I'm happy about this. There's no way they were sneaking him through waivers, and it's not like they'll suffer so many injuries that they'll need their 4th RB in the next week or two before he gets back.
Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
I'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.
I agree, Hillman looks the best, but Ball looks like pretty darn good at GL.ninerfanatic492000 said:bonesman said:Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.Jackal King said:I know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
Why do people make things up to make hemselves feel better about their position? Every team needs more than 1 running back and Moreno has injury concerns so of course other RBS are involvedAnarchy99 said:I find it interesting that people think Moreno will be the lead share holder when last year he only played a role when they had to play him. The team has been reluctant to make him the primary ball carrier and each year brought in someone else to run the ball. That still to me tells me that Moreno is not viewed as a main ball carrier or with long term potential in Denver, no matter how much coach speak there is to talk him up. Maybe Moreno will see a little more work in the beginning of the season, but the current coaching staff in DEN drafted Bell and Hillman and will coach them up and eventually both will have bigger roles than Moreno.
Hillman looks the worst all around (Pass protection , fumbling, power are all major problems)I agree, Hillman looks the best, but Ball looks like pretty darn good at GL.ninerfanatic492000 said:bonesman said:Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.Jackal King said:I know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
Yudkin didn't make anything up at all. Yudkin's take is right on the money.Why do people make things up to make hemselves feel better about their position? Every team needs more than 1 running back and Moreno has injury concerns so of course other RBS are involvedAnarchy99 said:I find it interesting that people think Moreno will be the lead share holder when last year he only played a role when they had to play him. The team has been reluctant to make him the primary ball carrier and each year brought in someone else to run the ball. That still to me tells me that Moreno is not viewed as a main ball carrier or with long term potential in Denver, no matter how much coach speak there is to talk him up. Maybe Moreno will see a little more work in the beginning of the season, but the current coaching staff in DEN drafted Bell and Hillman and will coach them up and eventually both will have bigger roles than Moreno.
- rookie season easily led the team in carries
- 2nd season easily lead the team in carriees despite getting injured
- 3rd season injured almost the entire season
- 4th season - Despite all of the previous injuries was #2 behind Mcghee who was a solid veteran RB
- 5th Season - Again overcoming injuries and seems to be favorite for starting role
There's no concerns about Hillman's pass protection.Hillman looks the worst all around (Pass protection , fumbling, power are all major problems)I agree, Hillman looks the best, but Ball looks like pretty darn good at GL.ninerfanatic492000 said:bonesman said:Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.Jackal King said:I know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
Ball looks the best running (Pass protection, receiving ? a concern)
Moreno best all around (Best Pass protection, Best Receiver and solid not spectacular runner, more power than Hillman less than Ball. injuries are a concern)
You may not be concerned but Denver is ... google it there's plenty about itThere's no concerns about Hillman's pass protection.Hillman looks the worst all around (Pass protection , fumbling, power are all major problems)I agree, Hillman looks the best, but Ball looks like pretty darn good at GL.ninerfanatic492000 said:bonesman said:Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.Jackal King said:I know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
Ball looks the best running (Pass protection, receiving ? a concern)
Moreno best all around (Best Pass protection, Best Receiver and solid not spectacular runner, more power than Hillman less than Ball. injuries are a concern)
That's from a Bleacher Report article written in April. Find me something from August criticizing his pass protection. Hillman put in a lot of work, and is much improved from his rookie season.You may not be concerned but Denver is ... google it there's plenty about itThere's no concerns about Hillman's pass protection.Hillman looks the worst all around (Pass protection , fumbling, power are all major problems)I agree, Hillman looks the best, but Ball looks like pretty darn good at GL.ninerfanatic492000 said:bonesman said:Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.Jackal King said:I know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
Ball looks the best running (Pass protection, receiving ? a concern)
Moreno best all around (Best Pass protection, Best Receiver and solid not spectacular runner, more power than Hillman less than Ball. injuries are a concern)
Here's one quote but there's plenty more
At the same time, Hillman definitely has some room to grow though. He’s been criticized for his “pass-protection” skills.
