What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Choosing a WR2 (1 Viewer)

Who would you draft in round 4?

  • Terrell Owens

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Chad Ochocinco

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Braylon Edwards

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

Callas Disregard

Footballguy
I'm running mocks using Draft Dominator and my league specs, and after grabbing a Steve Smith/Reggie Wayne type as my WR1, I find that in round 4 when I'm ready to take my WR2 that I'm faced with a top tier including TO, Ocho Cinco, and Braylon Edwards. I've got the three of them grouped pretty closely together. Who would you draft of those 3?

 
TO seems to be going quite a bit ahead of them; usually just after Bowe in the 3rd. I think Cinco is the best value of that group.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you feel real confident in your first 3 picks, I would go Edwards. I would love to see how many guys in the NFL over the 30 that put up 16 TDs in one year and never crossed the 1000 yd, 10 TD plateau again (and I am not talking over the hill guys that had a last gasp, but guys in their prime).

I just don;t buy this "stone hands" stuff...this isn't "50/50' Rod gardner we are talking about...he is more TO than Gardner and if you want to go for the juggular after your first 3 picks (if you really feel confident), I would say to take the chance on Edwards. While Cleveland may not have the best QB1, whoever loses the race will be one of the best QB2s in the league.

 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
I'm definitely not comfortable with Gonzo Jr as my WR2. I don't think the Colts offense is what they once were, and Gonzo Jr is certainly no Marvin Harrison.
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
I'm definitely not comfortable with Gonzo Jr as my WR2. I don't think the Colts offense is what they once were, and Gonzo Jr is certainly no Marvin Harrison.
well dont expect much better out of TO
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
I love playing in leagues were guys think in terms of "better value". Because, while he skips over players, with the idea of grabbing someone else in a later round, that someone else gets taken by another. So he ends up in that later round saying to himself, 'I can get this player, or grab that player later... because he'd have better value then."'Better value' owners tend to have a team full of second-class talent... since they won't "overpay" for the scoring studs.Von
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
don't forget, the Reggie Wayne type he mentioned just might be Reggie Wayne. I'm not taking two WRs from the same team as my 1/2. Imagine if Peyton were injured.
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
I love playing in leagues were guys think in terms of "better value". Because, while he skips over players, with the idea of grabbing someone else in a later round, that someone else gets taken by another. So he ends up in that later round saying to himself, 'I can get this player, or grab that player later... because he'd have better value then."'Better value' owners tend to have a team full of second-class talent... since they won't "overpay" for the scoring studs.Von
:headbang: The whole concept of tiers (which most good drafters use) is designed to maximize value. You can disagree with the idea that Gonzo is in the same tier as TO (I think it's a stretch myself) but I'd much rather my opponents go in with a linear rankings list than guys who are thinking about value.
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
TO is on the bills now... fyi. http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/wr check gonzo's catch rate then come back and tell me he has stone hands

 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
I'm definitely not comfortable with Gonzo Jr as my WR2. I don't think the Colts offense is what they once were, and Gonzo Jr is certainly no Marvin Harrison.
colts offense had a rash of OL injuries and peyton had knee surgeries in the off season and Marvin wilted. once peyton and the OL started rolling the offense wsa just fine. fast forward to now peyton healthy/OL healthy and youngsters season'd/add in a dynamic RB to compliment-replace addai'. saying that Gonzo is a extremely talented 3RD YEAR WR who is now starting and who PEYTON MANNING throwing him the ball. and if your needing your #2WR u don't need Gonzo to be Marvin.while still pretty good TO is clearly in decline(and that decline has been in a very good offense) and going to a offense with the worst QB(no offense to Trent) he's ever had throwing him the ball. everyone that keeps banging the TO "always gets over 1000yards and 10TD's" drum..........how did u feel when u had marvin 2years ago/joe horn a few years ago. TO is totally dependent on his physical tools which will make his demise(when it happens) very ugly.take Gonzo and fill another need in the 4th
 
Last edited by a moderator:
ninerfanatic492000 said:
I'm definitely not comfortable with Gonzo Jr as my WR2. I don't think the Colts offense is what they once were, and Gonzo Jr is certainly no Marvin Harrison.
colts offense had a rash of OL injuries and peyton had knee surgeries in the off season and Marvin wilted. once peyton and the OL started rolling the offense wsa just fine. fast forward to now peyton healthy/OL healthy and youngsters season'd/add in a dynamic RB to compliment-replace addai'. saying that Gonzo is a extremely talented 3RD YEAR WR who is now starting and who PEYTON MANNING throwing him the ball. and if your needing your #2WR u don't need Gonzo to be Marvin.while still pretty good TO is clearly in decline(and that decline has been in a very good offense) and going to a offense with the worst QB(no offense to Trent) he's ever had throwing him the ball. everyone that keeps banging the TO "always gets over 1000yards and 10TD's" drum..........how did u feel when u had marvin 2years ago/joe horn a few years ago. TO is totally dependent on his physical tools which will make his demise(when it happens) very ugly.take Gonzo and fill another need in the 4th
TO is a risk, but Gonzo is the 3rd receiving option in Indy. As for Edwards being TO's worst QB ever, we'll see. TO's 2006 QB was completely unknown before TO got to town. Garcia's been alright but not great. Edwards completion % last year is better than Romo's, McNabb's or Garcia's ever was and he basically had one good receiver. His any/a is low, but we'll see what happens with TO. In any event, the question is what do you want with your WR2, my answer is it depends on my WR1.If I have a STUD WR like Andre, Fitz, Calvin or Moss, I'll take a little more risk with my WR2. A guy like TO is perfect. If my WR1 is good, say Colston level, I want a WR2 I can count on to start for me. Injuries play a role here too, but not as much as I can't predict them.
 
