Consensus Top 350 Albums of All-Time: 1. The Dark Side of the Moon – Pink Floyd (166 Viewers)

[Dr. Octopus]

I sort of feel out of my depth here since you guys know more about and have listened to more music and while I do like songs like Good Riddance or Brainstew I have always felt like Green Day wasn't in the same tier as a Zepplin or Clapton etc. But I also didn't run in "punk" circles and I think thir early stuff was considered punk.

They were a whole era apart - Zeppelin and Green Day - so they aren’t compared much.

We will see more Zeppelin albums than Green Day albums, which goes to your “tier” comments. As you know, we’re an older crowd here. If this was a poll of 30 somethings perhaps Green Day would be the more “popular” act.

 

[Ilov80s]

I sort of feel out of my depth here since you guys know more about and have listened to more music and while I do like songs like Good Riddance or Brainstew I have always felt like Green Day wasn't in the same tier as a Zepplin or Clapton etc. But I also didn't run in "punk" circles and I think thir early stuff was considered punk.

Throw on Dookie and see what you think. I would love to hear your thoughts fr fr.

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

I also find it surprising that a Green Day album is top 50. It was probably already noted that RS votes it #375 album of all time so it jumped 325 spots in our countdown. Fascinating.

I hope I wasn't the only one that didn't read any of these lists before making my own.

I read it but it clearly didn't influence my rankings.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Speaking of high pitched nasally voices and silly lyrics, I see we had some Rush drafted today.

Bah, most of the acts featured today would give their left nut to write lyrics as good as the ones Peart wrote at his peak.

 

[Ilov80s]

I sort of feel out of my depth here since you guys know more about and have listened to more music and while I do like songs like Good Riddance or Brainstew I have always felt like Green Day wasn't in the same tier as a Zepplin or Clapton etc. But I also didn't run in "punk" circles and I think thir early stuff was considered punk.

They were a whole era apart - Zeppelin and Green Day - so they aren’t compared much.

We will see more Zeppelin albums than Green Day albums, which goes to your “tier” comments. As you know, we’re an older crowd here. If this was a poll of 30 somethings perhaps Green Day would be the more “popular” act.

Objectively, LZ has more great albums. Placement of the great albums is up for debate but LZ has more .

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

I sort of feel out of my depth here since you guys know more about and have listened to more music and while I do like songs like Good Riddance or Brainstew I have always felt like Green Day wasn't in the same tier as a Zepplin or Clapton etc. But I also didn't run in "punk" circles and I think thir early stuff was considered punk.

Throw on Dookie and see what you think. I would love to hear your thoughts fr fr.

just 4 you i will

 

[Dr. Octopus]

This is a good example of an album I know is great, and I even own it on CD (tucked away, with the rest of my CDs now), but one I rarely listen to anymore. I am just rarely in the mood for jazz, but on the rare occasions I am, this or Coltrane always hit the spot.

I said something similar to this earlier and had those you mentioned and other jazz CDs, but if I’m being honest while I did love them I just didn’t listen to them as much.

I did listen to a lot of different Miles Davis albums though.

 

[Ilov80s]

Now that I listen closer with a nitpicking critical ear, both Ad Rock and Mike D have a bit of a higher pictched delivery, correct? It's MCA that has a bit of a deeper voice?

You're totally right but Ad Rock is, like, so over-the-top that he's over the moon

You are right that it's Ad Rock that is the more frequent offender, but where I was going is I think because it's 2 in that range after a long bout of listening it wears on me slightly. Still LOVE many of the songs, but in the end I think they are more of a playlist group for me vs an album group.

That said, some of my favorite new to me songs were the few off Hot Sauce that were featured in the MAD31 countdown. I've watched the video for Make Some Noise so many times.

Oh, I get your point now. Yeah, they've got two nasally guys. I have trouble with it also—there are times that I'm just about to turn it off and I've just turned it on— but their production and music is so damn good. And Ad Rock is a very, very good emcee. Mike Diamond and MCA aren't really. Ad does some massively heavy lifting and always did. Plus, I was reading and watching something about them and somebody noted how absolutely awesome their timing and pacing of their sing/rapping was on the first album. And "Rhymin' & Stealin'" is a song that you actually have to be incredibly talented to carry that tune and they do somehow. MCA fits that track. He fits that album. He did not fit once they left the '80s but he was their spiritual leader and friend so what are they gonna do? It's not even a question what to do. He's just not a great emcee by that point.

