Plax's numbers

 

[pinequick]

I would take this thread to the ACF.