That strip steak on mac is my favorite dish at Mama Melrose's. And since it qualifies for DDP and Phantasmic dining, you can get it at a big discount.
Our Mama Melrose's experience was a bunch of little things that built up. The front of the house didn't have a record of us doing Phantasmic, so there was confusion about what we could and couldn't order and what price plan we were on. Our server was slow and short with us, quite unusual for Disney. Our entrees took a while to come out, much longer than it should at a place that level of dining. Water glasses were left empty. One member of our party wanted a mix of red and white sauce on their entree, and it came out with just white. We sent it back, and they just ladeled some red on top of it and brought it back, killing the texture of the dish.
Manager came out, gave us an extra FastPass for our trouble, and comped the botched entree. Server refused to accept a tip.