Has there ever been a hip hop experiment where other rappers laid down vocals over that Paul's Boutique production?

 

[MAC_32]

Call me the anti-music nerd's music nerd, but I have never understood, and never will understand, the need to classify music. Green Day is Green Day. Good sounds evolve over time. And I think most of there's are awesome and never tire listening to them.

 

[Ghost Rider]

43. Innervisions – Stevie Wonder (419 points)

@Uruk-Hai #1
@krista4 #1
@Eephus #6
@Atomic Punk #8
@landrys hat #14
@Pip's Invitation #14
@Yo Mama #40
@timschochet #65

Innervisions is the sixteenth studio album by American singer, songwriter, and musician Stevie Wonder, released on August 3, 1973, by Tamla, a subsidiary of Motown Records. A landmark recording of Wonder's "classic period", the album has been regarded as completing his transition from the "Little Stevie Wonder" known for romantic ballads into a more musically mature, conscious, and grown-up artist. On the album, Wonder continued to experiment with the revolutionary T.O.N.T.O. (The Original New Timbral Orchestra) synthesizer system developed by Malcolm Cecil and Robert Margouleff, and Innervisions became hugely influential on the future sound of commercial soul and black music.

Excellent record. He's Misstra Know It All is so damn good.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Call me the anti-music nerd's music nerd, but I have never understood, and never will understand, the need to classify music. Green Day is Green Day. Good sounds evolve over time. And I think most of there's are awesome and never tire listening to them.

Agreed. I am guilty of it at times, but I feel like many get too hung up on genres and whatnot. If it's good, who cares what genre it is?

 

[rockaction]

I sort of feel out of my depth here since you guys know more about and have listened to more music and while I do like songs like Good Riddance or Brainstew I have always felt like Green Day wasn't in the same tier as a Zepplin or Clapton etc. But I also didn't run in "punk" circles and I think thir early stuff was considered punk.

In terms of being huge? No, they were not as big as Led Zeppelin were at their peak. Green Day dwarfs them in terms of listeners now. It's because of the generations and time, man. I mean, you couldn't get away from Zeppelin growing up in the place and time that I did. Zeppelin wasn't just in another tier, they were in another stratosphere.

If you're talking about talent, I have no authority to speak on that, nor a real understanding of it. I can tell you that most critics of the '70s, '80s, '90s, and '00s would have probably told you that Zeppelin was either more talented or that those critics liked Zeppelin better or reasonably better. Green Day have never been critical darlings.

Clapton I don't know. I think Green Day is bigger now than he could have dreamed of being. That's just my opinion and he was definitely before my time.

 

[KarmaPolice]

I sort of feel out of my depth here since you guys know more about and have listened to more music and while I do like songs like Good Riddance or Brainstew I have always felt like Green Day wasn't in the same tier as a Zepplin or Clapton etc. But I also didn't run in "punk" circles and I think thir early stuff was considered punk.

You have been pushing me to watch movies I haven't seen before instead of watching Tucker and Dale for the 100th time - have you tried any of the albums that have been on the countdown that you haven't heard before?

Also, some here have 20-25 years on you, and that is a big head start for listening to a bunch of music. I really didn't start branching out and listening to a ton of different stuff until I started getting sucked into all these music threads, drafts, and playlist adventures here. I will be eternally grateful for this place because of that and getting me to expand my horizons a lot more.

 

[rockaction]

Call me the anti-music nerd's music nerd, but I have never understood, and never will understand, the need to classify music. Green Day is Green Day. Good sounds evolve over time. And I think most of there's are awesome and never tire listening to them.

Those of us that like to organize our record bins need things in boxes. I kid.

It’s a shorthand and a tool for identification and aesthetic comparison— and deeper understanding. It doesn’t have to be anything more than communication and a way of processing information.

One can hate genres as a concept because people use them to limit, pigeonhole, judge, dilute, and exclude, but others don’t do that. They use them for the very human need of taxonomy and ordering by essence and likeness/difference. It’s important because their existence and our need to categorize things actually sharpens our understanding of music because we must think about definitions and truly understand the essence of what makes the categories —with those offending labels—different. For example, how is pop different from no wave and why are they different? What are their essences, their qualities, and to what ends do they exist? Why do they exist, even, and sometimes where did they come from? There are nearly countless other potential labels. But that’s a lot of information in a word or two (if only I had a drop down taxonomy label for my posts!).

