[DYNASTY] RB #48 (1 Viewer)

[Tick]

1 - Tomlinson San Diego Chargers

2 - Shaun Alexander Seattle Seahawks

3- Larry Johnson Kansas City Chiefs

4 - EDGE Indianapolis Colts

5 - Steven Jackson St. Louis Rams

6 - Willis McGahee Buffalo Bills

7 - Clinton Portis, Washington Redskins

8 - Lamont Jordan, Oakland Raiders

Links to 7 and the Run-off

9 - Caddillac Williams Tampa Bay Bucs

10 - Ronnie Brown Miami Dolphins

11 - Kevin Jones Detroit Lions

12 - Deuce New Orleans Saints

13 - Brian Westbrook Philadelphia Eagles

14 - Reggie Bush Houston Jets Who knows?

15 - Tiki Barber New York Giants

16 - Dom Davis Houston Texans

17 - Rudi Johnson Cincinati Bengals

18 - Julius Jones Dallas Cowboys

19 - Jamal Lewis Baltimore Ravens

20 - Cedric Benson Chicago Bears

21(t) - Chris Brown, Tennessee Titans

21(t) - Deshaun Foster, Carolina Panthers

23 - Tatum Bell, Denver Broncos

24 - DeAngelo Williams, NCAA

25 - Thomas Jones, Chicago Bears

26 - Chris Perry

27 - Reuben Droughns

28 - Warrick Dunn

29 - Ricky Williams

30 - Willie Parker

31 - Corey Dillon

32t - LenDale White

32t - Lawrence Maroney

34 - Frank Gore

35 - Ahman Green

36 - Chester Taylor

37t - TJ Duckett

37t - Samkon Gado

39 - Fred Taylor

40 - JJ Arrington

41 - Mewelde Moore

42 - Greg Jones

43 - Kevan Barlow

44 - Marion Barber 3

45 - Mike Anderson

46 - Ryan Moats

47 - Michael Turner

Who is #48?

Please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round.

Waiting list: Lee Suggs*, Stephen Davis*, Duce Staley*, Maurice Morris, Maurice Hicks, Musa Smith, Nick Goings, William Green

*Removed for a bit for getting 0 votes.

 

[wannabee]

Calhoun

 

[-OZ-]

I'll go with Cedric Houston here, but the talk of the Jets taking a RB in roud one makes me a little nervous.

 

[Tick]

OZ is taking these back over, but I'll give them one last bump.I'm surprised at the lack of concern about Blaylock among the Houston supporters.

 

[Bloom]

Calhoun, and I didnt have to think about it very long. I think Addai and Maurice Drew also at least deserve consideration at this point - and I would want them over some of the guys already listed.I also think that if you started this today, White would rank somewhere in lows 20s, right around Benson.

 

[Tick]

Calhoun, and I didnt have to think about it very long. I think Addai and Maurice Drew also at least deserve consideration at this point - and I would want them over some of the guys already listed.

I also think that if you started this today, White would rank somewhere in lows 20s, right around Benson.

I wish we had listed rookie pick numbers instead of player names. I'd take 1.05 ahead of the guys on this list, but Calhoun might not even declare.

 

[wannabee]

Calhoun, and I didnt have to think about it very long. I think Addai and Maurice Drew also at least deserve consideration at this point - and I would want them over some of the guys already listed.

I also think that if you started this today, White would rank somewhere in lows 20s, right around Benson.

I wish we had listed rookie pick numbers instead of player names. I'd take 1.05 ahead of the guys on this list, but Calhoun might not even declare.

I think he did yesterday, per the thread bearing his name

 

[wannabee]

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...pic=219939&st=0

is the Calhoun thread

 

[Tick]

Ah - I read down through to somebody saying the announcement might come Thursday, then quit reading. Looks like I should have kept going.

 

[-OZ-]

I wish we had listed rookie pick numbers instead of player names. I'd take 1.05 ahead of the guys on this list, but Calhoun might not even declare.

Sure, but that would have to be a complete draft thread. 1.05 may very well be Leinart or Young, not a RB.

 

[Tick]

I wish we had listed rookie pick numbers instead of player names.  I'd take 1.05 ahead of the guys on this list, but Calhoun might not even declare.

Sure, but that would have to be a complete draft thread. 1.05 may very well be Leinart or Young, not a RB.

But at this point, if you're looking at trade value, you're trading for a pick, not a player. Let's say I want to trade away Ricky Williams. What pick can I get in return for him at this point? Let's say I can get 1.05 for him... I'd do it. I don't even know if it's an RB or not at 1.05, but I'd make the trade and see what happens. It's not an option to trade Ricky for Calhoun.No big deal, though - this is a good system whether I quibble about minor details or not.

 

[-OZ-]

I wish we had listed rookie pick numbers instead of player names. I'd take 1.05 ahead of the guys on this list, but Calhoun might not even declare.

Sure, but that would have to be a complete draft thread. 1.05 may very well be Leinart or Young, not a RB.

But at this point, if you're looking at trade value, you're trading for a pick, not a player. Let's say I want to trade away Ricky Williams. What pick can I get in return for him at this point? Let's say I can get 1.05 for him... I'd do it. I don't even know if it's an RB or not at 1.05, but I'd make the trade and see what happens. It's not an option to trade Ricky for Calhoun.No big deal, though - this is a good system whether I quibble about minor details or not.

It's a good discussion, I just think it's best served in another thread - hey, maybe that's where we'll go after we finish the players?