DT, 1.12 for CJ and 1.06 (1 Viewer)

[slicedbred21]

12 team dynasty, ppr, all tds 6 points

team 1: D Thomas and 1.12

team 2: CJ Anderson and 1.06

 

[TheBottomLine]

I think there is a drop-off after the top 6 rookie picks so I may slightly lean towards CJ and the better pick, but I'm lower on Demaryius than most.  

 

[travdogg]

I'd rather have Anderson and the 1.6. The 1.6 is the best part of the deal, and the 1.12 is the worst.

 

[Mr. Irrelevant]

Close enough that it probably comes down to lineup considerations.

If it's a typical 1/2/3/1/1/1 plus a flex, people will more often be starting 2 RB/4 WR than 3/3 - therefore the VBD baseline for WRs will be lower, which combined with their significantly longer careers means mid-tier WRs such as DT will hold significantly more value than mid-tier RBs such as CJA.

If people have the ability to start 4 RBs (for instance 1/2/2/1/1/1 plus 2 FL), the value of mid-tier RBs swings back up enough that I'd lean the CJA side given the higher pick.

In a vacuum, you can probably flip a coin.

 

[fightingillini]

Pretty even trade, but I would side with Anderson and the 1.6.

 

[Gally]

Nothing additional to say.  Fair deal that would depend on roster need.  I probably lean the DT side unless there was someone I really wanted at 1.06.

 

[slicedbred21]

what about this one  

DT, 1.12 and 2018 2nd

CJ, Charles, 1.06

 

[Gally]

what about this one  

DT, 1.12 and 2018 2nd

CJ, Charles, 1.06

I don't think Charles has much left in the tank but for an additional 2nd rounder it probably isn't a bad thing to lock up both CJ and Charles.  Again, this is somewhat dependent upon your team makeup and needs as to which side I would prefer.  I don't have a lot of faith in CJ/Charles as anything more than a low end RB2 but probably more likely RB3.     

 

[slicedbred21]

My roster after the trade would be. 

Rodgers, Stafford

Howard, Crowell, CJ, Charles, Coleman, White

Watkins, Adams, Pryor, Wallace, Perriman, Britt

Welker, Fleener, Allen, Barnidge

1.06, 1.11, 3.11, 4.11

 

[huskermadhatter]

I like CJ Anderson and the 1.06 with your roster as long as you're a believer in the long-term upside of Pryor.  I haven't seen anything to believe that he won't improve with better QB play.

See Mine:  Link

 

[slicedbred21]

So now I also have these 2 offers:

#1

DT, 1.12, 2018 2nd

CJ, Charles, 1.06

or

#2

DT, White, 1.12

CJ, Charles, 1.06

I concerned that neither of these trades actually make my team any better. I am leaning toward the first one but am still torn.  I feel like I have pretty decent depth at WR already and moving up, for what is likely going to be Williams, ends up being a wash with me trading away DT.

Sometimes I think I get excited about trading during the off season just because there isn't anything else going on.

Anyone else care to share an opinion?

Current roster:

QB: Rodgers, Stafford

RB: Howard, Crowell, Coleman, White

WR: DT, Watkins, Adams, Pryor, Wallace, Perriman, Britt, Conley, Gordon

TE: Walker, Fleener, Allen, Barnidge

Taxi: Miller, Treadwell, D. Washington

1.11, 1.12, 3.11, 4.11