What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Determining Draft Order - Redraft Leagur (1 Viewer)

Spiderman

Footballguy
This is how our league plans to determine the draft order of our 12 person league this season.

The initial plan is to catch 12 turtles at the cottage, list all 12 participants in the league on a piece of paper in no particular order, tape a number from 1-12 on each turtles back, place them in a rocked off section of the beach in a perfect line and then let them go for 1/2 an hour. After 30 minutes, we will stand behind the rocked off area and read the numbers off their backs from left to right as seen looking out at the water. The farthest left will be the number assigned to the guy whose name is at the top of the list and so on reading numbers from left to right and writing names from top to bottom.

Once numbers have been assigned, we will place the turtles back in the rocked off area and turn them loose a second time for 30 minutes. The same rules apply. The turtle on the farthest left will represent the #1 pick in the draft. 2nd from the left is the 2nd overall pick and so on. Ties will be determined by shell position (whichever turtle has the slightest piece of shell that is farther left at the buzzer with a majority rules decision). We will fold the pieces of paper on the turtles' backs so that it is not readily understandable who the winning turtle actually is and that will allow us to count back from 12 to 1 to keep "The Decision of the Turtles" a secret until the very last two #'s are opened.

Does anyone have a problem with this method? I will think of a secondary method in case we are unable to come up with 12 turtles by Sunday morning.

Anyway, this seems to be the way we are leaning toward picking the draft order this year. We've never used wild animals, so that should increase the unnecessary complexity a bit from last year, which is the given requirement.

 
Pick #1: Loser of Toilet Bowl

Picks #2 – 4: Reverse order of non-playoff teams

Picks # 5 – 8: Non-Super Bowl participants in reverse order of finish

Pick #9: Super bowl loser

Pick #10: Super Bowl winner

League set-up

10 team league/2 divisions

Top 3 in each division make playoffs:

Week 14: #1’s have bye - #2 & #3 play and #4 & #5 play

Week 15: Winners of #2/3 play #1

Week 16: Winners of #2/3 vs #1 meet other divisions #2/3 vs #1 winner in Super Bowl Losers of #4/#5 play other #4/5 loser in “Toilet Bowl” with the loser of that game buying pizza at next years draft

 
We actually pick cards ( A,2,3 - 10,J,Q) every 2 rounds. So when you make your second round pick you have no idea when you are drafting in the third.

Time consuming and strategically frustrating but that is the tradition.

 
Random draw out of a helmet by one of our draft girls.

We then use the reverse order for the waiver wire until kick off of week one.

Keep it fun.

 
We bid real $$$ for the draft SLOT (not the player) for the first round.

Then repeat the auction for the second round slots

The serpentine draft starts at 3-1 with the order for the third round determined by the order of Round 1

:thumbup: REALLY builds the prize pool

 
Wow. Both TeamDingo's and Spiderman's suggestions seem like a LOT of work.

This year we are using an online dice roll simulator. Each team gets 3 rolls of a 1000 sided dice. Once everybody has rolled, we will pick our draft spots starting with the highest roll.

This will be done ahead of our draft, so each team can plan their strategy ahead of time.

 
Random lotto......

Your turtle idea seems a little bit much just to get a list of random draft slots in an order. If your dead set on going with something like this, I'd suggest a crab race (these are popular at some SoFla bars).

Each player gets a hermit crab and gives it a name. They are cheap at any pet store and come in (or can be painted) a varity of colors.

Make a big circle in the sand. Place all crabs in the middle. First one out of the circle is the winner with the other slots to follow. Assign reverse points for the placements and run 3 rounds of races. Most points is 1st, etc......

Don't forget the beer which helps with your passion in cheering on your crab to victory. If you ever in Miami and you hear the howl of "Gooooo Ms. Kryppies!!!!" coming from one of these events, that is probaby me you hear.

Have fun!

 
We bid real $$$ for the draft SLOT (not the player) for the first round.

Then repeat the auction for the second round slots

The serpentine draft starts at 3-1 with the order for the third round determined by the order of Round 1

:thumbup: REALLY builds the prize pool
I like this. how does the bidding usually go?
 
We go by regular season standings with the last place team getting the first choice of where to pick. Different players like drafting in different positions so we allow them to choose their draft slot.

Someone normally grabs the #12 pick early for the turn picks.

....I am thinking about using the turtle method now though.

 
We do a lottery ala the NBA.

12 team league.

Worst team gets their name put on a piece of paper into a hat 12 times, 2nd worst; 11 pieces of paper.......Champion gets their name on one piece of paper.

The order in which your name is drawn is your draft spot.

 
My 10 team redraft has an Excel spreadsheet programmed to generate random draft picks for every odd numbered round. Then the even number round is just a reverse snake method of the odd numbered round before it. Since it is redraft, we don't bring into any account of the previous year(s) results. Our two divisions are also randomly selected based on the first round draft order.

