Dynasty RB #3 (1 Viewer)

[JuSt CuZ]

1. Adrian Peterson 3/21/85 --- 69.5% (MJD 13%)

2. Maurice Jones-Drew 3/23/85 --- 46.6% (SJax 27%)

3. Steven Jackson 7/22/83 --- 47.2% (CJ 17%)

CLOSED

 

[gonzobill5]

Here's the career carries for these guys, thought it would be helpful

Matt Forte 12/10/85 316

Michael Turner 2/13/82 605

Marion Barber 6/10/83 715

Steven Jackson 7/22/83 1225

Frank Gore 5/14/83 939

Brian Westbrook 9/2/79 1247

LaDanian Tomlinson 6/23/79 2657

Chris Johnson 9/23/85 251

DeAngelo Williams 4/25/83 539

Clinton Portis 9/1/81 2052

BTW, shouldn't Slaton deserve a spot? I believe he'd be the youngest on the list, had 50 receptions, 1600 total yards and 10 total TDs. I know everyone likes to think that houston adds another RB, but I'd rate him neck and neck with forte, slightly below chris johnson, and way ahead of clinton portis in dynasty.

 

[Faulk-U]

I voted SJAX here.

Soon you can add Ronnie Brown to this list.

 

[The Barber]

I voted SJAX here.Soon you can add Ronnie Brown to this list.

I agree, in a dynasty I'd vote Rock'n Ronnie before I'd vote for LT or Portis.

 

[•TheRealMcCoy]

I personally would say AP than SJ than probably Chris Johnson? MJD is right there in the top 4 or 5!! But I have to see him an entire season w/o Taylor? And the question may be asked why CJ3 than? Hes younger and faster and kills in PPR! I agree, wheres RONNIE!!

 

[travdogg]

I voted CJ3. I just have way too many questions about Jackson's durability.

 

[Whiplash Inc.]

Forte

 

[Buffaloes]

I voted CJ3. I just have way too many questions about Jackson's durability.

I think CJ3 might be used more as a receiving threat than he was as a rookie too.

 

[ratbast]

Wow. Surprising to see the lack of standouts. this tier is obviously deep.

 

[ratbast]

Here's the career carries for these guys, thought it would be helpfulMatt Forte 12/10/85 316Michael Turner 2/13/82 605 Marion Barber 6/10/83 715Steven Jackson 7/22/83 1225Frank Gore 5/14/83 939Brian Westbrook 9/2/79 1247 LaDanian Tomlinson 6/23/79 2657 Chris Johnson 9/23/85 251DeAngelo Williams 4/25/83 539 Clinton Portis 9/1/81 2052 BTW, shouldn't Slaton deserve a spot? I believe he'd be the youngest on the list, had 50 receptions, 1600 total yards and 10 total TDs. I know everyone likes to think that houston adds another RB, but I'd rate him neck and neck with forte, slightly below chris johnson, and way ahead of clinton portis in dynasty.

I voted for SJax. After reading this I think I would have given Turner the nod.I think Stewart needs to be on this list.

 

[Sweet Love]

Here's the career carries for these guys, thought it would be helpfulMatt Forte 12/10/85 316Michael Turner 2/13/82 605 Marion Barber 6/10/83 715Steven Jackson 7/22/83 1225Frank Gore 5/14/83 939Brian Westbrook 9/2/79 1247 LaDanian Tomlinson 6/23/79 2657 Chris Johnson 9/23/85 251DeAngelo Williams 4/25/83 539 Clinton Portis 9/1/81 2052 BTW, shouldn't Slaton deserve a spot? I believe he'd be the youngest on the list, had 50 receptions, 1600 total yards and 10 total TDs. I know everyone likes to think that houston adds another RB, but I'd rate him neck and neck with forte, slightly below chris johnson, and way ahead of clinton portis in dynasty.

Good info Gonzo...I love the fact MBIII has had only 715 carries...everyone makes him seem like he is one year away from being a "29-year old Eddie George"...

 

[KellysHeroes]

I voted SJAX here.Soon you can add Ronnie Brown to this list.

MB3 before Jackson