Braylon Edwards or Brandon Marshall (1 Viewer)

[hardtellin]

Considering Edwards ACL injury and these receivers' offenses and QBs, is Marshall a better pick? Even tho he doesn't have great speed, Marshall is a big receiver who could be a dominant player in Shanahan's offense, and Edwards' injury may take away some of his speed.

 

[Blackjacks]

I'll stick with Edwards

 

[wannabee]

Edwards has a ton more value. With, ot without his injury, many still think he could be special. Marshall has a chance to be a starting WR for the Broncos, but the chances are much more with Edwards. If nothing else, Edwards has much more opportunity to start/excel.

 

[Weiner Dog]

Considering Edwards ACL injury and these receivers' offenses and QBs, is Marshall a better pick? Even tho he doesn't have great speed, Marshall is a big receiver who could be a dominant player in Shanahan's offense, and Edwards' injury may take away some of his speed.

Are you seriously being serious, or are you not being serious??

 

[BroadwayG]

You are spot on with Marshall. I've got him permanent sharpied in for 90/1400/12 per season for the next 12 years.

M. Jenkins still owes me a 220/4200/38 season to catch up.

 

[JMon348]

this has to be a joke...........braylon not even close, im in the minority, but i have edwards in the top 15 dynasty WRs, i think his future is bright.

 

[Team Legacy]

You are spot on with Marshall.  I've got him permanent sharpied in for 90/1400/12 per season for the next 12 years. 

M. Jenkins still owes me a 220/4200/38 season to catch up.

Charles Rogers owes me more than that!

 

[The Man With No Name]

Considering Edwards ACL injury and these receivers' offenses and QBs, is Marshall a better pick? Even tho he doesn't have great speed, Marshall is a big receiver who could be a dominant player in Shanahan's offense, and Edwards' injury may take away some of his speed.

Torn ACL's have little to nothing to do with a players speed. Ask Drew Carter.

 

[P Boy]

Holy crap. I'm a Donkey fan & Marshall's upside really intrigues me - I'm very glad Shanahan took a chance on him.

Given all that, I take Edwards every day of the week & twice on Sunday over Marshall.

Wow.

 

[Kit Fisto]

Edwards could be a stud for years and years.

Marshall is nice, but not stud-caliber.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

hardtellin is NOT my alias for the record

this is not even close, and there's not too many people higher on marshall than I am.

 

[P Boy]

hardtellin is NOT my alias for the record

 

[mightyeskimo]

You are spot on with Marshall. I've got him permanent sharpied in for 90/1400/12 per season for the next 12 years.

Seriously bro, Sharpie abuse is a big deal! I think it's time to get your Sharpie weened off of China White!

 

[wannabee]

hardtellin is NOT my alias for the record

this is not even close, and there's not too many people higher on marshall than I am.

It has to be either you or Chaos ..... hhhhhmmmmmmm So, since it is not even close, are you choosing Marshall?