Tick
Footballguy
1 - Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts
2 - Carson Palmer Cincy Bengals
3 - Tom Brady New England Patriots
4 - McNabb Philadelphia Eagles
5 - Eli Manning New York Football Giants
6 - Marc Bulger St. Louis Rams
7 - Daunte Culpepper Minnesota Vikings
8 - Michael Vick Atlanta Falcons
9 - Drew Brees San Diego Chargers
10 - Ben Roethlisberger Pittsburgh Steelers
11 - Matt Hasselbeck Seattle Seahawks
12 - Byron Leftwich Jacksonville Jaguars
13 - Jake Delhomme Carolina Panthers
14 - Jake Plummer Denver Broncos
15 - Matt Leinart
16 - Charlie Frye Cleveland Browns
17 - Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers
18 - Trent Green
19 - David Carr
20 - Vince Young
21 - Rex Grossman
22t - Kyle Boller
22t - Chris Simms
24 - JP Losman
25 - Aaron Brooks
26 - David Garrard
27 - Alex Smith
Who is #28?
If you vote other, please specify.
Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round.
(note: Orton, Harrington, Warner, and Ramsey to be added in sometime soon. Kerry Collins and Omar Jacobs to reappear soon - they got 0 votes)
Final results:
Brian Griese [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Drew Bledsoe [ 6 ] [13.64%]
Matt Schaub [ 7 ] [15.91%]
Jason Campbell [ 8 ] [18.18%]
Aaron Rodgers [ 5 ] [11.36%]
Billy Volek [ 5 ] [11.36%]
Kerry Collins [ 4 ] [9.09%]
Steve McNair [ 5 ] [11.36%]
Jay Cutler [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Chad Pennington [ 0 ] [0.00%]
Brett Favre [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Other [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Campbell wins. Pennington comes off the list next round.
2 - Carson Palmer Cincy Bengals
3 - Tom Brady New England Patriots
4 - McNabb Philadelphia Eagles
5 - Eli Manning New York Football Giants
6 - Marc Bulger St. Louis Rams
7 - Daunte Culpepper Minnesota Vikings
8 - Michael Vick Atlanta Falcons
9 - Drew Brees San Diego Chargers
10 - Ben Roethlisberger Pittsburgh Steelers
11 - Matt Hasselbeck Seattle Seahawks
12 - Byron Leftwich Jacksonville Jaguars
13 - Jake Delhomme Carolina Panthers
14 - Jake Plummer Denver Broncos
15 - Matt Leinart
16 - Charlie Frye Cleveland Browns
17 - Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers
18 - Trent Green
19 - David Carr
20 - Vince Young
21 - Rex Grossman
22t - Kyle Boller
22t - Chris Simms
24 - JP Losman
25 - Aaron Brooks
26 - David Garrard
27 - Alex Smith
Who is #28?
If you vote other, please specify.
Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round.
(note: Orton, Harrington, Warner, and Ramsey to be added in sometime soon. Kerry Collins and Omar Jacobs to reappear soon - they got 0 votes)
Final results:
Brian Griese [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Drew Bledsoe [ 6 ] [13.64%]
Matt Schaub [ 7 ] [15.91%]
Jason Campbell [ 8 ] [18.18%]
Aaron Rodgers [ 5 ] [11.36%]
Billy Volek [ 5 ] [11.36%]
Kerry Collins [ 4 ] [9.09%]
Steve McNair [ 5 ] [11.36%]
Jay Cutler [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Chad Pennington [ 0 ] [0.00%]
Brett Favre [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Other [ 1 ] [2.27%]
Campbell wins. Pennington comes off the list next round.
Last edited by a moderator:
