Biabreakable
Footballguy
These are consensus dynasty rankings for year 2007 1pt./tackle .5pt assist 3pt./sack or interception 2pt. forced fumble/fumble recovery 1pt./pass defensed.
If you vote other, please specify.
Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round. By doing this we can get some good information about players being considered here and why. If everyone contributes then each poll position can be similar to a player spotlight. That is idealy what I would like to see. I definitly need feedback on what players you think should be on these polls that may not be. I do not have as much knowledge of IDPs as I do offensive players so all of the good players on defense are not neccessarily in my forward memory banks so to speak. So I need some help from the rest of your there.
1. Julius Peppers 1/18/1980
2. Jarred Allen 4/3/1982
3. Osi Umenyiora 11/16/1981
4. Terrell Suggs 10/11/1982
5. Jason Taylor 9/1/1974
6. Aaron Kampman 11/30/1979
7. Will Smith 7/4/1981
8. Aaron Schobel 4/1/1977
9. Robert Mathis 2/26/1981
*please note it was very hard for me to award Mathis as the winner of this poll when he only has one vote more than Hali. But this is the way I am going to try doing this to speed up the process. I will consider taking the top 2 or 3 in close decisions moving forward also as has been suggested. I did not want to do that here without adding Charles Grant to the polls 1st. And I am still thinking over this runoff idea that for some reason does not sit well with me.
If you vote other, please specify.
Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round. By doing this we can get some good information about players being considered here and why. If everyone contributes then each poll position can be similar to a player spotlight. That is idealy what I would like to see. I definitly need feedback on what players you think should be on these polls that may not be. I do not have as much knowledge of IDPs as I do offensive players so all of the good players on defense are not neccessarily in my forward memory banks so to speak. So I need some help from the rest of your there.
1. Julius Peppers 1/18/1980
2. Jarred Allen 4/3/1982
3. Osi Umenyiora 11/16/1981
4. Terrell Suggs 10/11/1982
5. Jason Taylor 9/1/1974
6. Aaron Kampman 11/30/1979
7. Will Smith 7/4/1981
8. Aaron Schobel 4/1/1977
9. Robert Mathis 2/26/1981
*please note it was very hard for me to award Mathis as the winner of this poll when he only has one vote more than Hali. But this is the way I am going to try doing this to speed up the process. I will consider taking the top 2 or 3 in close decisions moving forward also as has been suggested. I did not want to do that here without adding Charles Grant to the polls 1st. And I am still thinking over this runoff idea that for some reason does not sit well with me.
Last edited by a moderator:
