does anyone use (1 Viewer)

[tuffnutt]

Is there a place i can go to get an unbiased person to look at trades and ok or veto them in my league. we have tried to vote thing in years past but it seems like there is always lobbying to get trade vetoed. any help pointing me in the right direction would be great.

thanks

tuff

 

[Zoomanji]

PM the trade to me and I'll approve them for you.

I can't even count how many threads I have seen about trades, vetoes and collusion.

In a nutshell the prevailing opinion is that any trade should stand unless

1- There is obvious collusion between 2 owners (which is nearly impossible to prove but easy to suspect)

2- Many trades look lopsided at 1st than a couple weeks later the "dummy" is a genius

3- Dude is just an idiot and will throw-off the balance in the league either intentionally or through stupidity. This happens abut 1% of the time. The other 99% of the time its owners complaining because they didn't get what looked like a "sweet deal"

So to finally answer your question: No, I have never heard of such a place but feel free to use me as an arbitrator. Sounds like fun.

 

[MAC_32]

No, unless it's obvious one owner is dumping no trades should be vetoed.

 

[comfortably numb]

Just post them in the AC forum, and take a consensus?

 

[Rushmore]

Yes, there's a place on another website (forget which one) called commisioner's court or something like that. In the league I comish, I appointed a small commitee of owners who I deemed most honorable, objective, and knowledgeable. You get a better and more fair result than just letting the whole league vote on it, where bias and less educated opinions can have a better chance of swaying the result.