Blockbuster Trade...Is this fair??? WHIR (1 Viewer)

[MissionCoach]

12 tem league, ppr, standard scoring

Roethlisberger, D. Freeman, and Dez Bryant for Stafford, Gurley, and P. Dorsett

Is this a fair trade?  If not, which side has the better value?

Leave a link, WHIR

 

[PiKappEK328]

That's tough... I think Big Ben bounces back in a couple of weeks, and Dez Bryant should be playing in week 8.  I think side A (Big Ben, Freeman, and Dez) is the better side.  If side B had a diff WR (someone like Landry), then I would go with side B.

 

[Gally]

One side is building for a stretch/playoff run so if you are assured of a playoff spot I would definitely want Big Ben/Dez side.  Even if you are not assured playoffs I still might take the injured players.

Dorsett is fairly useless so that really hurts that side.  Like the previous poster mentioned, if you can upgrade the Dorsett portion of the trade then the Stafford side would be a lot more appealing.