Dynasty Qb #6 Ranking (1 Viewer)

[Biabreakable]

These are consensus dynasty rankings for year 2007

If you vote other, please specify.

Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round.

I like the chatter lets keep that going as we vote.

Link to poll #5 http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=292482

1. Peyton Manning

2. Carson Palmer

3. Tom Brady

4. Drew Brees

5. Donovan McNabb

6. Matt Hasselbeck

Link to poll #7 http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=292933

 

[mlball77]

I like Hass here... a healthy Hass, with the running game a little bit stronger should equal a better passing game going forward, imho.

 

[wannabee]

Hass, Leinart, and Romo for me here and chose Hass

 

[onionsack]

Brett Favre

 

[broncofan13000]

Hass, Leinart, and Romo for me here and chose Hass

went with Hass as well. I think this time next year, Leinart will move up to this position.

 

[zoonation]

Hass is overrated. Went romo...notng but upside and tons of weapons.

 

[FunkyPlutos]

Hass and I don't think it is close!

 

[norton17]

I went Rivers due to his big age advantage over Hasselbeck.

 

[Jeff Pasquino]

Too much love for Rivers, not enough for Vick....

 

[Blackjacks]

I know Eli looked like junk lately but I'll still take him here. With Tiki gone next year he'll be throwing even more. Also give him Toomer and S. MOss healthy for a year and it can only help.

 

[GrandpaRox]

Since these are dynasty rankings all I have to do is see what QBs I have on my rosters and look at who I am starting over who.

I have Hass, Rivers, Romo, Bulger, Grossman, Favre, Leinart and Alex Smith on one or another of my rosters.

Based on who I have and who I start of these QBs I would hands down select Romo, he is starting in 4 of my leagues this weekend.

The other 2 that I would consider are Vick and Young because of their athletic abilities.

But based on the fact that Romo has been able to shut up TO and no other QB has been able to do that, I have to go with Romo, but would understand Vick at this point.

Do you realize the enormity of the fact that Romo has been able to shut up TO, that is huge, everything Dallas has been Romo and TO has not raised a blip, that says a lot.

Of course he could crash and burn against the Giants, but he seems to have "it". We shall see.

I think Eli and Roth are way overrated as dynasty QBs and well Grossman is ummmm not good at all.

 

[tikitime]

Since these are dynasty rankings all I have to do is see what QBs I have on my rosters and look at who I am starting over who.

I have Hass, Rivers, Romo, Bulger, Grossman, Favre, Leinart and Alex Smith on one or another of my rosters.

Based on who I have and who I start of these QBs I would hands down select Romo, he is starting in 4 of my leagues this weekend.

The other 2 that I would consider are Vick and Young because of their athletic abilities.



But based on the fact that Romo has been able to shut up TO and no other QB has been able to do that, I have to go with Romo, but would understand Vick at this point.

Do you realize the enormity of the fact that Romo has been able to shut up TO, that is huge, everything Dallas has been Romo and TO has not raised a blip, that says a lot.

Of course he could crash and burn against the Giants, but he seems to have "it". We shall see.

I think Eli and Roth are way overrated as dynasty QBs and well Grossman is ummmm not good at all.

Can you say honeymoon period?Ask Garcia and Mcnabb what yr 2 of TO was like as opposed to year 1.

 

[-OZ-]

Since these are dynasty rankings all I have to do is see what QBs I have on my rosters and look at who I am starting over who.

I have Hass, Rivers, Romo, Bulger, Grossman, Favre, Leinart and Alex Smith on one or another of my rosters.

Based on who I have and who I start of these QBs I would hands down select Romo, he is starting in 4 of my leagues this weekend.

The other 2 that I would consider are Vick and Young because of their athletic abilities.



But based on the fact that Romo has been able to shut up TO and no other QB has been able to do that, I have to go with Romo, but would understand Vick at this point.

Do you realize the enormity of the fact that Romo has been able to shut up TO, that is huge, everything Dallas has been Romo and TO has not raised a blip, that says a lot.

Of course he could crash and burn against the Giants, but he seems to have "it". We shall see.

I think Eli and Roth are way overrated as dynasty QBs and well Grossman is ummmm not good at all.

Can you say honeymoon period?Ask Garcia and Mcnabb what yr 2 of TO was like as opposed to year 1.

How much controversy was there in Philly his first year?

 

[Tornacl]

I went with Rivers over Hasselbeck. I know that Hasselbeck has proven himself more and over a longer time period, but I chose Rivers because of his age and how well he has played in his first year.

 

[beto]

Hass for me. On the strength of playing for Holmgren.

 

[Ariakis]

I think it has to be Romo although I could understand Vick but noone else. Rivers and others have upside but I see Romo being more likely to produce consistantly. Jerry Jones will always surround him with talent. While Glenn and TO are getting up there, his RB's, Witten, and Crayton are young and so is that defense.

 

[Tick]

Strange to see how few votes Eli is getting here...