I just saw the same NFL.com as wellJust saw a tweet that Hillman was named starter
Until the third run and fumble by hillman, then you will be doing the Ronnie hillman face palmIm doing the Ronnie Hillman 13th round shuffle right now![]()
Not really. I took him in the 13th round so there's pretty much nothing to lose. If Knowshon and Ball overtake him, so be it.Until the third run and fumble by hillman, then you will be doing the Ronnie hillman face palmIm doing the Ronnie Hillman 13th round shuffle right now![]()
But can you start him with any confidence at all in fantasy? Honestly, had they came out and said Ball is our guy, I think you could. If they had said Moreno is our guy, I think we could because we get the pass protection aspect. But with hillman, this has " you're the guy...until someone brings heat or until we get to the redzone" written all over it.Not really. I took him in the 13th round so there's pretty much nothing to lose. If Knowshon and Ball overtake him, so be it.Until the third run and fumble by hillman, then you will be doing the Ronnie hillman face palmIm doing the Ronnie Hillman 13th round shuffle right now![]()
I have him in a couple of leagues, no way can I start him with any confidence lolBut can you start him with any confidence at all in fantasy? Honestly, had they came out and said Ball is our guy, I think you could. If they had said Moreno is our guy, I think we could because we get the pass protection aspect. But with hillman, this has " you're the guy...until someone brings heat or until we get to the redzone" written all over it.Not really. I took him in the 13th round so there's pretty much nothing to lose. If Knowshon and Ball overtake him, so be it.Until the third run and fumble by hillman, then you will be doing the Ronnie hillman face palmIm doing the Ronnie Hillman 13th round shuffle right now![]()
Ther Weill probably be a thread dedicated to this coming this week of people who started hillman. I don't think it will take long considering the first opponent. I just don't see how I could, as a hillman owner, have him as a starter if I have any other options. This seems like a "congradudolences" thing. Congrats, you have the listed starter but you probably will have to watch these games for 2-3 weeks to understand when you can actually play him.
I can agree with this. In leagues where I own Hillman and Ball, I'm really conflicted on who to start in week 1, in a way I wouldn't be if Ball or Moreno were 1st string on the depth chart. I expect Hillman to get most of the touches, but Ball to have the highest chance at a TD.But can you start him with any confidence at all in fantasy? Honestly, had they came out and said Ball is our guy, I think you could. If they had said Moreno is our guy, I think we could because we get the pass protection aspect. But with hillman, this has " you're the guy...until someone brings heat or until we get to the redzone" written all over it.Not really. I took him in the 13th round so there's pretty much nothing to lose. If Knowshon and Ball overtake him, so be it.Until the third run and fumble by hillman, then you will be doing the Ronnie hillman face palmIm doing the Ronnie Hillman 13th round shuffle right now![]()
Ther Weill probably be a thread dedicated to this coming this week of people who started hillman. I don't think it will take long considering the first opponent. I just don't see how I could, as a hillman owner, have him as a starter if I have any other options. This seems like a "congradudolences" thing. Congrats, you have the listed starter but you probably will have to watch these games for 2-3 weeks to understand when you can actually play him.
Last year, Denver's backs combined for 449 carries for 1829 yards (4.06 ypc) with 12 TDs, plus another 65/518/1 receiving. That's good for 312.7 fantasy points in standard scoring leagues. I would expect the rushing TD total to come up, as well as the YPC some (I'd be hard-pressed to see Denver rushing for barely 4 ypc again given the amount of nickel defense they'll be facing- especially because Moreno was the primary reason it was so low, and Moreno's running 3rd on the depth chart). Call it 450 carries for 1935 yards (4.3 ypc) with 15 TDs, with maybe 60/500/2 receiving, or 345.5 points. Assume that 10% of that is going to go to Hester and Anderson (last season, Denver's 4th and 5th RBs were Hester and Lance Ball, who got 17.5% of the fantasy points... but that was largely a result of McGahee's injury). That leaves 311 points left to divide among Hillman, Ball, and Moreno.
