Dynasty - Last minute pick ups for Practice Squad (1 Viewer)

[gheemony]

I am in a salary cap keeper league with a 4-person practice squad. I have all four spots open and enough cash to bid and buy 4 players to fill these spots. Today is our last transaction session of the season. I am looking for thoughts on the following priority list. Before next season, I will probably need 2-3 spots on my practice squad for rookies and carry-over players that are practice squad eligible, so I don't need all 4 of these players to pan out. I am looking for guys that are most likely to increase in value in the off-season so that it is a "no brainer" to keep them.

1. Michael Turner: Yes, I know he is an RFA and that it is unlikely that he'll move teams. But my thought is, if he does move teams, he becomes a no-brainer keeper.

2. Matt Schaub: Again, an RFA who may not move teams. But my thought is that he is a player who become very valuable if does change teams. Maybe not in 2007, but in 2008. I like the idea of having a promising young QB to stash.

The next few are quite equal:

3. Cedric Houston: RBs are fantasy gold in most league, including this one. He seems to be a RB with potential to be good. I worry about him splitting time with Leon Washington or NYJ drafting another RB. I could see Houston moving down the list.

4. Vincent Jackson: Recent article is that he's slated to be the #1 WR in SD next season. It's his third year. McCardell is aging. Down side is that he's still option 3 behind Gates and LT.

5. Brian Calhoun: RBs are gold. Jones is possibly out for the season. My worry is that Calhoun is still coming of a knee injury and DET is an awful team.

6. Brandon Marshall: He looks like the heir apparent to replace Rod Smith. But when will that happen? And how do we know that he doesn't become Darius Watts.

7. Tony Scheffler: Seems to be an up and coming TE with a good connection with Cutler. But, he is just a TE and I have Gonzo and Heath Miller.

8. Kris Wilson: Again, lots of skill and chance to start if Gonzo moves to another team, but just a TE.

Other names to consider: Garrard, Jason Campbell, Leon Washington, Adrian Peterson (CHI), Buckhalter, Brandon Jones, Malcolm Floyd, Derek Hagan, Tarvaris Jackson.

Am I potentially missing anyone (I know you don't know who else is available)? Wrong preferences? I am thinking that a QB might be useful.

Thanks.

Edit: to add Tarvaris Jackson to other options.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

My Dynasty Rankings should help answer this question.

I would do Turner, Marshall, Schaub, Jackson as the top 4 in that order.

 

[gheemony]

My Dynasty Rankings should help answer this question.

I would do Turner, Marshall, Schaub, Jackson as the top 4 in that order.

Bloom, thanks. Really appreciate a staff member taking the time to reply. Question: why not Garrard over Jackson? Isn't the assumption that Garrard will be the starter next year with Lefty being traded? Or do you think there is a better chance that Jackson is the starter in MIN?Lastly, I love the Audible, and know that you love Brandon Marshall. I also heard Schefter say that he has seen many DEN WRs not live up to the hype (Kasper, Watts, etc.). Still sticking by your opinion that he will be baby TO?

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

My Dynasty Rankings should help answer this question.

I would do Turner, Marshall, Schaub, Jackson as the top 4 in that order.

Bloom, thanks. Really appreciate a staff member taking the time to reply. Question: why not Garrard over Jackson? Isn't the assumption that Garrard will be the starter next year with Lefty being traded? Or do you think there is a better chance that Jackson is the starter in MIN?Lastly, I love the Audible, and know that you love Brandon Marshall. I also heard Schefter say that he has seen many DEN WRs not live up to the hype (Kasper, Watts, etc.). Still sticking by your opinion that he will be baby TO?

Actually missing Garrard was an oversight. Garrard over Jackson, unless you are strictly going for upside.I still believe in Marshall 100000%

 

[nightshift]

Nice to see smaller rosters in dynasty...

For those of us hoarding waterboys in the hopes that they can some hold LT2's strap, here's a few not so obvious stash players:

Cedric Humes, RB PIT (practice squad) - has been seen @ GB for a workout

Dede Dorsey, RB IND - Rhodes is a UFA next year.

Greg Jones, RB JAX - Fred & Drew show need a 3rd? Nope. Could be traded...

Aaron (Please retire before me, Favre) Rodgers, QB GB - Favre's last season? maybe...

 

[Biabreakable]

Aaron (Please retire before me, Favre) Rodgers, QB GB - Favre's last season? maybe...

lol funny enough I could see Favre's career as a starter lasting longer than Rodgers does. Rodgers is not a shoe in for the Green Bush job even if Favre does retire. He was drafted by a different regime and it was a late pick at that when many other Qb needing teams passed on him. Ingle Martin may have close to even footing with Rodgers in training camp net year.of the players listed I like:TurnerTarvaris JacksonBrian CalhounShuabOthers who might be there worth consideringemitrius WilliamsKevin Curtis

 

[weisguy0831]

Sigmund

Great job on the rankings. At a quick glance, I noticed you have Brian Calhoun ranked ahead of Ladell Betts. Can you explain this one?

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

SigmundGreat job on the rankings. At a quick glance, I noticed you have Brian Calhoun ranked ahead of Ladell Betts. Can you explain this one?

Betts is stuck behind Portis for the foreseeable future. If Betts hadn't re-signed long term with the Skins, his recent performances would have easily vaulted him up 5-10 spots. However, its hard to see his value growing greatly.Calhoun has new opportunity due to Kevin Jones foot falling apart. Sure, Calhoun is coming back from a torn ACL himself, but he could definitely be ready to play before KJ. Remember Calhoun was rated very close to MJD and Norwood going into the draft, and we know how those guys are doing.

 

[nightshift]

SigmundGreat job on the rankings. At a quick glance, I noticed you have Brian Calhoun ranked ahead of Ladell Betts. Can you explain this one?

Betts is stuck behind Portis for the foreseeable future. If Betts hadn't re-signed long term with the Skins, his recent performances would have easily vaulted him up 5-10 spots. However, its hard to see his value growing greatly.Calhoun has new opportunity due to Kevin Jones foot falling apart. Sure, Calhoun is coming back from a torn ACL himself, but he could definitely be ready to play before KJ. Remember Calhoun was rated very close to MJD and Norwood going into the draft, and we know how those guys are doing.

I doubt either one is the starter in 2007. Either Detroit drafts a RB early plus there will be some interesting vets available.

 

[nightshift]

Aaron (Please retire before me, Favre) Rodgers, QB GB - Favre's last season? maybe...

lol funny enough I could see Favre's career as a starter lasting longer than Rodgers does. Rodgers is not a shoe in for the Green Bush job even if Favre does retire. He was drafted by a different regime and it was a late pick at that when many other Qb needing teams passed on him. Ingle Martin may have close to even footing with Rodgers in training camp net year.of the players listed I like:TurnerTarvaris JacksonBrian CalhounShuabOthers who might be there worth consideringemitrius WilliamsKevin Curtis

Best thing that could happen to Rodgers is that GB managment trades him to a different team.

 

[Futility]

SigmundGreat job on the rankings. At a quick glance, I noticed you have Brian Calhoun ranked ahead of Ladell Betts. Can you explain this one?

Betts is stuck behind Portis for the foreseeable future. If Betts hadn't re-signed long term with the Skins, his recent performances would have easily vaulted him up 5-10 spots. However, its hard to see his value growing greatly.Calhoun has new opportunity due to Kevin Jones foot falling apart. Sure, Calhoun is coming back from a torn ACL himself, but he could definitely be ready to play before KJ. Remember Calhoun was rated very close to MJD and Norwood going into the draft, and we know how those guys are doing.

I doubt either one is the starter in 2007. Either Detroit drafts a RB early plus there will be some interesting vets available.

I seriously doubt they draft another RB high unless they get very negative reports on Jones, ie career ending. If the Lions are concerned that Jones won't be ready for 2007, I would expect a low key, veteran free agent signing - think Michael Bennet, Najeh Davenport types.

 

[urfriend]

Where do you think Chris Brown will be signing next year? DO you think he signs with the Broncos? With Tatum still not living up to the starter role it appears that they will be looking for a new RB next year.

I know there are some rumors with J.Jones being traded but I do not know who would be interested him because of his style of running. He might fit in well with the Giants as a change of pace if Tiki does retire. I do not think anyone in the league will give up a 2nd for him.

Is the other Jones brother done in Chicago? I would think so Benson has been showing great improvement and I feel Jones is probably out of the picture. I do not know where he would end up because a lot of the backfields in the league are pretty settled.

Next Year Teams that might need RBs:

Houston Is Davis done if so who will be in there

Denver Both Bells are not doing the job

Jets Big mess in this backfield

Giants? Is Tiki really done

Titans? Who is going to come out of this mess

Arizona? how much does Edge have left

Detroit? Jones if healthy is the one to go with

There might be more but with the rookies that are coming out I know most of these teams will be able to fill there voids.

Just trying to see if anyone has any insight on next years vets.

 

[gheemony]

Aaron (Please retire before me, Favre) Rodgers, QB GB - Favre's last season? maybe...

lol funny enough I could see Favre's career as a starter lasting longer than Rodgers does. Rodgers is not a shoe in for the Green Bush job even if Favre does retire. He was drafted by a different regime and it was a late pick at that when many other Qb needing teams passed on him. Ingle Martin may have close to even footing with Rodgers in training camp net year.of the players listed I like:TurnerTarvaris JacksonBrian CalhounShuabOthers who might be there worth consideringemitrius WilliamsKevin Curtis

Thanks. INteresting to have Jackson at #2 on the list. I worry that this is like Lundy-mania of the summer. The draftniks agree that he is pretty raw. In contrast, Garrard has started in this league and can score points by running and Schaub has very good skills (check out the Football Outsiders college QB projection system). Jackson could be like Culpepper, but he feels a long ways away. If I had a deep dynasty league, I would definitely stash him, but this league is a little too thin.Same with Calhoun. The ACL tear makes me think I can grab him as a free agent in the off-season auction.

 

[Biabreakable]

Aaron (Please retire before me, Favre) Rodgers, QB GB - Favre's last season? maybe...

lol funny enough I could see Favre's career as a starter lasting longer than Rodgers does. Rodgers is not a shoe in for the Green Bush job even if Favre does retire. He was drafted by a different regime and it was a late pick at that when many other Qb needing teams passed on him. Ingle Martin may have close to even footing with Rodgers in training camp net year.of the players listed I like:TurnerTarvaris JacksonBrian CalhounShuabOthers who might be there worth consideringemitrius WilliamsKevin Curtis

Thanks. INteresting to have Jackson at #2 on the list. I worry that this is like Lundy-mania of the summer. The draftniks agree that he is pretty raw. In contrast, Garrard has started in this league and can score points by running and Schaub has very good skills (check out the Football Outsiders college QB projection system). Jackson could be like Culpepper, but he feels a long ways away. If I had a deep dynasty league, I would definitely stash him, but this league is a little too thin.Same with Calhoun. The ACL tear makes me think I can grab him as a free agent in the off-season auction.

I'm used to much deeper rosters so take it for what its worth.In a perfect world Childress would prefer to let Jackson learn the ropes from the sidelines for another year before throwing him into the fray. However that is no longer and option. He will get to play these last 2 games and gain some experience to use as perspective for the offseason in preperation. I believe he will be the Vikings starter next year so that is why I have him 2nd out of the players you listed. Immediate results and you can leave him on your practice squad until he is needed correct?If you don't aquire him I imagine someone else will. Then if he develops into somthing useful you will have missed your chance to get him cheap. I think most of those other players will be slower to develop and therefore safer on waivers for now.So that is also a factor in my reasoning besides overall talent. Players that make a faster impact in a small roster league will gain trade interest before long term impact players. So I would target the players I see as giving me quicker return on my investment. Once trades are executed then you free roster space to pick up more players and keep cycling that process.ETA- in small roster leagues draft picks become more valuable imo because they do not take roster space. They are like a free roster slot until the pick is made.

 

[wannabee]

A few names might be Dominik Hixon, wr, Denver (who is on IR with foot injury) and Brad Smith, WR, NYJ who has shown flashes.

 

[Faust]

 

[zamboni]

The now-forgotten TJ Duckett is a UFA and could conceivably end up in a good situation (maybe a thunder part of a thunder and lightning). While an underperformer, he still has some skills.

 

[Biabreakable]

The now-forgotten TJ Duckett is a UFA and could conceivably end up in a good situation (maybe a thunder part of a thunder and lightning). While an underperformer, he still has some skills.

Duckett has pretty much been a bust but yes he should get another shot with another team.If he gets beaten out again I think thats it for him though and he will forever be a backup/COP Rb.I just had a nightmare thought as a DeAngelo Williams owner though.. as Carolina has shown an interest in the big Rb.. I expect Williams would beat Duckett out anyways but it would be nice to not have the RBBC.What other teams do you think might pursue him?The Steelers were rumored to have an interest in him. I don't know if that is true or not. Parker has done very well in the mean time.Who else?Also I think its important to point out that although Duckett is a bigger Rb he has not shown the power that one might expect for a Rb his size. He does have some good stright line speed though.

 

[gheemony]

Aaron (Please retire before me, Favre) Rodgers, QB GB - Favre's last season? maybe...

lol funny enough I could see Favre's career as a starter lasting longer than Rodgers does. Rodgers is not a shoe in for the Green Bush job even if Favre does retire. He was drafted by a different regime and it was a late pick at that when many other Qb needing teams passed on him. Ingle Martin may have close to even footing with Rodgers in training camp net year.of the players listed I like:TurnerTarvaris JacksonBrian CalhounShuabOthers who might be there worth consideringemitrius WilliamsKevin Curtis

Thanks. INteresting to have Jackson at #2 on the list. I worry that this is like Lundy-mania of the summer. The draftniks agree that he is pretty raw. In contrast, Garrard has started in this league and can score points by running and Schaub has very good skills (check out the Football Outsiders college QB projection system). Jackson could be like Culpepper, but he feels a long ways away. If I had a deep dynasty league, I would definitely stash him, but this league is a little too thin.Same with Calhoun. The ACL tear makes me think I can grab him as a free agent in the off-season auction.

I'm used to much deeper rosters so take it for what its worth.In a perfect world Childress would prefer to let Jackson learn the ropes from the sidelines for another year before throwing him into the fray. However that is no longer and option. He will get to play these last 2 games and gain some experience to use as perspective for the offseason in preperation. I believe he will be the Vikings starter next year so that is why I have him 2nd out of the players you listed. Immediate results and you can leave him on your practice squad until he is needed correct?If you don't aquire him I imagine someone else will. Then if he develops into somthing useful you will have missed your chance to get him cheap. I think most of those other players will be slower to develop and therefore safer on waivers for now.So that is also a factor in my reasoning besides overall talent. Players that make a faster impact in a small roster league will gain trade interest before long term impact players. So I would target the players I see as giving me quicker return on my investment. Once trades are executed then you free roster space to pick up more players and keep cycling that process.ETA- in small roster leagues draft picks become more valuable imo because they do not take roster space. They are like a free roster slot until the pick is made.

Great reasoning. The debate for me is whether Garrard will be worth more immediately than Jackson. If Garrard doesn't top 12 points in either of the next two games, I can stash him next season. I think he has great value to a team that wants to stash a starting QB with experience. I think my league is less likely to get excited about jackson, even if he is named the starter. My league is not full of guys that know the deep sleepers. They just know the sleepers, and I don't know if Jackson hits that mark unless he really takes off in the next two games.Last few minutes... debating the upside of jackson v. the greater certainy of Garrard.

 

[Biabreakable]

You know your league best so follow that just like you would ADP.

Guess it kind of depends on if your open bidding for players or blind or waiver priority too.

Honestly I am not sure what Jaxonville is going to do. Go back to Leftwich or keep Garrard. Maybe I missed this as I have not been tracking that situation very closely.

 

[EBF]

Aim for underrated guys with good talent. Some candidates: Tarvaris Jackson, Marcedes Lewis, Derek Hagan, and Ryan Moats.

I think all four have a chance to become solid FF players in the right situation. Moats and Hagan are a bit risky, but Jackson and Lewis should increase in value very soon.

 

[EBF]

The now-forgotten TJ Duckett is a UFA and could conceivably end up in a good situation (maybe a thunder part of a thunder and lightning). While an underperformer, he still has some skills.

I've always thought this guy was a bum. There are probably 10-15 backups RBs that I'd rather have. I doubt Duckett ever becomes a starter.

 

[BigTex]

My Dynasty Rankings should help answer this question.

I would do Turner, Marshall, Schaub, Jackson as the top 4 in that order.

Hello Bloom,I notice you have Marshall ranked higher the K. Curtis. What is your thought process behind this?

 

[zamboni]

The now-forgotten TJ Duckett is a UFA and could conceivably end up in a good situation (maybe a thunder part of a thunder and lightning). While an underperformer, he still has some skills.

Duckett has pretty much been a bust but yes he should get another shot with another team.If he gets beaten out again I think thats it for him though and he will forever be a backup/COP Rb.I just had a nightmare thought as a DeAngelo Williams owner though.. as Carolina has shown an interest in the big Rb.. I expect Williams would beat Duckett out anyways but it would be nice to not have the RBBC.What other teams do you think might pursue him?The Steelers were rumored to have an interest in him. I don't know if that is true or not. Parker has done very well in the mean time.Who else?Also I think its important to point out that although Duckett is a bigger Rb he has not shown the power that one might expect for a Rb his size. He does have some good stright line speed though.

I don't disagree - Duckett seems to be one of those guys that hangs around but is viewed as a worthless bum, a la Ron Dayne. And now Dayne is producing, so you never know with a guy like Duckett if he gets in the right situation. I wouldn't hitch my hopes on Duckett, but I wouldn't take my eye off him either.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

My Dynasty Rankings should help answer this question.

I would do Turner, Marshall, Schaub, Jackson as the top 4 in that order.

Hello Bloom,I notice you have Marshall ranked higher the K. Curtis. What is your thought process behind this?

Biggest reasons, but not limited to:1) Im not sure Curtis will ever start in the NFL. Marshall should start at some point next year, and could easily be starter on opening day opposite Javon Walker.

2) Marshall is big and strong, but is also quick and fast for such a big guy. He can be used in just about all facets of the passing game. Curtis is very fast and dangerous after the catch, but he's small and best suited to be a slot receiver - used on deep routes and short routes that get him the ball in space.

3) Curtis is 28, Marshall is 22.

 

[BigTex]

My Dynasty Rankings should help answer this question.

I would do Turner, Marshall, Schaub, Jackson as the top 4 in that order.

Hello Bloom,I notice you have Marshall ranked higher the K. Curtis. What is your thought process behind this?

Biggest reasons, but not limited to:1) Im not sure Curtis will ever start in the NFL. Marshall should start at some point next year, and could easily be starter on opening day opposite Javon Walker.

2) Marshall is big and strong, but is also quick and fast for such a big guy. He can be used in just about all facets of the passing game. Curtis is very fast and dangerous after the catch, but he's small and best suited to be a slot receiver - used on deep routes and short routes that get him the ball in space.

3) Curtis is 28, Marshall is 22.

Thanks for the reply.

 

[messinwithu]

Hey Bloom,

Thanks for keeping the Dyanasty rankings updated all year

Since the season is over or really close to over now when do you plan to add the rookies into the dynasty rankings? I know that it will be different depending on the draft but it would be helpful to see where you think Peterson and Lynch (and other RB's and WR's) rank overall and what kind of players could be traded for the 1st or 2nd overall picks.

Thanks again

 

[Renegades of Funk]

Which of these three guys would you take a flyer on for next year:

Earnest Graham

Artose Pinner

Eric Shelton

 

[gheemony]

Final results are in! Here is who I landed:

1. Michael Turner - outbid one other team.

2. Matt Schaub - I like that he'll either have a job or not, so it is easy to decide whether to roster him next season.

3. Tarvaris Jackson - Yep, he narrowly edged out Garrard. We have interesting rule that says that if a QB scores 12 points in 5 or more games, he is no longer eligible for the practice squad. Garrad needs one more game like that this season. So I decided to play it safe with Jackson. I am hoping that he lights it up the next two games and I can sell him for a high price in the offseason. The next runner-up was Bloom's favorite - Brandon Marshall. I just couldn't justify another WR on my roster. I am hoping he finishes quietly and I can buy him at the free agent auction.

4. Kris Wilson - My cap space was limited to bidding on a TE for the fourth spot. I got outbid for Tony Scheffler. Darn. In hindsight, I could have bid less for Turner and gotten Scheffler, but I didn't want to risk losing out on Turner. I have Gonzo, so Wilson is nice safety valve if Gonzo leaves.

Thanks to everyone that chimed in with advice!

 

[gheemony]

Ugh. Not liking the Jackson pick right now. Watch Brandon Marshall have a great game this weekend. Oh well.

 

[Ron_Mexico]

Which of these three guys would you take a flyer on for next year:Earnest GrahamArtose PinnerEric Shelton

1. Pinner2. Shelton3. Graham