can only keep 1 ...... (1 Viewer)

[leave a whisper]

Evans

Godwin

Kittle

Kupp

I can only keep 1 ..... standard scoring 3WR/1TE no flex  

2 keepers (Barkley my other) - redraft in 4 years

 

[jwsbowler]

for me it comes down to Kittle or Godwin.  And my initial reaction is Godwin.  I could probably be talked into taking Kittle, but I do like the age difference.  What position are you in when the draft starts in round 3 (assuming two keepers being round 1 and 2).

 

[Cjw_55106]

Kittle for me. 

 

[Gally]

kittle is the choice for me.  Position scarcity and now you can set it and forget it.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

What is scoring system?  PPR ..TE Premium?

I would lean Kittle over Godwin.  Distant 3rd is Evans and Kupp shouldn't be considered.

 

[leave a whisper]

to answer a few questions:

standard scoring (non-PPR, no TE premium)

draft order will be selected at random (for a snake) AFTER 2 keepers are turned in August 2nd

I love Kittle ..... if it was start 2 WR it would be him hands down - but it's start 3WR (no flex)

Note: Evans has always been "one of my guys", so I have an unhealthy attachment to him - and Godwin was my Boner pick last year I jumped on early

 

[fightingillini]

It's close, but I would choose Kittle as well.  You can find tons of WRs that can get you 900-1000 yds and 7 or so TDs in the draft.

I wouldn't fault you for taking Godwin. 

 

[PantherThunder]

Do you have to keep 2?  I would almost keep one and see who is available in the second. Probably not a huge downgrade, lots of upside. 

 

[leave a whisper]

YES - I have to keep 2

last season was a start-up 5 year keeper league (standard scoring/ no flex/ 3WR/ no TE premium but required to start 1)

keep 2 players every year for 5 years, then redraft again

how I got these players:

Barkley rd1

Evans rd2

Kittle rd3

Godwin rd4

Kupp - trade 2 days before season started (gave M.Andrews & C.Kirk)

...... AFTER 2 keeps are turned in league will generate a random snake draft ..... I will have control of the kept players for another 3 years (if I choose)

 

[beerbuff]

kittle

 

[TBBuccs6988]

It obviously kills me to against the Buccaneers, but I would keep Kittle for sure for the reasons already stated.   It's just strategy as far as positional scarcity. 

Good Luck!!

 

[PantherThunder]

If you have to keep two. Then Kittle. Going to be a top guys for a few years. Godwin Evans new qb. Maybe a rookie in year 3