Over the last 5 years, the average RB24 has scored 140 fantasy points in standard. The average RB18 has scored 164 fantasy points. Assuming all of my projections to this point are in the ballpark, and there's 311 fantasy points to divide among Hillman, Ball, and Moreno, oneback will need to score 45% of the fantasy points in order to be a very low-end RB2, or 53% of the fantasy points to be a middle-of-the-road RB2. Assuming the split won't be a perfect 33/33/33/ split (hint: it won't), then either of those are totally achievable. If it's 40/40/20, you've got a pair of crappy RB2s / fantastic flex plays. If the split is 50/30/20, you've got a very credible RB2 and a crappy flex play. If one of the three gets injured, you're either looking at a fantasy RB1 or else a fantasy RB2 + flex-worthy backup.
As it stands, I see Moreno getting maybe 20% of the split. I think he'll be the primary back when Denver's in its 2-minute offense, but in standard game situations, I expect him to be the 3rd option just like the depth chart says he is. That means either one of Hillman or Ball will almost certainly be startable (but underwhelming- we're talking low-to-middle-end RB2), or both will be flex-able.
At least, that's how I see everything playing out. There's a lot of risk inherent in the situation (I feel like my projections are realistic, but if Denver underperforms them, or if the split winds up closer to 33/33/33, or if C.J. Anderson throws his hat into the ring, you could be burning multiple roster spots on players who are completely unstartable, even as a flex). At the same time, there's a lot of upside, too.
Everyone looks good until the pads come onThat's from a Bleacher Report article written in April. Find me something from August criticizing his pass protection. Hillman put in a lot of work, and is much improved from his rookie season.You may not be concerned but Denver is ... google it there's plenty about itThere's no concerns about Hillman's pass protection.Hillman looks the worst all around (Pass protection , fumbling, power are all major problems)I agree, Hillman looks the best, but Ball looks like pretty darn good at GL.ninerfanatic492000 said:bonesman said:Quite literally anyone who is unbiased would say the same thing. Hillman looks the best of the 3.......if he can overcome fumbling the offense is so much better and explosiveI'm a Ball owner (and Moreno in one league) and I think Hillman has looked the best by far from what I've seen (fumbles aside of course). I hope he falls flat on his face but he's looked the most dangerous to me.Jackal King said:I know the hillman haters will throw rocks at this...but, it's possible that Fox wanted to get him a few carries to help get the yips out of Ronnies head. I think he was in there for only 3 plays...and his 2nd carry was an ankle tackle away from a long td. If nothing else, I think Hillman may have replinished a small amount of confidence.
Ball looks the best running (Pass protection, receiving ? a concern)
Moreno best all around (Best Pass protection, Best Receiver and solid not spectacular runner, more power than Hillman less than Ball. injuries are a concern)
Here's one quote but there's plenty more
At the same time, Hillman definitely has some room to grow though. He’s been criticized for his “pass-protection” skills.
Here's the Woody Paige of the Denver Post on July 28th:
Hillman is more comfortable and, Fox told me, "tenacious." Gaze said Hillman has made the second-year leap, and his blocking has improved.
Here's Mike Klis from the same paper on July 31st:
That Hillman has maintained his No. 1 spot on the tailback depth chart from Day One of the 2013 preseason speaks to his improvement in blocking for quarterback Peyton Manning.
The Broncos official site on May 24th:
One of his biggest leaps in improvement came in blitz pickup as a blocker... Through three days of OTAs, the team’s coaches have already seen an improvement in the pass-blocking abilities of the second-year running back.
“The thing that he’s shown us the last three days is at least his aggressiveness and willingness to go attack the blitzer,” Offensive Coordinator Adam Gase said. “That’s what we need to see. When we get in pads, that’s going to be a different deal as far as, OK, is he going to be able to sustain and do it consistently? I think he will."
Pads were on in the preseason. Hillman looked fine. He's not ever going to be the greatest blocker in the history of mankind, but he acquitted himself pretty well, and Denver had no problem entrusting Manning's neck to him when the bullets were live.Everyone looks good until the pads come on
I'll give you LaFell for himAs a Hillman owner who is now regretting the pick, Hillman being named the starter is great news. Even though I drafted him as my RB3/RB4, I still have no confidence starting him. This mess can can easily last throughout the year. I don't need that headache. With Hillman listed as the "starter" I am wondering what I can get in return for him in a trade before things flpflop again later.