To wit, when Eephus says that Green Day are punk and that they’re more within the Buzzcocks vein of of punk rock and that their lineage is more on the Buzzcocks side than the Sex Pistols side of the descendant tree, I know what he might be trying to convey—faster, melodic, guitar-heavy, higher-pitched singing with lyrics about fumbling lust and the risqué; sometimes regarding the public airing of the heretofore private, the sexually awkward, and the lovelorn feelings that often remain unexpressed. So if I hadn't heard Green Day, now I have a starting point or a narrowed down idea of what their music might sound like. Punk takes on a sociopolitical aspect also, which makes it tricky, but that’s what genres and their encoded understanding does in their ideal sense.

The heuristics of the labels do important communicative and classification sorting work.

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

You have been pushing me to watch movies I haven't seen before instead of watching Tucker and Dale for the 100th time - have you tried any of the albums that have been on the countdown that you haven't heard before?

I have? I mean you should. lol Before the countdown began I started listening to some of the recomended songs, I even made a post about them/my reactions to but I've gotten behind. I just promised 80's I'd listen to Dookie though.

 

[kupcho1]

I also find it surprising that a Green Day album is top 50. It was probably already noted that RS votes it #375 album of all time so it jumped 325 spots in our countdown. Fascinating.

I hope I wasn't the only one that didn't read any of these lists before making my own.

You're not alone on that

 

[kupcho1]

Clapton I don't know. I think Green Day is bigger now than he could have dreamed of being. That's just my opinion and he was definitely before my time.

Type "Clapton is" into Google and see what the autocomplete says.

 

[rockaction]

Clapton I don't know. I think Green Day is bigger now than he could have dreamed of being. That's just my opinion and he was definitely before my time.

How big was he? You have to give me leeway here. He was before my time and Thumper Rule. Need it here.

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

Clapton is God

 

[Ilov80s]

Call me the anti-music nerd's music nerd, but I have never understood, and never will understand, the need to classify music. Green Day is Green Day. Good sounds evolve over time. And I think most of there's are awesome and never tire listening to them.

Those of us that like to organize our record bins need things in boxes. No, it's shorthand and nothing more. Punk takes on a sociopolitical aspect also, which makes it tricky. You can hate genres, but to some people it's important. It helps define the essence of things and the qualities of the band. When Eephus says that Green Day are more on the Buzzcocks side of the punk lineage tree I know exactly what he means and if I hadn't heard Green Day I would know what they might sound like.

Genres are heuristics and little more, but they do important communicative and classification work.

I am with you 100%. Maybe it helps to say clearly genre does not equal quality.

 

[The Dreaded Marco]

This is a true, start-to-finish album for me in which each song is perfect and leads into the other. When I listen to it, I hear the beginning notes of the next song play in my head as the current song is fading out.

This statement intrigued me, so I listened to Disintegration start to finish today. Then I listened to Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me start to finish. It confirmed what I initially thought, that for me KM KM KM is easily the best Cure album and is their best "start to finish every song is great" album. Sorry to potentially spotlight here...

Obviously I disagree but Kiss Me x 3 is my 4th favorite the Cure album and so it’s pretty damn great. Just a few too many misses for me to rank it as a top 70 album for me.

My 2nd favorite made my top 70 but did not likely make the cut. I’d be surprised if we see another the Cure album but I hope I’m wrong.

 

[Ilov80s]

Clapton I don't know. I think Green Day is bigger now than he could have dreamed of being. That's just my opinion and he was definitely before my time.

Type "Clapton is" into Google and see what the autocomplete says.

A particularly tough spot to be in with an ever more atheist western society

 

[The Dreaded Marco]

44. Tapestry – Carole King (416 points)

@simey #2
@Snoopy #2
@Idiot Boxer #3
@zamboni #13
@timschochet #13
@jwb #30
@Ilov80s #32
@Atomic Punk #46
@Mt. Man #70



Tapestry is the second studio album by the American singer-songwriter Carole King. Produced by Lou Adler, it was released on February 10, 1971, by Ode Records. The album's lead single, "It's Too Late" / "I Feel the Earth Move", spent five weeks at number one on both the Billboard Hot 100 and Easy Listening charts.

The album has received critical acclaim since its release and is widely regarded as one of the greatest albums of all time. It won four Grammy Awards at the 14th Annual Grammys in 1972, including Album of the Year, Song of the Year, and Record of the Year.

This was a favorite of my mom and reminds me Sunday mornings growing up, her cooking in the kitchen and me helping out. Us singing a long (terribly out of key). It's not an album I fire up too often anymore but whenever I do, I am reminded of how great it is. Another album that has more big hits than most artists can muster across 3 or 4 albums. My pick might be Where You Lead?