 
Work league is random drawing each year w/ equal odds for all participants.

Main league is based on last year's standings -- non-playoff team with best record picks #1, worst team picks #10. Playoff teams are slotted 11 - 16 in reverse order they were eliminated. Regular season record then total points are used to break any "ties."

 
We go by regular season standings with the last place team getting the first choice of where to pick. Different players like drafting in different positions so we allow them to choose their draft slot.

Someone normally grabs the #12 pick early for the turn picks.

....I am thinking about using the turtle method now though.
I'll let you guys know how it goes! We're doing it in mid July, so a few of us are going snorkling for some turtles the evening before....We're looking forward to this method.
 
Random lotto......

Your turtle idea seems a little bit much just to get a list of random draft slots in an order. If your dead set on going with something like this, I'd suggest a crab race (these are popular at some SoFla bars).

Each player gets a hermit crab and gives it a name. They are cheap at any pet store and come in (or can be painted) a varity of colors.

Make a big circle in the sand. Place all crabs in the middle. First one out of the circle is the winner with the other slots to follow. Assign reverse points for the placements and run 3 rounds of races. Most points is 1st, etc......

Don't forget the beer which helps with your passion in cheering on your crab to victory. If you ever in Miami and you hear the howl of "Gooooo Ms. Kryppies!!!!" coming from one of these events, that is probaby me you hear.

Have fun!
Yeah, the idea of the turtle method is to make this as complicated as possible while having fun!
 
We do a lottery ala the NBA.

12 team league. 

Worst team gets their name put on a piece of paper into a hat 12 times, 2nd worst; 11 pieces of paper.......Champion gets their name on one piece of paper.

The order in which your name is drawn is your draft spot.
I actually like the idea of having some continuity to the previous season. I also like giving a slight perk to a team who had a rough year. I think it helps the long term health of a league and certainly has a correlation to the real NFL. (I know some of you cutthroats think this is insane, but to each his own I guess.)Your method of having the order the names is drawn be the draft spot is fine, but you might consider a twist: have each owner choose their preferred draft spot rather than be locked into a position. I for one would not typically want to be first, especially if I see a situation where the top 3 or 4 picks are roughly the same. I'd rather slot myself 3rd or 4th if that's where I see the dropoff.

So the first team to be picked by the lottery could choose any spot 1-12. The second team would have every spot available except for the one chosen by the first team, etc.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The initial plan is to catch 12 turtles at the cottage, list all 12 participants in the league on a piece of paper in no particular order, tape a number from 1-12 on each turtles back, place them in a rocked off section of the beach in a perfect line and then let them go for 1/2 an hour.
We do something similar in my league. Each of us catches our own coed and tape our name to her before letting her go. We draft in the order we get arrested. However, we have found we have to set the draft order 6-9 months in advance to make sure everyone can make it. 3 months with good behavior.Chris Henry mentioned he's going to talk all of his leagues into using this method this year.
 
Man, I am loving the Hooters suggestion.........

I HATE attaching draft order or ANY privileges to the draft and acquisitions during the season. We draw numbers and allow selection of draft position which makes things much more interesting for strategic purposes. I bumped down last year from 4 to 8 (targeting Portis) and picked up their 8th round pick (used for Rodney Harrison, ugh).

 
We do a lottery ala the NBA.

12 team league.

Worst team gets their name put on a piece of paper into a hat 12 times, 2nd worst; 11 pieces of paper.......Champion gets their name on one piece of paper.

The order in which your name is drawn is your draft spot.
Combine this with the turtles...Toilet winner gets first slot, then reverse regular season order of finish for non playoffs and then reverse order of playoff finish.

 
In my league we go random every odd round. 1 mos. before the draft we put everyones name into a draft order randomizer and we select random every other round. I think this makes for a really interesting draft and i think it's pretty fair. You could get the 1st pick of the draft then draft 12th in round 2 and then draft 10th in round 3 and so on heres the website:

http://www.profantasysports.com/draft_randomizer/

 
whatever happened to the worst team in the league getting the 1st round pick in the rookie draft assuming he did not trade it away the previous season?? and then so on??

 
whatever happened to the worst team in the league getting the 1st round pick in the rookie draft assuming he did not trade it away the previous season?? and then so on??
Works will for a keeper/dynasty league. Not so much or as clear for a redraft. Theoretically, everyone starts the same in a redraft, although I mentioned earlier that I'm in favor of throwing a bone to the worst teams from the year before. I guess I'm soft.
 
We play a League-Pick'Em and whoever wins at the end of the year, get's the number one pick the following year.

Then we spin a random draft generator until the winner get's the number one slot. Everyone is slotted based on that spin.

 
We use an online dice roll with 100 sides. It rolls 3 random numbers. 1st number: draft position

2nd number: used as tie breaker of the 1st number

3rd number: division placement, etc

lowest number - 1st overall

highest number - last pick

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top