Wow. Really? One of the best albums ever. To be listened to in perfect silence or with high end headphones only.
I'm in for this for sure.
Sure you know this already, but for the benefit of the thread:
The excellent Beatles thread breaks down the chronology in which Wilson was inspired by Rubber Soul to create Pet Sounds, which in turn spurred on the Beatles to their masterpieces Revolver and Sgt. Peppers. Maybe it isn't entirely an accident but partly a product of that friendly rivalry and dynamic interplay between geniuses that on many polls Pet Sounds or Sgt Peppers are ranked as the #1 & #2 greatest albums in pop/rock history - Rolling Stone has SP #1 & PS #2, many UK publications like MOJO and Uncut have the reverse order (Rolling Stone had Good Vibrations #6 on their GOAT song list, MOJO #1).
Wilson seems to have suffered from some form of mental illness (schizophrenia, he reportedly heard voices?), which also claimed Syd Barrett of Pink Floyd. Unlike Barrett, Wilson was eventually able to return to productivity, helped in a huge way by his eventual second wife, who extricated him from a nightmarish relationship of dependence on an unorthodox, abusive psychotherapist. As with Barrett, heavy drug use may not have been the ultimate root cause of his primary issues, but may have hastened the process of breakdown. Due to a combination of these factors, and perhaps band member Mike Love lacking the ability to appreciate what a visionary work of art Smile could have been, it was shelved for many years, until being reconstituted decades later with assistance from others. Smile was to be Wilson's answer to Revolver and Sgt. Peppers. If it had come out as intended and in a timely manner, we can only speculate about whether that would have ratcheted up the figurative call and response rivalry between Wilson and The Beatles, and something even greater than Magical Mystery Tour might have emerged. We'll never know, maybe in a parallel universe?
BTW, drummer Hal Blaine, the informal leader of The Wrecking Crew, which also featured bassist Carol Kaye and guitarist Tommy Tedesco, who all worked on literally hundreds of hits in every conceivable genre (well, maybe not Tuvan throat singing

), and worked with countless brilliant artists, I think claimed Brian Wilson was special and on a completely different level even by these rarified standards, and the greatest musical genius he ever encountered. Similarly, the great Beatles producer George Martin was in awe of Wilson. He claimed that Wilson, basically BY HIMSELF (of course he needed The Wrecking Crew's brilliant instrumentalists and musicianship and the Beach Boys vocal harmonies to help flesh out and realize the music in his head) was able to accomplish what it took Martin's production expertise in his domain, the song writing genius of Lennon/McCartney and the musical ability of all four Beatles, the greatest band ever, to match. Like Martin and the Beatles, and Phil Spector in the US, Wilson was a pioneer in the art of record production, engineering and the concept of STUDIO AS INSTRUMENT (in a different way, the orchestra was Duke Ellington's instrument, he shaped and sculpted his songs and composed with them in mind AS INDIVIDUALS, not just generic instrumental passages, but accounting for their strengths and weaknesses, and unique voices and TONAL CHARACTERISTICS).
Martin on Wilson