Carr, Watson or Purdy for the finals? (1 Viewer)

[fstep]

So i'm in the finals and totally screwed at QB (starter is out). I'm left with Watson (who is severely underperforming), Carr (who is playing the best defense in the league), and Purdy (who is trending up, playing a below avg defense, but they just aren't letting him throw and they'll likely get off to a big lead and run the whole game). Nothing else on the wire. What's the best option here?

 

[Rubi]

I throw Watson out for sure. Always been a fan of Carr but tough matchup this week,garbage points if they get behind? That leaves Purdy. He's been consistent,all it takes is a couple run after catch td's and he puts up a nice number. Purdy for me.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

I am going with Purdy who has been super consistent. Don't trust Carr and turned down an offer for Adams this week (dynasty) cause of Carr. Watson is by far the 3rd choice.

See mine please https://forums.footballguys.com/threads/dynasty-trade-aj-brown-pollard-for-arsb-barkley.807446/

 

[Gally]

Purdy really is the easiest choice. I guess if I am a huge underdog and need everything to go right I may throw a Hail Mary to Carr as he will have to throw the whole game

 

[arichards728]

I would go Purdy. 3-0 as a starter against quality teams.

Please help:

Championship Game(s) - Lineup Help - WHIR

All Full PPR Leagues: Final #1 1. Ken Walker vs NYJ or Jerrick McKinnon vs DEN? 2. Darren Waller vs SF or Cole Kmet vs DET (Knox also available on Waivers) Final #2 1. Justin Fields vs DET or Joe Burrow vs BUF? 2. Ken Walker vs NYJ or Mike Williams vs LAR in Flex spot? Final #3 1. Tyler...

forums.footballguys.com

 

[Gally]

I would go Purdy. 3-0 as a starter against quality teams.

Being 3-0 on it's own is irrelevant for fantasy purposes. I will agree that Purdy is the safe choice but I see a game where the ground game does all the heavy lifting and he is disappointing in fantasy. I also think that there is a world where the Raiders are down the entire time and Carr throws 50 times and Adams has a big game giving Carr the upside play (but a lot more risk of having a bad game).