Dynasty Market - Elite QBs (1 Viewer)

[Jeff Pasquino]

You know the names - Brees, Rodgers, Peyton, Brady - feel free to include other "elites" - what's the going rate that you are seeing these days?

Feel free to mention the details or even a link to the league, but the only part that I ask is that they be Keeper / Dynasty leagues and that they are REAL transactions. Scoring style (PPR/non-PPR), league size (10, 12, 14, 16 teams) and any other quirks might be good inclusions as well.

 

[dmac37]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

 

[one time]

I completed this trade a few weeks ago:

A gave up Schaub, Matt HOU QB;McFadden, Darren OAK RB; Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from A;Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from C

B gave up Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB;Stewart, Jonathan CAR RB

A was the league champ and C was middle of the pack(14 team league) just as a small indicator of the future picks

 

[Hendo]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

nope

 

[dmac37]

I completed this trade a few weeks ago:A gave up Schaub, Matt HOU QB;McFadden, Darren OAK RB; Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from A;Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from CB gave up Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB;Stewart, Jonathan CAR RBA was the league champ and C was middle of the pack(14 team league) just as a small indicator of the future picks

I hope you got the Rodgers & J Stew part of the deal, seems like a steal to me.Rodgers > SchaubStew >>> than D Mac + picks

 

[FreeBaGeL]

I completed this trade a few weeks ago:A gave up Schaub, Matt HOU QB;McFadden, Darren OAK RB; Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from A;Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from CB gave up Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB;Stewart, Jonathan CAR RBA was the league champ and C was middle of the pack(14 team league) just as a small indicator of the future picks

Wow...What was team B thinking. They lose in every part of the deal, that makes no sense.

 

[Tanner9919]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

nope

:( yeah ok..Schaub is in the `elite` class, without a doubt. Check his numbers over the past two seasons, he's every bit a fantasy stud as Aaron Rodgers is.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

Zealots league:

Big Ben/Vilma for 2010 1st (2nd overall)/2011 2nd rookie picks

Team getting picks is in complete rebuild mode

 

[Buddy Ball 2K3]

Here are the trades from our 12 team keeper league that involved top flight QB's at the time. Basically teams were not trading what they perceived to be a top QB unless they were getting one in return.

Rules: Points for TD's are based on length - Non PPR - Only Bonus Points at Yardage bench marks (100, 200, 300 etc)

* Team 3 gave up Manning, Peyton IND QB;Edwards, Braylon (Browns at the time) WR

* Team 4 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB;Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR

* Team 2 gave up Manning, Eli NYG QB;Jones, Julius SEA RB

* Team 1 gave up Turner, Michael ATL RB; Year 2010 Round 5 Draft Pick from Team 1

* Team 1 gave up Brees, Drew NOS QB;Jones, Felix DAL RB;Bennett, Earl CHI WR; Year 2010 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team 1

* Team 3 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB;McCoy, LeSean PHI RB;Boldin, Anquan ARI WR

* Team1 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB

* Team2 gave up Rivers, Philip SDC QB; Year 2010 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team 2

 

[Happy Ragnarok]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

nope

Do you people just not like the Texans' uniforms or something? 4770/29 is what, third tier?

 

[Colts Win]

I completed this trade a few weeks ago:A gave up Schaub, Matt HOU QB;McFadden, Darren OAK RB; Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from A;Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from CB gave up Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB;Stewart, Jonathan CAR RBA was the league champ and C was middle of the pack(14 team league) just as a small indicator of the future picks

Team B got smashed.

 

[Colts Win]

Here are the trades from our 12 team keeper league that involved top flight QB's at the time. Basically teams were not trading what they perceived to be a top QB unless they were getting one in return.

Rules: Points for TD's are based on length - Non PPR - Only Bonus Points at Yardage bench marks (100, 200, 300 etc)

* Team 3 gave up Manning, Peyton IND QB;Edwards, Braylon (Browns at the time) WR

* Team 4 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB;Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR

* Team 2 gave up Manning, Eli NYG QB;Jones, Julius SEA RB

* Team 1 gave up Turner, Michael ATL RB; Year 2010 Round 5 Draft Pick from Team 1

* Team 1 gave up Brees, Drew NOS QB;Jones, Felix DAL RB;Bennett, Earl CHI WR; Year 2010 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team 1

* Team 3 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB;McCoy, LeSean PHI RB;Boldin, Anquan ARI WR

* Team1 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB

* Team2 gave up Rivers, Philip SDC QB; Year 2010 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team 2

When was this trade? I would think Rivers has move value than Brady right now.

 

[Black]

I completed this trade a few weeks ago:A gave up Schaub, Matt HOU QB;McFadden, Darren OAK RB; Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from A;Year 2011 Round 1 Draft Pick from CB gave up Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB;Stewart, Jonathan CAR RBA was the league champ and C was middle of the pack(14 team league) just as a small indicator of the future picks

Wow...What was team B thinking. They lose in every part of the deal, that makes no sense.

