[DYNASTY] RBs rankings (1 Viewer)

[JayMan]

From another thread discussion... I just wanted to gather information on official backup RBs from the FBG Depth Charts as of Week 1 of the '06 NFL season.

Needing to rank these players for [DYNASTY] purposes - and assuming FBG scoring - I ended up with the following list.

Keep in mind that I have listed one and only one backup RB for every NFL team.

TIER 1R. BushL. MaroneyM. TurnerTIER 2C. BensonD. WilliamsJ. NorwoodM. BarberL. WhiteJ. AddaiT. BellC. PerryTIER 3B. JacobsV. MorencyT. DuckettM. DrewJ. HarrisonR. MoatsC. FasonB. CalhounV. HaynesTIER 4M. AndersonM. BennettM. MorrisM. HicksS. GadoTIER 5J. ArringtonS. DavisJ. FargasD. BlaylockM. PittmanT. MinorA. Thomas

Let's discuss...

 

[Armando]

I'd have Benson in Tier 1.

I'd rather own Michael Robinson than Hicks, but perhaps that's just me.

Lendale White would be in my Tier 3 at the highest.

I'd have Fason in Tier 5 with Moore in Tier 3 (regardless of what the current arrangement is).

 

[Restricted]

I'd snip M. Anderson from your Tier 4 and put in Musa Smith in your Tier 3 for Baltimore.

 

[JayMan]

I'd have Benson in Tier 1.I'd rather own Michael Robinson than Hicks, but perhaps that's just me. Lendale White would be in my Tier 3 at the highest.I'd have Fason in Tier 5 with Moore in Tier 3 (regardless of what the current arrangement is).

I'm with you on Michael Robinson (and I think everyone will agree on that)... he would fit nicely in TIER 3...I'm not sure on LenDale so far... he hasn't shown anything (other than poor work ethic) - but the guy has tremendous talent... if (and it's a big if) he puts it all together - he could be special... and this is why I wouldn't mind using a roster spot on him...I finally think the backup RB role in Minnesota is too unclear to figure out a winner...

 

[JayMan]

I'd snip M. Anderson from your Tier 4 and put in Musa Smith in your Tier 3 for Baltimore.

Fair enough - I like Smith's long term potential... I can see someone picking him in front of BCalhoun or CFason for that matter...

 

[broncofan13000]

I think Drew should be higher then Duckett, and Blaylock should move up a tier. He could see just as much action as Barlow...