Brady the choke artist... (1 Viewer)

[Jrodicus]

Just sayin'.

Let the fight begin...er...continue.

 

[Bigboy10182000]

:IBTL:

 

[sports_fan]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

 

[fantasycurse42]

Who was he even throwing the ball to? Slater, Mulligan, Dobson, Mouuhrrjjrinrnwalli...

Pretty sure if Brady was surrounded by the cast in Den, the results would've been much different.

 

[Sweet Love]

Who was he even throwing the ball to? Slater, Mulligan, Dobson, Mouuhrrjjrinrnwalli...

Pretty sure if Brady was surrounded by the cast in Den, the results would've been much different.

Seriously...Manning's fourth passing option (Welker) is better than Brady's first option. I am a Jets fan...would love for my QB to "choke" as much Brady.

 

[Bigboy10182000]

Who was he even throwing the ball to? Slater, Mulligan, Dobson, Mouuhrrjjrinrnwalli...

Pretty sure if Brady was surrounded by the cast in Den, the results would've been much different.

Seriously...Manning's fourth passing option (Welker) is better than Brady's first option. I am a Jets fan...would love for my QB to "choke" as much Brady.

31 other cities agree

 

[msommer]

With stinky bait no less.

Eventually the 'choker' label on Manning will have to be removed, instead of revived. But that doesn't excuse this thread.

 

[JuniorNB]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

He's a .500 playoff QB since the Spygate year.

 

[Dinsy Ejotuz]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

Better check the "one game" and "career" parts there.

 

[Dinsy Ejotuz]

Who was he even throwing the ball to? Slater, Mulligan, Dobson, Mouuhrrjjrinrnwalli...

Pretty sure if Brady was surrounded by the cast in Den, the results would've been much different.

Weird. Manning's situation (defense) was always discounted when he "choked". It's almost like there's a double standard or something.

 

[Ghost Rider]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

I disagree with this thread's premise, but Brady has had a lot piss poor playoff performances over the years, so it's not like yesterday was his first crappy playoff game (and years from now, I suspect some will look at just his stats and surmise that he had a good game). Oddly, most of his poor playoff performances have come in AFC championship games. Still one of the best ever, though.

 

[Bigboy10182000]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

He's a .500 playoff QB since the Spygate year.

Since Spygate doesnt Manning have a SUB .500 playoff record?

 

[Rick James]

4-6 in his last 10 playoff appearances, with 10 interceptions.

 

[Ghost Rider]

4-6 in his last 10 playoff appearances, with 10 interceptions.

And 18 touchdown passes. As much as I like having the Brady/Manning debate, it is stupid to me when people nitpick Peyton, who is clearly one of the top QBs ever, and it's stupid to me to see people today nitpicking Brady, who is also clearly one of the top QBs ever.

 

[JuniorNB]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

He's a .500 playoff QB since the Spygate year.

Since Spygate doesnt Manning have a SUB .500 playoff record?

Manning's rep for being a bad clutch QB is well known. He does have a ring however.

 

[Bigboy10182000]

4-6 in his last 10 playoff appearances, with 10 interceptions.

And 18 touchdown passes. As much as I like having the Brady/Manning debate, it is stupid to me when people nitpick Peyton, who is clearly one of the top QBs ever, and it's stupid to me to see people today nitpicking Brady, who is also clearly one of the top QBs ever.

BUT YOU HAVE TO PICK JUST ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Bigboy10182000]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

He's a .500 playoff QB since the Spygate year.

Since Spygate doesnt Manning have a SUB .500 playoff record?

Manning's rep for being a bad clutch QB is well known. He does have a ring however.

i agree. And with all that being said, are they both great QB's? Yes.

 

[JuniorNB]

So one game negates a career of clutchness?

He's a .500 playoff QB since the Spygate year.

Since Spygate doesnt Manning have a SUB .500 playoff record?

Manning's rep for being a bad clutch QB is well known. He does have a ring however.

i agree. And with all that being said, are they both great QB's? Yes.

Yes

 

[T with T]

Just sayin'.

Let the fight begin...er...continue.

overmatched is a better word for it....... no wrs and peytons are all 6-5..... lopsided talent to not make Brady take all the blame although I predicted Den Sea a long time ago.

 

[T with T]

Who was he even throwing the ball to? Slater, Mulligan, Dobson, Mouuhrrjjrinrnwalli...

Pretty sure if Brady was surrounded by the cast in Den, the results would've been much different.

 

[T with T]

Don't forget the almighty Edelman...

 

[Thunderlips]

Winning those Super Bowls early has his legacy all the cushion that he needs.....but he hasn't exactly been a juggernaut in the playoffs since Spygate......so much so....that I do think the "overrated" tag has to be placed on him.

 

[Bills_Fan11]

4-6 in his last 10 playoff appearances, with 10 interceptions.

And 18 touchdown passes. As much as I like having the Brady/Manning debate, it is stupid to me when people nitpick Peyton, who is clearly one of the top QBs ever, and it's stupid to me to see people today nitpicking Brady, who is also clearly one of the top QBs ever.

BUT YOU HAVE TO PICK JUST ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

No reasonable person disagrees.

There's just something awfully befitting about the Brady camp explaining circumstances and how it's a team game after years and years of "you can have your stats I'll take the clutch wins bro".

They deserve all the trolling they get.

 

[Thunderlips]

Who was he even throwing the ball to? Slater, Mulligan, Dobson, Mouuhrrjjrinrnwalli...

Pretty sure if Brady was surrounded by the cast in Den, the results would've been much different.

Meh....a bull#### defense.....seeing as he did it with scrubs back in the day and they have/had a decent running game. Plus....that defense isn't extended to just about any other players when their team comes up short.