I've got four slots burned on Denver RBs in a Dynasty league where I waited forever before drafting my backs (the three regulars plus C.J. Anderson). I was hoping Anderson would get cut and picked up by some other team. In the meantime, I comfort myself with the fact that we should have a lot more clarity in a couple of weeks, and by the time the byes approach I'll probably feel comfortable cutting one or even two of these guys loose again.regretting getting into this situation at all...and Im all in on it with all 3 of them (deep enough rosters to do it)...its my RB4...maybe 5 if the Vereen play lives up to any of the hype.
'I am trying to trade into this mess looking to trade Vereen and Pierce for Hillman and Ball (already have Moreno). I think someone emerges at some point.
NFL Network's Ian Rapoport reports the Broncos plan to use a running back by committee on a "drive-by-drive" basis.
As opposed to a "play-by-play" basis, the "drive-by-drive" formula will allow Ronnie Hillman, Montee Ball, and Knowshon Moreno to "stay in" and "go fast" in the Broncos' hurry-up attack. Hillman is expected to get the "start" on Thursday, but it's anyone's guess who will end up leading the backfield in touches against the Ravens. Our money's on Ball. As our own Evan Silva noted in his "Matchups" column, it's best to take a wait-and-see approach for the opener.
Related: Knowshon Moreno, Montee Ball
Source: Ian Rapoport on Twitter
They'll all be asked to block if that's true. The problem will be that if a guy misses a block and gets pulled, he could miss a significant chance to make an impact and get carries.Rotoworld:
NFL Network's Ian Rapoport reports the Broncos plan to use a running back by committee on a "drive-by-drive" basis.
As opposed to a "play-by-play" basis, the "drive-by-drive" formula will allow Ronnie Hillman, Montee Ball, and Knowshon Moreno to "stay in" and "go fast" in the Broncos' hurry-up attack. Hillman is expected to get the "start" on Thursday, but it's anyone's guess who will end up leading the backfield in touches against the Ravens. Our money's on Ball. As our own Evan Silva noted in his "Matchups" column, it's best to take a wait-and-see approach for the opener.
Related: Knowshon Moreno, Montee Ball
Source: Ian Rapoport on Twitter
Fox is often faithful to Vets but remember Moreno has seemingly been in the doghouse much of his time with FoxWe are talking Fox and protecting Manning. Moreno should be the start until the young backs can mature and protect. If that even happnes. Can't see it any other way.
reminiscent of Dwill/JStewRotoworld:
NFL Network's Ian Rapoport reports the Broncos plan to use a running back by committee on a "drive-by-drive" basis.
As opposed to a "play-by-play" basis, the "drive-by-drive" formula will allow Ronnie Hillman, Montee Ball, and Knowshon Moreno to "stay in" and "go fast" in the Broncos' hurry-up attack. Hillman is expected to get the "start" on Thursday, but it's anyone's guess who will end up leading the backfield in touches against the Ravens. Our money's on Ball. As our own Evan Silva noted in his "Matchups" column, it's best to take a wait-and-see approach for the opener.
Related: Knowshon Moreno, Montee Ball
Source: Ian Rapoport on Twitter
I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
Since entering the league, Knowshon Moreno has 20 carries that (a) came inside the 5 yard line and (b) came with 2 or fewer yards to go for a first down. On those 20 carries, he has scored 9 TDs, good for 45%.I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
Didn't the original Mendoza weigh in the 180's? Can't bat .180? Yeesh that's bad. I hope he's better than that.I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
I thought it was .220Raiderfan32904 said:Didn't the original Mendoza weigh in the 180's? Can't bat .180? Yeesh that's bad. I hope he's better than that.Adam Harstad said:I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
And this is the NFL, where GM's are always looking to upgrade personnel regardless of who you are. Denver will upgrade next year and look to do the same in 2015. That's part of this business.
Good analysis. I don't think anybody is saying Moreno is their long term back. He's not electric by any means. Nobody builds a RB stable behind a Knowhson Moreno. But the truth of the matter is that a Mendoza Line of NFL RB's can do very well in an offense like this. In a redraft situation, not worrying about next year, at a time when they have to win now with Manning's window, Moreno may win out. And I don't think they really want to go by committee. Ruins there flow. We saw McGahee, we saw Moreno - they want a prime back.Adam Harstad said:Since entering the league, Knowshon Moreno has 20 carries that (a) came inside the 5 yard line and (b) came with 2 or fewer yards to go for a first down. On those 20 carries, he has scored 9 TDs, good for 45%.SaintsInDome2006 said:I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.LOCO said:i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
For comparison, over that same span, all other Broncos RBs combined have 23 carries and 10 TDs, good for a nearly-identical success rate (43%). In this case, "all other RBs" includes McGahee (9 carries), Jacob Hester (2), Peyton Hillis (3), Correll Buckhalter (1), Lance Ball (4), LaMont Jordan (1), and Laurence Maroney (3). In other words, there's an awful lot of roster trash in those numbers.
I think this is Knowshon Moreno's career in a nutshell. He'll perform the same as any other generic RB would, no better and no worse. Since he entered the league, Broncos RBs as a whole (including Moreno) average 4.18 ypc, while Moreno alone averages 4.02 ypc. All Broncos RBs combined (including Moreno) get a first down on 21.6% of their carries, while Moreno alone gets one on 20.4%. He's the platonic ideal of replacement level. He's basically Isaac Redman, or Chester Taylor, or any number of other replacement-level RBs who have managed to put up some solid production when given the opportunity, but who weren't nearly good enough to keep the opportunity once they had it. Elway and Fox keep trying to replace him, because that's what you do to replacement-level players- you try to get an upgrade. In Willis McGahee, they succeeded. In Ronnie Hillman, they failed (at least during his rookie year). Will 2nd-year Hillman or 1st-year Ball be an upgrade over Knowshon Moreno? Maybe, maybe not. If they aren't, though, and if Knowshon Moreno winds up winning the starting job, I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
The funny part is that they belive that Hillman can/has improved, but that Moreno can't?Good analysis. I don't think anybody is saying Moreno is their long term back. He's not electric by any means. Nobody builds a RB stable behind a Knowhson Moreno. But the truth of the matter is that a Mendoza Line of NFL RB's can do very well in an offense like this. In a redraft situation, not worrying about next year, at a time when they have to win now with Manning's window, Moreno may win out. And I don't think they really want to go by committee. Ruins there flow. We saw McGahee, we saw Moreno - they want a prime back.Adam Harstad said:Since entering the league, Knowshon Moreno has 20 carries that (a) came inside the 5 yard line and (b) came with 2 or fewer yards to go for a first down. On those 20 carries, he has scored 9 TDs, good for 45%.SaintsInDome2006 said:I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.LOCO said:i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
For comparison, over that same span, all other Broncos RBs combined have 23 carries and 10 TDs, good for a nearly-identical success rate (43%). In this case, "all other RBs" includes McGahee (9 carries), Jacob Hester (2), Peyton Hillis (3), Correll Buckhalter (1), Lance Ball (4), LaMont Jordan (1), and Laurence Maroney (3). In other words, there's an awful lot of roster trash in those numbers.
I think this is Knowshon Moreno's career in a nutshell. He'll perform the same as any other generic RB would, no better and no worse. Since he entered the league, Broncos RBs as a whole (including Moreno) average 4.18 ypc, while Moreno alone averages 4.02 ypc. All Broncos RBs combined (including Moreno) get a first down on 21.6% of their carries, while Moreno alone gets one on 20.4%. He's the platonic ideal of replacement level. He's basically Isaac Redman, or Chester Taylor, or any number of other replacement-level RBs who have managed to put up some solid production when given the opportunity, but who weren't nearly good enough to keep the opportunity once they had it. Elway and Fox keep trying to replace him, because that's what you do to replacement-level players- you try to get an upgrade. In Willis McGahee, they succeeded. In Ronnie Hillman, they failed (at least during his rookie year). Will 2nd-year Hillman or 1st-year Ball be an upgrade over Knowshon Moreno? Maybe, maybe not. If they aren't, though, and if Knowshon Moreno winds up winning the starting job, I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
It's the state of the RB market, not a knock on any of these guys. Every team in the league should look to exploit rookie RB contracts by drafting a few backs late and let them form a committee. If one breaks out then use him for 300+ carries every year. When it's contract time hopefully you already have a Ben Tate/ B Pierce waiting when your star RB contract is up. It's a copy cat league. Untl AP or CJ2k win a few playoff games that's what smart teams are doing right now since there are so many capable RBs in the league. It's obvious Elway isn't reinventing the wheel here. This looks like a poor mans versions of the Saints backfield right now. Ball might be great as a bellcow but underwhelm in a committee like Ingram, Knowshon may be the most efficient all-around like Thomas and still put in a top 30-35 season in a prolific offense while no one cares, and Hillman can be Sproles without being used as much in the passing game. Moreno has the most upside for his versatility and Hillman the most downside for his inabilities. As long as I know some touches are there I don't think playing Moreno/Ball in a pinch is that bad week 1.Good analysis. I don't think anybody is saying Moreno is their long term back. He's not electric by any means. Nobody builds a RB stable behind a Knowhson Moreno. But the truth of the matter is that a Mendoza Line of NFL RB's can do very well in an offense like this. In a redraft situation, not worrying about next year, at a time when they have to win now with Manning's window, Moreno may win out. And I don't think they really want to go by committee. Ruins there flow. We saw McGahee, we saw Moreno - they want a prime back.Adam Harstad said:Since entering the league, Knowshon Moreno has 20 carries that (a) came inside the 5 yard line and (b) came with 2 or fewer yards to go for a first down. On those 20 carries, he has scored 9 TDs, good for 45%.SaintsInDome2006 said:I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.LOCO said:i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
For comparison, over that same span, all other Broncos RBs combined have 23 carries and 10 TDs, good for a nearly-identical success rate (43%). In this case, "all other RBs" includes McGahee (9 carries), Jacob Hester (2), Peyton Hillis (3), Correll Buckhalter (1), Lance Ball (4), LaMont Jordan (1), and Laurence Maroney (3). In other words, there's an awful lot of roster trash in those numbers.
I think this is Knowshon Moreno's career in a nutshell. He'll perform the same as any other generic RB would, no better and no worse. Since he entered the league, Broncos RBs as a whole (including Moreno) average 4.18 ypc, while Moreno alone averages 4.02 ypc. All Broncos RBs combined (including Moreno) get a first down on 21.6% of their carries, while Moreno alone gets one on 20.4%. He's the platonic ideal of replacement level. He's basically Isaac Redman, or Chester Taylor, or any number of other replacement-level RBs who have managed to put up some solid production when given the opportunity, but who weren't nearly good enough to keep the opportunity once they had it. Elway and Fox keep trying to replace him, because that's what you do to replacement-level players- you try to get an upgrade. In Willis McGahee, they succeeded. In Ronnie Hillman, they failed (at least during his rookie year). Will 2nd-year Hillman or 1st-year Ball be an upgrade over Knowshon Moreno? Maybe, maybe not. If they aren't, though, and if Knowshon Moreno winds up winning the starting job, I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
RBBC just like it was a week ago imoLooks like I should tear up that Moreno golden lottery ticket mentioned in another thread. Hillman is (pretty much) the man.
Obviously anyone is capable of improving. John Riggins never topped 250 carries until he was 30, and never topped 300 until he was 34. Nothing is impossible.The funny part is that they belive that Hillman can/has improved, but that Moreno can't?Good analysis. I don't think anybody is saying Moreno is their long term back. He's not electric by any means. Nobody builds a RB stable behind a Knowhson Moreno. But the truth of the matter is that a Mendoza Line of NFL RB's can do very well in an offense like this. In a redraft situation, not worrying about next year, at a time when they have to win now with Manning's window, Moreno may win out. And I don't think they really want to go by committee. Ruins there flow. We saw McGahee, we saw Moreno - they want a prime back.Adam Harstad said:Since entering the league, Knowshon Moreno has 20 carries that (a) came inside the 5 yard line and (b) came with 2 or fewer yards to go for a first down. On those 20 carries, he has scored 9 TDs, good for 45%.SaintsInDome2006 said:I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.LOCO said:i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
For comparison, over that same span, all other Broncos RBs combined have 23 carries and 10 TDs, good for a nearly-identical success rate (43%). In this case, "all other RBs" includes McGahee (9 carries), Jacob Hester (2), Peyton Hillis (3), Correll Buckhalter (1), Lance Ball (4), LaMont Jordan (1), and Laurence Maroney (3). In other words, there's an awful lot of roster trash in those numbers.