Although I think I’m at least 15-20 years older than you, this was also one of my mom’s favorites. She owned it and played it on vinyl very frequently during my childhood. So I also loved it. Neither of us could carry a tune either…..


I inherited that vinyl and still play it occasionally, but not quite top 70 for me.

 

[Atomic Punk]

47. 2112 – Rush (398 points)

@Val Rannous #1
@Atomic Punk #1
@zamboni #10
@Yo Mama #11
@BroncoFreak_2K3 #11
@New Binky the Doormat #17
@Mt. Man #55
@jwb #64



2112 (pronounced "twenty-one twelve") is the fourth studio album by Canadian rock band Rush, released in March 1976 by Mercury Records. It reached No. 5 in Canada and became the band's commercial breakthrough in America, peaking at No. 61.

The band was in financial hardship due to the disappointing sales of 1975's Caress of Steel, which also got an unfavorable critical reception and a decline in attendance at its shows. Mercury, their international label, considered dropping them but granted one more album following negotiations with manager Ray Danniels. Rush were pressured to deliver more commercial material but decided to continue developing its progressive rock direction they had explored on Caress of Steel and made the 20-minute futuristic science-fiction title track occupy side one of 2112 with a collection of shorter songs on side two that display their hard rock roots.

Love love love this album, and the middle finger shot at their record label. "So, you want more commercial stuff for radio? Well, listen to this!!!"

Well, I'll wait for @Atomic Punk to chime in since we're tied at #1, but my vote for the playlist song is probably obvious. Hey, it makes the playlist 20 minutes longer all by itself, but it's 20 minutes of GREATNESS!!!!

100% agree @Val Rannous! There is no doubt 2112 will be the choice now that it is unanimous.

 

[Atomic Punk]

So happy to see 2112 in the top 50. In putting this list together, at least 10-15 albums could have landed #1 depending on my feels that particular day.

This album for some reason has become my rainy day album and I was playing it the day I was completing my list, hence the ranking at the top. The story behind the album just makes it that much more deserving IMO. Glad to see so much other love for it.

And a quick shout out for Tapestry that is in very heavy rotation at the Punk residence.

 

[Don Quixote]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

I guess the short answer is it's not for me. All by Myself was not what I expected. I still like Basketcase the best and I felt like Burnout sounded like it. Alot of the songs sound pretty similarish to me but I think that's just rather common for some/most bands. Liked the solo/outro on Chump and I think that's my second favorite song. Did appreciate the shortness of the songs.

It's a punk album not rock in case we were still debating that.

 

[Val Rannous]

47. 2112 – Rush (398 points)

@Val Rannous #1
@Atomic Punk #1
@zamboni #10
@Yo Mama #11
@BroncoFreak_2K3 #11
@New Binky the Doormat #17
@Mt. Man #55
@jwb #64



2112 (pronounced "twenty-one twelve") is the fourth studio album by Canadian rock band Rush, released in March 1976 by Mercury Records. It reached No. 5 in Canada and became the band's commercial breakthrough in America, peaking at No. 61.

The band was in financial hardship due to the disappointing sales of 1975's Caress of Steel, which also got an unfavorable critical reception and a decline in attendance at its shows. Mercury, their international label, considered dropping them but granted one more album following negotiations with manager Ray Danniels. Rush were pressured to deliver more commercial material but decided to continue developing its progressive rock direction they had explored on Caress of Steel and made the 20-minute futuristic science-fiction title track occupy side one of 2112 with a collection of shorter songs on side two that display their hard rock roots.

Love love love this album, and the middle finger shot at their record label. "So, you want more commercial stuff for radio? Well, listen to this!!!"

Well, I'll wait for @Atomic Punk to chime in since we're tied at #1, but my vote for the playlist song is probably obvious. Hey, it makes the playlist 20 minutes longer all by itself, but it's 20 minutes of GREATNESS!!!!

100% agree @Val Rannous! There is no doubt 2112 will be the choice now that it is unanimous.

Let's goooooo!

2112: Overture / The Temples Of Syrinx / Discovery / Presentation / Oracle / Soliloquy / Grand Finale - Medley

Rush · 2112 · Song · 1976

open.spotify.com

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

47. 2112 – Rush (398 points)

@Val Rannous #1
@Atomic Punk #1
@zamboni #10
@Yo Mama #11
@BroncoFreak_2K3 #11
@New Binky the Doormat #17
@Mt. Man #55
@jwb #64



2112 (pronounced "twenty-one twelve") is the fourth studio album by Canadian rock band Rush, released in March 1976 by Mercury Records. It reached No. 5 in Canada and became the band's commercial breakthrough in America, peaking at No. 61.