I was a bit confused about the ABC stuff, but regardless, whoever got Rodgers and Stew scored.Earlier this year, it looked like Eli was hot with his new receivers, Lynch was about to resurface and 'take over' the job in BUF, and A. Rodgers might die behind his swiss cheese GB line. The other team had Favre, McNabb, and Rodgers and was desperate for a young, starting RB.I gutted my RB and traded Lynch (and Eli) for Rodgers, sort of punting for 2009, but still ended up in the Superbowl with a mish-mash of RBs (and got hammered).Now I need to see what I can get for Brady...I probably have to wait for him to get healthy and put up some good games to get any real value.

 

[Buddy Ball 2K3]

Here are the trades from our 12 team keeper league that involved top flight QB's at the time. Basically teams were not trading what they perceived to be a top QB unless they were getting one in return.

Rules: Points for TD's are based on length - Non PPR - Only Bonus Points at Yardage bench marks (100, 200, 300 etc)

* Team 3 gave up Manning, Peyton IND QB;Edwards, Braylon (Browns at the time) WR

* Team 4 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB;Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR

* Team 2 gave up Manning, Eli NYG QB;Jones, Julius SEA RB

* Team 1 gave up Turner, Michael ATL RB; Year 2010 Round 5 Draft Pick from Team 1

* Team 1 gave up Brees, Drew NOS QB;Jones, Felix DAL RB;Bennett, Earl CHI WR; Year 2010 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team 1

* Team 3 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB;McCoy, LeSean PHI RB;Boldin, Anquan ARI WR

* Team1 gave up Brady, Tom NEP QB

* Team2 gave up Rivers, Philip SDC QB; Year 2010 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team 2

When was this trade? I would think Rivers has move value than Brady right now.

It was in week 8. Team 2 was making a play off run and thought that Brady would do better down the stretch.

 

[Titus Pullo]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

nope

yeah ok..Schaub is in the `elite` class, without a doubt. Check his numbers over the past two seasons, he's every bit a fantasy stud as Aaron Rodgers is.

no he's not. over the past two years rodgers scored 779 points and schaub scored 586.

 

[thevidon]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

nope

yeah ok..Schaub is in the `elite` class, without a doubt. Check his numbers over the past two seasons, he's every bit a fantasy stud as Aaron Rodgers is.

no he's not. over the past two years rodgers scored 779 points and schaub scored 586.

Their points per game average would be a MUCH better indicator considering Schaubs injuries last year.

 

[Titus Pullo]

Does Schaub qualify as an elite QB? I'm thinking he is.

nope

yeah ok..Schaub is in the `elite` class, without a doubt. Check his numbers over the past two seasons, he's every bit a fantasy stud as Aaron Rodgers is.

no he's not. over the past two years rodgers scored 779 points and schaub scored 586.

Their points per game average would be a MUCH better indicator considering Schaubs injuries last year.

break it down how ever you want. in 3 years as a starter schaub has only played in all 16 once and missed 5 games twice. if you guys want to believe schaub is elite and should fetch the same price as rodgers then good luck with that because he won't.

 

[Titus Pullo]

on the flip side, if people think schaub is elite then they should go after him instead of rodgers since the price should most definitely be cheaper.

 

[purplehaze67]

Just got offered this in a ZF dynasty league. I'll accept as soon as I get home, since MFL is blocked at work:

I get: Brees, McGaghee, Mason, Will Smith

I give: Josh Freeman, Mendenhall

 

[AcerFC]

I traded Manning and my 1st in HA2 for Bowe.

Not the best deal but I needed a WR and was hoping to make playoffs. I didnt

 

[VaCatFan]

I traded Manning and my 1st in HA2 for Bowe.Not the best deal but I needed a WR and was hoping to make playoffs. I didnt

Eli hopefully.

 

[AcerFC]

I traded Manning and my 1st in HA2 for Bowe.Not the best deal but I needed a WR and was hoping to make playoffs. I didnt

Eli hopefully.

No. Have Rivers and Cassel as my other QBs. I got lucky S Rice had a good year otherwise my second best WR was either J Knox or R Williams. Had to make a move. No one else was selling WRs.

 

[Spike]

Zealots league.

I was offered Carson Palmer and Calvin Johnson for Aaron Rodgers and Hakeem Nicks.

I had to turn it down because Rodgers is my only viable QB and I won't go into a season with Palmer as my only startable QB.

 

[odon]

i traded shcaub(also have P. manning) aj hawk, and dimitreus williams

for

hassalebeck, dewayne Bowe, and 1st round pick in 2011

i think this is good value for schaub.

 

[NeverEnough]

I've been thinking about moving Brees & trying to get Rivers in return. We get 3 pts per passing TD. I'm still on the fence asd to whether or not now is the time to move him or if I should ride him for another year.