I think this is Knowshon Moreno's career in a nutshell. He'll perform the same as any other generic RB would, no better and no worse. Since he entered the league, Broncos RBs as a whole (including Moreno) average 4.18 ypc, while Moreno alone averages 4.02 ypc. All Broncos RBs combined (including Moreno) get a first down on 21.6% of their carries, while Moreno alone gets one on 20.4%. He's the platonic ideal of replacement level. He's basically Isaac Redman, or Chester Taylor, or any number of other replacement-level RBs who have managed to put up some solid production when given the opportunity, but who weren't nearly good enough to keep the opportunity once they had it. Elway and Fox keep trying to replace him, because that's what you do to replacement-level players- you try to get an upgrade. In Willis McGahee, they succeeded. In Ronnie Hillman, they failed (at least during his rookie year). Will 2nd-year Hillman or 1st-year Ball be an upgrade over Knowshon Moreno? Maybe, maybe not. If they aren't, though, and if Knowshon Moreno winds up winning the starting job, I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
I think this will play out over an extended time, barring injury. If one or more of three suck or cause sacks or fumble, Fox will have to adjust. The fans, the OC and Manning will have some input into this.
W1 Hillman will get the call, and we'll have to see how he does and go from there.
Good stuff here...and what is really frustrating with him is that he's had every opportunity to increase those % and #'s - and yet he takes himself off the field. He can't last for a drive much less a season - that is the #1 reason why those other guys get the chance. My picture of Moreno is making a good run and looking at the bench and coming off the field.Adam Harstad said:Since entering the league, Knowshon Moreno has 20 carries that (a) came inside the 5 yard line and (b) came with 2 or fewer yards to go for a first down. On those 20 carries, he has scored 9 TDs, good for 45%.SaintsInDome2006 said:I enjoy watching Moreno play. It seems like since after his rookie year, Moreno has just come in and done well every time. Catches the ball well, blocks well, good at the goal line, and the Broncos (Elway) just keeps trying to find a replacement.LOCO said:i think Moreno is worth a flyer. other than that, I think i am passing.
For comparison, over that same span, all other Broncos RBs combined have 23 carries and 10 TDs, good for a nearly-identical success rate (43%). In this case, "all other RBs" includes McGahee (9 carries), Jacob Hester (2), Peyton Hillis (3), Correll Buckhalter (1), Lance Ball (4), LaMont Jordan (1), and Laurence Maroney (3). In other words, there's an awful lot of roster trash in those numbers.
I think this is Knowshon Moreno's career in a nutshell. He'll perform the same as any other generic RB would, no better and no worse. Since he entered the league, Broncos RBs as a whole (including Moreno) average 4.18 ypc, while Moreno alone averages 4.02 ypc. All Broncos RBs combined (including Moreno) get a first down on 21.6% of their carries, while Moreno alone gets one on 20.4%. He's the platonic ideal of replacement level. He's basically Isaac Redman, or Chester Taylor, or any number of other replacement-level RBs who have managed to put up some solid production when given the opportunity, but who weren't nearly good enough to keep the opportunity once they had it. Elway and Fox keep trying to replace him, because that's what you do to replacement-level players- you try to get an upgrade. In Willis McGahee, they succeeded. In Ronnie Hillman, they failed (at least during his rookie year). Will 2nd-year Hillman or 1st-year Ball be an upgrade over Knowshon Moreno? Maybe, maybe not. If they aren't, though, and if Knowshon Moreno winds up winning the starting job, I guarantee you one thing- Denver's going to spend next offseason trying to upgrade from Knowshon Moreno, too. He's the Mendoza Line of NFL RBs.
Got sucked in too...not in dynasty.^^^^^^^Yep. Age relative to league matters for prospects, in all sports. As a baseball scout would perhaps say, there's still projectability when it comes to Hillman. We pretty much know what Moreno is.