The band was in financial hardship due to the disappointing sales of 1975's Caress of Steel, which also got an unfavorable critical reception and a decline in attendance at its shows. Mercury, their international label, considered dropping them but granted one more album following negotiations with manager Ray Danniels. Rush were pressured to deliver more commercial material but decided to continue developing its progressive rock direction they had explored on Caress of Steel and made the 20-minute futuristic science-fiction title track occupy side one of 2112 with a collection of shorter songs on side two that display their hard rock roots.

Love love love this album, and the middle finger shot at their record label. "So, you want more commercial stuff for radio? Well, listen to this!!!"

Well, I'll wait for @Atomic Punk to chime in since we're tied at #1, but my vote for the playlist song is probably obvious. Hey, it makes the playlist 20 minutes longer all by itself, but it's 20 minutes of GREATNESS!!!!

100% agree @Val Rannous! There is no doubt 2112 will be the choice now that it is unanimous.

Let's goooooo!

2112: Overture / The Temples Of Syrinx / Discovery / Presentation / Oracle / Soliloquy / Grand Finale - Medley

Rush · 2112 · Song · 1976

open.spotify.com

now this I like

 

[Eephus]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

vs. three for all other hip hop acts combined (four if you count Hamilton )

 

[Ilov80s]

I guess the short answer is it's not for me. All by Myself was not what I expected. I still like Basketcase the best and I felt like Burnout sounded like it. Alot of the songs sound pretty similarish to me but I think that's just rather common for some/most bands. Liked the solo/outro on Chump and I think that's my second favorite song. Did appreciate the shortness of the songs.

It's a punk album not rock in case we were still debating that.

I appreciate that, you have an album you want me to listen to right now?

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

I guess the short answer is it's not for me. All by Myself was not what I expected. I still like Basketcase the best and I felt like Burnout sounded like it. Alot of the songs sound pretty similarish to me but I think that's just rather common for some/most bands. Liked the solo/outro on Chump and I think that's my second favorite song. Did appreciate the shortness of the songs.

It's a punk album not rock in case we were still debating that.

I appreciate that, you have an album you want me to listen to right now?

have you done Audioslave yet? If so I got a x-mas album you can listen to but it didn't make the countdown :/

 

[jwb]

44. Tapestry – Carole King (416 points)

This made my 71-100 list. I have a theory that the first three songs (I Feel the Earth Move, So Far Away, It's Too Late) are a mini-song cycle about the beginning, middle and end of a relationship. My friend says I am nuts. (Insert joke about wikkid's libido here.)

Never thought of it that way but it makes a ton of sense.

I'm glad this one finished high.

 

[Ilov80s]

I guess the short answer is it's not for me. All by Myself was not what I expected. I still like Basketcase the best and I felt like Burnout sounded like it. Alot of the songs sound pretty similarish to me but I think that's just rather common for some/most bands. Liked the solo/outro on Chump and I think that's my second favorite song. Did appreciate the shortness of the songs.

It's a punk album not rock in case we were still debating that.

I appreciate that, you have an album you want me to listen to right now?

have you done Audioslave yet? If so I got a x-mas album you can listen to but it didn't make the countdown :/

I have definitely listened to Audioslave before because of how much I loved RATM but I don't know what albums.

 

[KarmaPolice]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

 

[jwb]

43. Innervisions – Stevie Wonder (419 points)

@Uruk-Hai #1
@krista4 #1
@Eephus #6
@Atomic Punk #8
@landrys hat #14
@Pip's Invitation #14
@Yo Mama #40
@timschochet #65

Innervisions is the sixteenth studio album by American singer, songwriter, and musician Stevie Wonder, released on August 3, 1973, by Tamla, a subsidiary of Motown Records. A landmark recording of Wonder's "classic period", the album has been regarded as completing his transition from the "Little Stevie Wonder" known for romantic ballads into a more musically mature, conscious, and grown-up artist. On the album, Wonder continued to experiment with the revolutionary T.O.N.T.O. (The Original New Timbral Orchestra) synthesizer system developed by Malcolm Cecil and Robert Margouleff, and Innervisions became hugely influential on the future sound of commercial soul and black music.

I re-listened to the five albums in Stevie's magnificent early-mid 70s run and liked Innervisions the best. YMMV.

