Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
[DYNASTY] Peytons trade value (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter fbgnewby
- Start date
kellumsboys
Footballguy
the only players more valueble than Peyton Manning in a dynasty league are LT and LJ.
I would have to get a top 10 RB in his place.
Alexander (healthy)
Portis
S. Jackson
R. Brown
I would have to get a top 10 RB in his place.
Alexander (healthy)
Portis
S. Jackson
R. Brown
Limp Dogg Bizkits
Footballguy
T
trader jake
Guest
I wouldn't trade Peyton Manning in a dynasty unless I received LT or some ridiculous offer back in return.
In your situation...trade Matt Leinart. There is little risk with Peyton and you'll still receive solid value for Leinart.
In your situation...trade Matt Leinart. There is little risk with Peyton and you'll still receive solid value for Leinart.
RustyFA
Footballguy
I have Manning in a dynasty league. I would have to get Ronnie Brown and Chad Johnson for him. I would have to get LJ and a top 5 rookie pick for him. I would have to get Eli Manning and Rudi Johnson and Darrel Jackson for him and a low low 1st rookie pick. I would have to get Reggie Bush and Vick and the #1 overall rookie pick for Manning and the 8th plus pick.
Manning is pure gold. Build your team around him. Have a down season or two and improve your team through the draft. Don't trade him unless you get a GREAT deal for young players.
Manning is pure gold. Build your team around him. Have a down season or two and improve your team through the draft. Don't trade him unless you get a GREAT deal for young players.
Super King
Footballguy
same here. i dont own him, but my buddy does, he says hes untradable. hes a keystone.
redman
Footballguy
How would you rate McNabb compared with Manning? The only edge that I can think of that Manning has over McNabb is durability.
Snotbubbles
Footballguy
Last week I offered McNabb straight up for him and got turned down.
I think asking for a top 10 RB and a top WR is a little steep for a QB.
I think asking for a top 10 RB and a top WR is a little steep for a QB.
Mapmaker
Footballguy
I picked Manning up a couple weeks ago in my dynasty league from an owner that had a pretty poor team aside from Manning that is ... I gave up Pennington, Kellen Clemens, Vince Young, Jones-Drew, Chris Chambers, Hinse Ward, Bo Scaife, D'Qwell Jackson .. in return I got Manning, Jim Sorgi, Thomas Jones, Braylon Edwards, LJ Smith, and a 3rd round rookie pick in a 14 team IDP league.
Manning fits right in with LT on my squad, it's just a shame I haven't got to start him yet since last week the trade didn't go down till just around kick-off and this week I started Bulgar .. Manning outscored Bulgar this week in my league by 2.4 pts so no big deal!
Manning fits right in with LT on my squad, it's just a shame I haven't got to start him yet since last week the trade didn't go down till just around kick-off and this week I started Bulgar .. Manning outscored Bulgar this week in my league by 2.4 pts so no big deal!
Disco Stu
Confirmed FBGal
Agreed. A good QB (Bulger, Hass, etc) along with a good RB or WR should be enough IMO.
Earlier this season (maybe in the preseason) this trade went down in one of my dynasty leagues.
Manning for Westbrook and Ward.
The team that traded Manning also had McNabb and Brady. It is PPR league with .04 points for passing yards, 4 for passing TDs, and -2 for Ints, 3 pts for a 300 yd passing game.
Manning for Westbrook and Ward.
The team that traded Manning also had McNabb and Brady. It is PPR league with .04 points for passing yards, 4 for passing TDs, and -2 for Ints, 3 pts for a 300 yd passing game.
ILoveMyLions
Footballguy
Agreed. I'm in a 2 QB start league and he's even more valuable. He's untradeable unless it's a ridiculous offer...
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
This is ridiculous.
Headed into this week (haven't re-run the numbers after this week's games yet) in my league which is pretty standard scoring for QBs (25yds/point, 4pt TDs) Peyton is averaging...
1 point per game less than Mcnabb per game
1.5 points per game more than Vick per game
4 points more than Mcnabb per game
5.5 points more than Brady per game
6 points more than Eli per game
Meanwhile LT is averaging...
5 points more than Westbrook
7 points more than Ahman
And everyone else is behind that. 15th round guys like Kitna/Grossman are closer to Peyton in ppg than any of the other running backs are to LT/LJ.
LT and LJ both blew up this week so I'd imagine they've seperated themselves even more now if I included those numbers. Mentioning Peyton in the same breath as those two guys is a joke (this coming from a huge fan of what Peyton does in real life - just go check any of the countless Manning/Brady arguments that have come up the last few years). I realize that Peyton provides a certain level of certainty from year to year but at this point LT/LJ provide the same. That's not even to mention that we're talking RB vs. QB here and position scarcity just flat out makes mentioning them in the same sentence an utter and dispicable joke.
He's a quarterback, and this is fantasy football.
Headed into this week (haven't re-run the numbers after this week's games yet) in my league which is pretty standard scoring for QBs (25yds/point, 4pt TDs) Peyton is averaging...
1 point per game less than Mcnabb per game
1.5 points per game more than Vick per game
4 points more than Mcnabb per game
5.5 points more than Brady per game
6 points more than Eli per game
Meanwhile LT is averaging...
5 points more than Westbrook
7 points more than Ahman
And everyone else is behind that. 15th round guys like Kitna/Grossman are closer to Peyton in ppg than any of the other running backs are to LT/LJ.
LT and LJ both blew up this week so I'd imagine they've seperated themselves even more now if I included those numbers. Mentioning Peyton in the same breath as those two guys is a joke (this coming from a huge fan of what Peyton does in real life - just go check any of the countless Manning/Brady arguments that have come up the last few years). I realize that Peyton provides a certain level of certainty from year to year but at this point LT/LJ provide the same. That's not even to mention that we're talking RB vs. QB here and position scarcity just flat out makes mentioning them in the same sentence an utter and dispicable joke.
He's a quarterback, and this is fantasy football.
Last edited by a moderator:
In a start 2QB dynasty he would be the most valuable player in the league. I wouldn't trade him for LT or LJ. Edit: At least, not straight up unless I had some dang good QB's to take his place.
Last edited by a moderator:
T
trader jake
Guest
An in a dynasty league Peyton Manning will be an elite QB for the next five seasons. LT and LJ are monsters right now but neither is likely to be a primary ball carrier for an NFL team in 5 years...that's just how RB's go. I wouldn't blame a Manning owner for trading him straight up for either of those two players but any other player you can name is laughable straight up for Peyton Manning.
Team Legacy
Footballguy
Terrible trade for you. Sorry. You have to account for how many years RBs play in this league. Peyton will play every game and be there for AT LEAST 5 more years. The average lifespan of a RB is much less.
ninerfan
Footballguy
Traded for Manning this weekend. I gave Bulger, Tatum Bell, Brandon Jacobs for Manning and 1st round pick in 2007 (his team is 1-8 and the pick should be number 1 or 2. Could net Peterson, Lynch, etc.) I still have Kevin Jones, Julius Jones and Frank Gore as my RB's. I'm pretty happy about the deal.
That's a freakin heist. I think it's a solid trade without the 1st. The first makes it highway robbery.
