Diggs or Kittle (1 Viewer)

[aaj1997]

Which is the better option for a 5th keeper?  There are no keeper restrictions for this league and I can keep for as long as I want.  My other keepers will be 2 RB and 2 WR, the league is PPR starting a QB/2RB/3WR/TE/1FLEX(RB,WR,TE)/K/DEF.  I will attempt to trade whichever I do not keep.  Thanks.

 

[travdogg]

I'm curious who your other 4 keepers are, as Diggs and Kittle are both top-30 overall guys in my opinion. I'd prefer Diggs, by a hair. I think they are both still ascending, but Diggs is a bit more proven. I worry Kittle, while not a fluke, sees less work with the new additions in SF, and while not a worry, it is mildly concerning that his best work came with QB's who aren't Garoppolo.

 

[ZWK]

I'd keep Kittle since I'd draft him a bit sooner in redraft. It's close. Seems best to shop both of them around, trade the one that brings in a better offer, and keep the other.

 

[Gally]

If you can only keep one and are torn on which one to keep I would put both on the trade block and give up the one that nets you the best return. 

 

[ProfPoobah]

I also would be interested to know who the other four keepers are, but working on the assumption that their redraft value is higher than either Diggs or Kittle, I think I'd lean towards keeping Kittle and trading Diggs, as I believe most of the top-end TE will be kept with so many keepers gone (how many teams in your league?).  That said, if Kittle would get you more than a marginally better deal in a trade, I'd be fine moving him.

 

[aaj1997]

Keeping Kamara, Chubb, Beckham and Evans.

 

[LBH]

I’d keep Kittle pretty easily over Diggs.