nlgb1 said:
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
TO is on the bills now... fyi. http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/wr check gonzo's catch rate then come back and tell me he has stone hands
LOL let me quote ur website:DYAR and DVOA include all passes intended for the receiver, both complete and incomplete. Catch Rate represents the percentage of passes to this receiver completed. This is a reference to incomplete passes, not dropped passes: dropped passes are not specified in publicly available play-by-play, and unfortunately we cannot yet correct for this.

So those numbers have little to do with drops. NIce try tho. lol :hophead:

 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
I agree that if you could get TO in the 4th, I would take that. .but this is a bit ironic calling out Gonzalez with a stone hands quote while talking up TO who probably drops more passes than any WR out there...
 
nlgb1 said:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
ant gonzalez in the 5th instead of TO in the 4th? omg What r u smoking??? lol can i join ur league!
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
I agree that if you could get TO in the 4th, I would take that. .but this is a bit ironic calling out Gonzalez with a stone hands quote while talking up TO who probably drops more passes than any WR out there...
last year A.Gonzalez caught 71% of passes thrown to him TO caught 47%I still like TO in the in the 4th more than GonzoII in the 5th

 
Last edited by a moderator:
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.

if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
I agree that if you could get TO in the 4th, I would take that. .but this is a bit ironic calling out Gonzalez with a stone hands quote while talking up TO who probably drops more passes than any WR out there...
last year A.Gonzalez caught 71% of passes thrown to him TO caught 47%

I still like TO in the in the 4th more than GonzoII in the 5th
This isn't a "hands" statistic. If TO runs deeper routes and has a less accurate QB than Gonzo his percentage is going to be lower regardless of ability.
 
...yes gonzo in 5th over TO in 4th easy. TO barely eclipsed 1000 yds and 10 tds with romo throwing him the ball. gonzo was number 3 last year and put up 57/664/4. a TO decrease in production and gonzo increase in production puts them at a very similar spot, if not identical. so yes, wait a round and grab gonzo. pick up higher tier RB in the 4th instead.

if ur gonna criticize a post, at least provide some reasoning... not just some blind shot in the dark
TO puts up 1000+ yards every year. Gonzo put up 664 yards last year and has stone hands. Is that enough for ya lol?
I agree that if you could get TO in the 4th, I would take that. .but this is a bit ironic calling out Gonzalez with a stone hands quote while talking up TO who probably drops more passes than any WR out there...
last year A.Gonzalez caught 71% of passes thrown to him TO caught 47%

I still like TO in the in the 4th more than GonzoII in the 5th
This isn't a "hands" statistic. If TO runs deeper routes and has a less accurate QB than Gonzo his percentage is going to be lower regardless of ability.
Not sure...but TO might have seen a few more double teams too.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
draft anthony gonzalez in the 5th instead. much better value
I love playing in leagues were guys think in terms of "better value". Because, while he skips over players, with the idea of grabbing someone else in a later round, that someone else gets taken by another. So he ends up in that later round saying to himself, 'I can get this player, or grab that player later... because he'd have better value then."'Better value' owners tend to have a team full of second-class talent... since they won't "overpay" for the scoring studs.Von
I AGREE with Von 100% I see it happen all the time and it even happened to me last year when I thought for sure my guy would be there next round.I would grab TO without a doubt before any of those guys mentioned. It's his first year in BUF, he has a one year contract so he will be on his best behavior. I feel BUF will have some weapons this year.If PPR you better come right back for WR in hopes of Braylon/Chad 85/ Royal/Bryant/V Jax/Holmes or A Gonz. Mock it up and see as depending on value of TE dropping I usually start looking for my te anywhere from rounds 4-7. Just my 2 cents
 
This isn't a "hands" statistic. If TO runs deeper routes and has a less accurate QB than Gonzo his percentage is going to be lower regardless of ability.
You know what *IS* a "hands" statistic? Dropped passes. How many times has Anthony Gonzalez led the league in dropped passes? I can't think of any. I can, however, think of at least THREE SEASONS where Terrell Owens has led the league in dropped passes. In other words- you were saying?Besides, I don't care if he's running nothing but 8-yard curls- no WR catches 70+% of his targets if he has bad hands. Simply impossible.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top