It really was a remarkable run.

No Stevie on my list is a big miss by me. This is a great album.

 

[Don Quixote]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

 

[shuke]

I like it ok too but it does not belong this high.

It deserves to be where it is based on the people who voted it that high.

 

[MAC_32]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

They've had all 5. I was partially responsible for 4 of them, Undertow had enough pull from others to get it in too.

 

[shuke]

Call me the anti-music nerd's music nerd, but I have never understood, and never will understand, the need to classify music. Green Day is Green Day. Good sounds evolve over time. And I think most of there's are awesome and never tire listening to them.

Thank you. I hate being asked "what kind" of music I like. Uh, the good kind?

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

I guess the short answer is it's not for me. All by Myself was not what I expected. I still like Basketcase the best and I felt like Burnout sounded like it. Alot of the songs sound pretty similarish to me but I think that's just rather common for some/most bands. Liked the solo/outro on Chump and I think that's my second favorite song. Did appreciate the shortness of the songs.

It's a punk album not rock in case we were still debating that.

I appreciate that, you have an album you want me to listen to right now?

have you done Audioslave yet? If so I got a x-mas album you can listen to but it didn't make the countdown :/

I have definitely listened to Audioslave before because of how much I loved RATM but I don't know what albums.

Throwing Copper Live 70
Morning View Incubus 69
Break the Cycle Staind 68
Audioslave Audioslave 67
We are not Alone Breaking Benjamin 65
Slippery When Wet Bon Jovi 64
Toxicity System of a Down 63
Fear of the Dark Iron Maiden 62
Hybrid Theory Linkin Park 59
The Black Album Metalica 58
Tragic Kingdom No Doubt 56
Jagged Little Pill Alanis Morissette 55
Life Dope 54
The Marshall Mathers LP Eminem 51

these are all the albums of mine that have been revealed, just pick one.

 

[Don Quixote]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

They've had all 5. I was partially responsible for 4 of them, Undertow had enough pull from others to get it in too.

Huh. I still only see four on the first page. Maybe one got skipped when Dr. O was putting the list on page one.

 

[Nick Vermeil]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

They've had all 5. I was partially responsible for 4 of them, Undertow had enough pull from others to get it in too.

Huh. I still only see four on the first page. Maybe one got skipped when Dr. O was putting the list on page one.

Let’s face it, Dr. O is a disaster.

 

[KarmaPolice]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

They've had all 5. I was partially responsible for 4 of them, Undertow had enough pull from others to get it in too.

Huh. I still only see four on the first page. Maybe one got skipped when Dr. O was putting the list on page one.

Let’s face it, Dr. O is a disaster.

It would be funny if he misspelled Tool after all the mistakes on submissions he had to deal with.

 

[KarmaPolice]

We should have done a mystery draft buddy that was assigned at the beginning who we have to listen to a couple albums of theirs we never had before. Could make for good hijinks.

 

[Don Quixote]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

They've had all 5. I was partially responsible for 4 of them, Undertow had enough pull from others to get it in too.

Huh. I still only see four on the first page. Maybe one got skipped when Dr. O was putting the list on page one.

Let’s face it, Dr. O is a disaster.

It would be funny if he misspelled Tool after all the mistakes on submissions he had to deal with.

I think I figured it out. #99 missing from page one. That was Lateralus, it looks like.

 

[MAC_32]

We should have done a mystery draft buddy that was assigned at the beginning who we have to listen to a couple albums of theirs we never had before. Could make for good hijinks.

I'd still be up for this

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

we could still pair off but the question is if there are enough albums that people besides me have not heard

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

we could still pair off but the question is if there are enough albums that people besides me have not heard

well I guess half of you haven't listened to the new metal albums....

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

Granted that other artists have more to come, but do the Beastie Boys (at least temporarily) hold the lead for the most albums in the countdown? It looks like they have had four show up so far. (And I’m just going by artist name for this question — I expect Clapton, Dylan, Neil Young, or a Beatle may have shown up most overall between the different acts.)

Hasn't Tool had all 5 drafted?

I see four for Tool too when I search on first page of the thread.

They've had all 5. I was partially responsible for 4 of them, Undertow had enough pull from others to get it in too.

Huh. I still only see four on the first page. Maybe one got skipped when Dr. O was putting the list on page one.

Let’s face it, Dr. O is a disaster.

It would be funny if he misspelled Tool after all the mistakes on submissions he had to deal with.

a tool cover band named toll?