Just about every decision AJ has made has turned out to be fantastic. Look at the difference between the talent on the roster three years ago and the talent on the roster today. Everything AJ has done has been controversial, from the moment he took over and immeidately got rid of David Boston and Marcellus Wiley, to bringing in Steve Foley, Randall Godfrey, and Mike Goff, to trading Eli Manning for P.Rivers, Nate Kaeding, Roman Oben, and Shawne Merriman . . . and so on. But all of those decisions turned out great. Letting Brees go is also controversial, but it was the right move. (He missed on the Sammy Davis pick, but no team gets every pick right. And bringing Gates in more than makes up for it.)
I think AJ is an absolutely fantastic GM.
Marty is a good coach, but he's Alex Spanos's guy, and Alex isn't running the show anymore. (Dean Spanos is.)
AJ's job is safe barring a complete meltdown. But Marty appears to be on the hot seat.